The recent wave of anti-Semitic crimes in the New York City region has set off alarm bells across the nation, and should.
Repercussions have spread many miles away: Rabbi Jeffrey Myers of Pittsburgh’s Tree of Life synagogue reports that congregants were immediately hesitant to put menorahs in their homes’ front windows, for fear of making themselves targets.
For some New Yorkers, the violence has called to mind the wrenching weeks of August 1991, when Brooklyn’s Crown Heights neighborhood erupted after a car driven by a Hasidic Jew struck and killed a 7-year-old black boy.
The aftermath of the Crown Heights tragedy left many dissatisfied, with perceived injustices compounding hurt and loss. Perhaps revisiting those terrible days could shape our response to the challenges of this moment — for there is no doubt the situation is worsening.
After decades of gradual decline, all kinds of hate crimes (racial, religious, ethnic, gender bias, etc.) began rising in 2014. Why then?
When victims are grouped according to religion, there have long been many more crimes against Jews than against any other group (with the glaring exception of the huge surge in anti-Muslim crime in the months following 9/11).
Read More
Anti-Semitic crime spiked in 2017, but as NBC News noted (and The Wall Street Journal, for one, did not), much of it was due to one person — counter-intuitively, an Israeli-American teenager who phoned in dozens of bomb threats against Jewish community centers.
While the Tree of Life massacre and the April 2019 San Diego synagogue slaying were perpetrated by white supremacists, the recent crimes in Jersey City, N.J., and Monsey, N.Y., were committed by African Americans.
The profiles and motives of the criminals, then, are varied, but what they’ve had in common is the internet. Troubled people are finding ideas that few would utter out loud. The ideas attract what becomes a virtual community, whose members stoke one another’s anger and incite, it seems, increasingly deadly crimes.
Crown Heights occurred pre-internet. The hate-filled speech was not digital; it was printed and chanted.
After Gavin Cato was killed by an out-of-control car from a rabbi’s motorcade, false information — of a drunken driver, discriminatory EMTs, biased police treatment — spread quickly via word-of-mouth, the original “social media.”
At the accident scene, hundreds of black teens shouted “Jews! Jews! Jews!” At a protest led by the Rev. Al Sharpton, marchers carried anti-Semitic signs, some chanted “Kill the Jews” and an Israeli flag was burned. Protesters at Lubavitcher headquarters shouted “Heil, Hitler!”
At Gavin Cato’s funeral, near a banner that said, “Hitler did not do the job,” Rev. Sharpton referred to Jews as “diamond dealers.”
And what deeds accompanied these horrifying words? On the first of three days’ rioting, a mob beat and stabbed to death Yankel Rosenbaum, a Jewish doctoral student from Australia. Hundreds of Jewish-owned businesses, homes and cars were vandalized or destroyed.
How close together do speech and actions have to occur before we see cause and effect? And at what point can law enforcement agencies step in to prevent imminent violence?
Even as modern technology has shrunk the world, it has also shrunk the interval between word and deed. A virtual mob can be mustered in moments and lives ruined, or ended.
We face difficult decisions ahead in the struggle to protect free speech while preventing the horrific acts it clearly can lead to. But this battle shouldn’t be waged only with laws. It requires persuasive moral example.
Some years after Crown Heights, Rev. Sharpton began working with Jewish leaders to heal the rift between their communities. New tragedies present a new moment for him to actually confess his past errors and to urge those who admire him or watch his national cable TV show to reach out — as he did — in respect.
And there are people of other races, religions and political persuasions, from Capitol Hill on down, who would serve their country well to follow his lead.
ruthanndailey@hotmail.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.