Dear Sisters,
A woman has to be the one to say this, and it’s time: We females cannot have it every which way at once. Too many of us are trying to. It is hypocritical, it defies logic and it won’t create progress.
Every day brings news of women speaking out courageously against assault, against gender bias and bullying, against body shaming and objectifying, while calling for equal treatment, for professionalism, for “body positivity” and acceptance.
These messages, however, are often muddled. Some of them — as currently practiced — are mutually exclusive.
Had I written this 10 days ago, instead of beginning “Dear Sisters,” I would have addressed myself directly to Jennifer Lopez’s vagina. I’m sure she wouldn’t mind because she certainly put it out there at the Super Bowl. On the Jumbotron.
Empowerment via a stripper pole is just one of the mixed messages I’m puzzling over. You too?
Read More
I first noticed the term “body shaming” in a viral post in 2016, from two young women angry about objections to their strutting around in butt-baring bikinis in front of little children at a public beach. “We won’t be body-shamed!” the girls said.
But the objecting parents were not, in fact, trying to make the girls feel ashamed of their healthy bodies; they were raising questions about when and where revealing those bodies might be inappropriate and disrespectful of others.
Multiply this conflict by a few million. It surfaced some months before the major media made a big, mocking deal, in early 2017, about Vice President Mike Pence’s refusal to dine alone with any woman other than his wife.
A Los Angeles Times columnist wrote, “If professional women and men cannot be alone together, women are the ones who will pay the price.” Experts declared it “gender discrimination.”
The next year brought Brett Kavanaugh’s nomination to the Supreme Court — and the advent of #BelieveWomen. I’d be fascinated to find out if Mr. Pence’s practice is now spreading. Frankly, it should.
If we women must be able to meet alone with male colleagues and must also be believed on any assertion we make about what was said and done at those meetings, well, it’s not women who will “pay the price” — it is men. They’d be crazy to take that risk.
If it’s unlikely a career-ending accusation might ensue, it is already certain that men — and plenty of women — object to such a gross double-standard.
I know, I know — overcorrection is normal. Women have been putting up with unequal treatment since, oh, the beginning of recorded history. But some of today’s pushback is actually cynical manipulation.
Which brings us back to J.Lo’s crotch.
In the first few days after the Super Bowl show, opinions veered between “empowering” and “disgusting.” A Chicago Tribune writer opined that two female performers’ decision to entertain millions with “sexy aplomb” should not prevent us from “tak[ing] women, as a gender, seriously.”
OK, if that performance does not lead to a negative view of all women neither can it claim to create a positive one for all women. But it did. It claimed to be all about female power — through text, neon symbols, a girls’ choir and, apparently, crotch close-ups.
Let’s face it: the “empowerment” talk was just window-dressing for major moneymaking. Both Shakira and J.Lo’s streaming and downloads skyrocketed after the show. They monetized their hoo-has.
If equality is what we’re after, it should be sobering to realize that very few men monetize their genitalia. Those who do are part of a highly specialized, um, industry. They don’t appear on “The Tonight Show” post-performance to weep and talk about empowerment.
If we objectify ourselves, we can’t complain in the next breath about men objectifying us. We can’t demand equal treatment and then insist we are not subject to the same rule of law as men.
If we continue to insist on having it every which way at once, we will have re-earned the old stereotype of women being illogical. This isn’t progress.
ruthanndailey@hotmail.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.