Picking through President Donald Trump’s word salad to separate the healthy bits from the spoiled or suspect is a never-ending task, but a necessary one, for citizens of all stripes. Some Ohioans have just found a unique way, though, to make Mr. Trump do it himself.

It would be nice if all verbal fumbling were so easily addressed.

In his Wednesday visit to a Lima, Ohio, factory, the president once again left an audience confused by the murky you’s and they’s, unmoored from antecedents, that mark his speaking style. (The I’s and me’s are clear, and frequent.)

He was trying to pummel both General Motors and local union leaders for closing the Lordstown plant, a theme he’s been hitting hard lately, but his remarks were met with silence.

Advertise with us

He was losing the room, and since blue-collar workers delivered his 2016 Ohio victory over Hillary Clinton, their silence forced him to clarify.

“Your union leaders aren’t on our side. But the people who work there are on our side.”

Rank-and-file versus leadership? That brought cheers.

A Post-Gazette article correctly conveyed Mr. Trump’s clarified distinction, but the headline did not. It claimed he was “tak[ing] on unions,” as opposed to union bosses.

The divide — anywhere — between ineffective or self-serving leaders and their beleaguered underlings (or constituents) is one Mr. Trump has mined from his earliest political days. The resentment that non-elites and outsiders feel toward big shots on Wall Street and Capitol Hill has propelled his political success.

Advertise with us

But he is hardly the first politician to divide voters in order to reorganize them into more supportive coalitions. Barack Obama did it when faced with losing his Democratic majority in Congress in 2010, urging Latino voters to “punish our enemies” come election day. Hillary Clinton attempted it in 2016 with phrases like “basket of deplorables.”

It’s an appeal to identity politics: Us vs. Them. They’re despicable, so vote with us.

Momentarily unsure who President Trump’s “us” and “them” were, though, United Auto Workers members in Ohio didn’t respond until he gave them what they were silently requesting.

Silence helps produce clarity, but we don’t get, or demand, many moments like that in today’s constant clamor.

And that was a relatively easy fix. Mr. Trump’s style, simplistic yet befuddling, is especially ill-suited to emotional and political complexity. Several instances spring to mind:

Advertise with us

During the 2016 campaign, he famously stated, “Russia, if you’re listening, I hope you’re able to find the 30,000 emails that are missing” from former Secretary of State Clinton’s secret private server.

Mr. Trump’s remark has been cited as evidence he was colluding with Russia and defended as cheeky tweaking of the Democrats’ just-launched “Russian meddling” meme.

The timeline supports the pro-Trump position — from the June 2016 discovery of Democratic National Committee email hacks, to FBI Director James Comey’s criticism of Mrs. Clinton on July 5, to Mr. Trump’s July 27 challenge or jest — but his clunky syntax doesn’t help anyone.

And then there are his still-disputed remarks after the deadly Charlottesville riot of August 2017. It is too detailed for this brief space, and for Twitter, but 18 months later, Trump partisans are still pointing out the president’s (typically erratic) effort at clarity and even complexity, the testimony of Twitter feeds and authenticated transcripts — and his opponents’ refusal to acknowledge these facts in their coverage or commentary.

Which position is stronger? Which helps which side? Which ultimately helps the nation? (Answer to the last question: What helps us is whatever is most supported by all the available facts.)

Advertise with us

Quiet skepticism of what’s potentially offensive and careful affirmation of what we can embrace seem to be the best way forward for people of good will.

We can mute the talking heads and read for ourselves, online, the transcripts of virtually any presidential appearance. We can emerge from whatever bubble we inhabit. And with a little quiet reflection, we can decide for ourselves.

Ruth Ann Dailey is a columnist for the Post-Gazette (ruthanndailey@hotmail.com).