As the impeachment trial of President Donald Trump opened in the U.S. Senate, Adam Schiff, visiting from the House of Representatives, implored the senators to honor the legacy of our wise, if flawed Founding Fathers.

He explained the gravity of impeachment and praised the founders for “insulat[ing] it, as best they could, from the crush of partisan politics.”

He urged the Senate to provide a “fair trial” and to fulfill their duty “to the Constitution and to the rule of law.”

Under all the lofty phrases and grave tone, what Mr. Schiff and his fellow Democrats seem to have forgotten is this: the fallout from the impeachment of Bill Clinton.

Advertise with us

They’ve forgotten that if Americans smell a setup, if they see a cannon being rolled out when a rap on the knuckles would do, their sympathies shift to the accused.

The same national character that shaped our response to the Clinton impeachment will shape how we view this trial and its major players, including Mr. Schiff. Our shared character will also determine how we answer questions raised, perhaps accidentally, by his opening remarks:

Has the impeachment process actually been insulated from partisan politics, as he says the founders hoped? If not, who breached it?

What would a fair trial look like?

What outcome will do more to shore up confidence in our great republic?

Advertise with us

Who has made the greater assault on our Constitution and the rule of law — Mr. Trump or his accusers?

Answers to some of these questions strike me as a draw. Each side has accused the other of putting a ridiculous spin on shifting “facts,” hiding evidence and witnesses, unnecessarily redacting transcripts and so on.

A fair trial will require both sides to honor the same rules, to produce witnesses, to draw back the self-serving veil of secrecy, to allow the accused to face his accuser.

But as to whether the impeachment process has been insulated from partisan politics, the answer is a resounding no, and the responsibility for that breach lies with the Democrats — with Mr. Schiff himself.

Way back in October, even The Washington Post had to address Mr. Schiff’s public lies about his committee not having had prior contact with the whistleblower, about not knowing who he was and more.

Advertise with us

On Wednesday, even as Mr. Schiff opened the Senate trial, Paul Sperry’s detailed report for RealClearInvestigations.com demonstrated anew, in appalling detail, how deeply entwined the whistleblower was with Mr. Schiff and his committee and how the “take-down” engine was already revving in 2017.

This reeks of bad faith, even to those of us who did not vote for Mr. Trump. And unless our partisanship is overwhelming, we Americans tend to judge people’s actions instinctively and pretty fairly. We think the punishment should fit the crime, and we usually hold the person with more knowledge to a higher level of responsibility.

That’s why public sentiment turned in favor of Mr. Clinton. He lied under oath, yes, but he was lying about having cheated on his wife and did so in response to questions that many people felt shouldn’t have been asked in the first place.

Mr. Clinton won only 43% of the popular vote in 1992 and 49% in ’96. Between those races, his party lost Congress to the “Republican Revolution.” But after impeachment, his popularity soared and he left office in 2000 with Gallup approval ratings of 65%.

Similarly, only 46% voted for Mr. Trump in 2016, but in 2018 voters gave only the House back to the Democrats. Now the 2020 elections loom.

Advertise with us

Mr. Schiff knows the law, the rules of Congress and probably the protocols of the presidency far better than Mr. Trump does. The president’s supporters knew this when they voted for him; in fact, this is precisely why he won their support — because he wasn’t part of the self-dealing D.C. swamp whose denizens practice to-the-death politics.

If Mr. Trump’s voters still feel that way, and if independents and centrists feel he’s been railroaded, the Democrats have already lost.

ruthanndailey@hotmail.com