April showers weren’t just rainfall. Quite a few tears were shed as various critics mourned in advance that the season opener of “Game of Thrones” also foreshadowed the landmark series’ looming finale.
“Is ‘Game of Thrones’ the Last Show We’ll Watch Together?” a Vulture headline worried. No, it isn’t, responded a Vox article, noting that similar fears surfaced at the demise of “Mad Men,” “Breaking Bad,” “Lost,” “The Sopranos” and “Seinfeld.”
I’m old enough to add, “What about ‘Cheers’?” And bemused enough to ask, “Who exactly is ‘we’? How many of us are there, really? And how did you decide which ‘we’ you wanted?”
The audience for any medium — movies, music, magazines, TV — can be measured by size or demographics, and those two metrics are richly related.
Look only at the numbers to start. Last Sunday’s epic GOT episode, “The Long Night,” drew almost 18 million viewers across all platforms. The premiere from three weeks earlier has just reached the 38-million mark because lots of us, despite possible spoilers, watched it days later.
By comparison, 76 million Americans watched the final episode of “Seinfeld” in 1998 — pre-DVR — when the U.S. population was only 276 million.
Read More
“We” have both grown and shrunk. We’ve splintered.
“Event television” comes and goes, as unpredictable as lightning. Ditto for movies and books. So what “we” are the critics referring to or producers of any medium trying to reach?
I watch GOT on-demand so I can fast-forward through gory battle scenes. I did this early on because I’m squeamish; I do it now because axes through skulls are boring.
But I guarantee you plenty of people do not care to see GOT’s explicit sex scenes. The show’s producers obviously decided to discard that demographic group long ago.
If anyone is concerned, then, that we lack common cultural experiences— that we have no event “we all” can enjoy together — such a person ought to be thinking hard about what attracts or excludes consumers. Narrow politics? Foul language? Violence? Religious insensitivity?
Consider Marie Claire, a women’s magazine that publishers presumably hope would appeal to many, many women. In the April edition, between ads for $10,000 handbags and tips on incorporating bike shorts into your office wardrobe, were these articles:
Barack Obama aide Valerie Jarrett’s new book; “The New Face of Power” by Black Lives Matter founder Alicia Garza; profile of Planned Parenthood exec Leana Wen; four pages on five female Democrats running for president in 2020; eight pages on “change-makers” — mostly “Time’s Up” members and their “Woke Group”; five pages on Democrat Stacey Abrams, who lost the 2018 Georgia governor’s race; and a one-page interview with activist/actor Ashley Judd.
This is no longer a women’s magazine; it’s a heavy-handed political tool. If circulation shrinks, or advertisers don’t get results, we might conclude this isn’t a good business model.
There are ways to court a specific demographic without alienating other potential fans. Joanna and Chip Gaines, of HGTV’s “Fixer Upper,” quietly revealed their Christian faith from day one of their five-season show: Joanna quipping that a dead raccoon had “gone to be with the Lord”; Chip geeking out over evangelical author Max Lucado; an artisan dubbing Joanna’s sketchbook “The Book of Jo.”
It was music to my ears, but their goofy charm and rock-solid relationship had broad appeal; “Fixer Upper” was consistently the highest-rated non-news cable TV show. And now they have a product line at Target, a magazine, multiple destination stores and, soon, their own cable channel.
The master of cross-cultural appeal, though, is J.K. Rowling, whose books meld wizards and the “dark arts” with a messianic story-line that millions worldwide devoured simultaneously, from midnight book releases onward.
It is reassuring, even thrilling, to find any common ground “we all” can share. Considering the financial rewards, I can’t understand why more writers, directors, publishers and producers don’t seem to agree.
ruthanndailey@hotmail.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.