During the long uproar surrounding the Affordable Care Act, I referred to it, on a local talk show, as “Obamacare.” The show’s host challenged me, asking whether that term wasn’t perhaps propaganda.
Had I been feeling less congenial just then, I’d have replied that maybe propaganda was embedded in the legislation’s original name — right there in the word “affordable” — but my challenger did make an important point: What we call something usually reveals what we think of it, and if our terms are emotionally or politically loaded, they may hinder our ability to establish facts and think clearly.
“Gag rule” is one of these terms, and this is one of those times.
The Trump administration has written new rules for Title X of the Public Health Act, passed in 1970 to ensure access to family-planning services. The latest change prohibits federal funding to go to clinics that make abortion referrals. But is this really a change to the law? Or is it a change to recent practice?
Critics of the restriction, as The Associated Press noted, call it a “gag rule.” But the AP did not call it that, and no news organization should, outside its opinion section.
Leave that to politicians like Pennsylvania Attorney General Josh Shapiro, who used the term without quote marks in the title of a press release and who claimed “it places unlawful and unethical restrictions on health care professionals, prohibiting them in most instances from providing information or referrals for abortion services.”
Whether these restrictions are unlawful is a matter of contention, hence the lawsuit Mr. Shapiro has decided Pennsylvania will join. And of course, what’s missing from the sentence quoted above is an important part of the truth: Abortion referrals are not allowed only if the clinic wants to receive taxpayer funding.
Maybe this isn’t a fight over free speech. Maybe it’s a fight over money — and subsidized speech.
In 1969, when President Richard Nixon proposed a national effort to provide family-planning services, it capped a decade of tremendous social change. The Food and Drug Administration had approved the birth-control pill in 1960 and intrauterine devices in 1968. Also in ‘68, Paul Ehrlich’s bestseller “The Population Bomb,” stoked fear of mass starvation and other ills due to “over-population.”
In this context, the 1970 legislation that Congress passed — Title X — was called “the Family Planning Services and Population Research Act.”
Also at this time, abortion was still illegal in most circumstances in more than 30 states. And Title X is explicit on this matter: “None of the funds appropriated … shall be used in programs where abortion is a method of family planning.” This was not changed in amendments passed in 1975 — that is, post-Roe v. Wade.
But what exactly is entailed in the words “programs where abortion is a method of family planning”?
Does a doctor or clinic staffer have the right to inform a pregnant client that abortion is a legal option? Does doing so make that family-planning program one “where abortion is a method of family planning”?
If the answer to this last question is yes, it would justify the Trump administration rule that clinics receiving Title X money would not be allowed to make referrals to, or share space with, abortion clinics.
The questions above, and their answers, seem irreconcilable — so long as public money is involved.
The conundrum for anti-abortion voters is that improved and accessible birth control is a major factor in the continuing drop in the nation’s abortion rate. Keeping family planning separate from abortion providers would further allow the huge subset of pro-birth-control pro-lifers to have common ground with pro-choice supporters.
Complexities like these are why it is so critical we choose our terms carefully. Partisan opportunists and all-or-nothing fundraisers may prefer loaded terms and scare tactics, but where the progress is being made is where we use calm, rational terms to discuss our profound conflict.
ruthanndailey@hotmail.com
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.