About 15 years ago, when my higher-ups at the Post-Gazette shifted one of my two weekly “North” columns to the “Local” page, the change was explained this way:

“You are not being promoted because you’re conservative, evangelical and female. Your writing merits this opportunity. But if, in your new position, you were to continue to be conservative, evangelical and female, well, we would not mind at all.”

They were acknowledging, tongue in cheek, a lack of balance in the PG lineup of opinion writers, in terms of politics, religion and gender.

Alienating half your potential customers by relentlessly attacking or dismissing their views is never a good business model, but, given the early-aughts recession and rise of the internet, it was nearly suicide — for both Pittsburgh dailies. PG leaders had the wisdom and survival instincts to shift course. Their effort continues.

Advertise with us

Since representative government cannot flourish without a free and vigorous press, I pray that enough readers understand this. Events of the past few days, however, do not foster optimism.

Hard on the heels of the Covington Catholic High School debacle came the Jussie Smollett travesty. Media coverage of both displayed strong bias and caused real damage. “Empire” actor Jussie Smollett has been charged with a felony for reporting a staged hate-crime to Chicago police. And Covington’s Nick Sandmann has filed a $250 million defamation lawsuit against The Washington Post for inaccurate, “bullying” articles.

Coverage of both stories was overwhelmingly and stubbornly wrong. Assertions were accepted and/​or facts ignored in favor of Trump-supporters-are-racist narratives. Where was the fact-checking? The skepticism? Basic professionalism?

Into this national context came news that editorial director Keith Burris has been named executive editor of the Post-Gazette. Mr. Burris’ academic and professional credentials are impressive, and his (liberal) mentor, John Craig, filled both roles at the PG for 26 years. But the PG’s left-leaning readers are in a frenzy, judging from online comments.

Mr. Burris stressed the need to present balance in the opinion section, neutrality in news coverage and separation of the two. For readers who doubt this is imperative for a newspaper — and for themselves, as citizens — let me share a cautionary tale from the safely distant past:

Advertise with us

In September 2004, I learned at a local Sunday church service that pop star Christina Aguilera was arriving soon to film an MTV documentary for World AIDS Day. Our church housed an independent ministry, “Silver Ring Thing,” which challenged teens to abstain from sex and to wear a ring to symbolize their pledge to God.

I was and am ambivalent about such efforts, but Ms. Aguilera, MTV, AIDS, teen sex — this was news! News a newspaper would cover, right? On Monday, I asked the local-desk editor on duty if anything was scheduled.

He laughed. He said, “That program is a joke. Those kids are screwing like lemmings” — I’ll never forget his scrambled metaphor — “so no, we’re not covering it.”

I objected. “Whether the program works, and whether or not we agree, a major pop star doing a documentary here for MTV is news, isn’t it?”

The reply: “We’re not covering it.”

Advertise with us

After a few minutes of reflection, I went to his superior, who acknowledged this was troubling bias. Absolutely nothing was done.

This is just one instance I happened to uncover. How many other instances go unnoticed? How do you quantify non-coverage?

Most newspeople I’ve known over 30 years at four very different papers are diligent, self-examining professionals. But all of us — readers included — have worldviews, some deep, some narrow, some inflexible. There are certain things we don’t learn about ourselves until others confront us. This happens to opinion columnists constantly, but less often to reporters.

Without accountability, the ugly, self-indulgent stuff festers. What festers does damage. Journalists and readers alike have a responsibility to confront what we might rather not see. There’s a lot riding on it.

Ruth Ann Dailey is a columnist for the Post-Gazette (ruthanndailey@hotmail.com).