One doesn’t speak ill of the dead, the saying goes, but this admonition aside, the accolades and fond remembrances of George H.W. Bush sound unusually deep and heartfelt.
Even if it were polite to dredge up old sins or slights, it seems this man who once led our nation was so thoroughly kind and good that there’s little fault to find.
Which stands in stark contrast to … something. Or someone.
“ ‘Honorable, gracious and decent’: In death, Bush becomes a yardstick for Trump” was a Washington Post headline three days before the state funeral. Greg Jaffe’s article beneath it noted, “Bush’s desire to include Trump at his funeral suggests that the president didn’t want his final send-off to be about the current occupant of the Oval Office, but rather about his life, his presidency and his country.”
Both the article and its headline, then, defy this desire; they come not to praise Mr. Bush but to bury Donald Trump.
A post-funeral Politico article sounded a common theme: “The service was replete with praise for the 41st president that could, with just the slightest nudge of interpretation, be heard as implied rebuke of the 45th president.
“Speakers rhapsodized about” Mr. Bush’s many virtues, said editor John Harris’s article. “Who wouldn’t admire these traits? Or expect that any president should try to emulate them?”
There’s a bigger, and unflattering, question buried there.
Who wouldn’t expect Mr. Trump to emulate the Bush-ian virtues? Well, that would be the 46.1 percent of American voters who knew going into the 2016 election pretty much what they’d be getting and voted for Mr. Trump anyway. Does praise for Mr. Bush, with the slightest nudge, also rebuke them?
It depends on what you think motivated their votes: Either they (like Mr. Trump) often fail to pursue the good and noble, or they are generally decent people who nevertheless preferred some particular policy or quality of Mr. Trump to the policies or qualities of his opponents. They weighed him and found him necessary.
In four of our seven presidential contests since 1992, the winner has failed to win 50 percent of the popular vote. Nonetheless, who we elect is an expression of what many of us consider most urgent at the time we cast our ballots — whether it is economic vitality, a break from the past or racial progress.
We already know that the voters who put Mr. Trump in the White House are, counterintuitively, America’s “values voters” — Republicans, Reagan Democrats, the “religious right,” workers from the heartland and Rust Belt, average Americans.
They are the ones whose sons and daughters go to war, who lose their jobs when Washington’s “best and brightest” sign trade agreements and environmental pacts, who lose their houses when Congress and Wall Street scratch each other’s backs.
They are President Barack Obama’s “bitter clingers” and Hillary Clinton’s “deplorables,” and they’re tired of being despised.
I know, from talking with them in churches and around the dinner table, that they would much prefer another George H.W. Bush, but they realize his days are long gone. An East Coast aristocrat and World War II hero who loved God, family, country and country music, Mr. Bush was born in elite circumstances without ever being an elitist.
Much has changed since he left office 26 years ago. What we don’t trust, at this point in our history, is elitism without virtue.
But that’s what we’ve got: a ruling class that is insulated and insular, secular and morally sick, unelected and unaccountable to those whose lives they fancy themselves capable of running.
Maybe only a swamp creature could survive the swamp long enough to drain it, or at least seriously rearrange its topography. Maybe Mr. Trump’s voters hope a kinder, gentler leader can emerge from the wreckage to lead us to brighter days.
If so, they may be nearly as optimistic as the great man we’ve just laid to rest.
ruthanndailey@hotmail.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.