Last week I spent some time with many delightful members of St. Valentine Women’s Guild at their Bethel Park church.

Despite my being a rather protest-y kind of Protestant, my brief speech and Q&A time went well enough that, as we chatted afterward, several women urged me to visit again soon, particularly at next month’s Harvest Dinner Dance.

“Alas,” I said, “I’m not just a Protestant but was raised as a fundamentalist. We weren’t allowed to dance, growing up, and I’m too self-conscious an adult to overcome that social deficit.”

I even gave a brief demonstration — not Elaine-Benes-on-”Seinfeld”-worthy, but sufficiently awkward, I thought, to inspire pity. They were charming, of course — “So you dance like most of us” — but we also laughed about the fact that the Bible mentions dancing favorably at times yet it was forbidden in my church.

Advertise with us

My ineptitude is a harmless result of an unusually strict benchmark for virtue. Setting unreasonable standards is a pitfall in many human undertakings. Sometimes the consequences are disastrous. I believe it has played a significant role in the Roman Catholic Church’s heartbreaking sexual-abuse scandal, so news that the church is ready to consider major changes fascinate me.

Vatican watchers say Pope Francis is convening a 2019 meeting at which the possibility of ordaining married men likely will be considered.

Sometimes strict, unbending rules make sense. You wouldn’t want me as a Navy Seal or a heart surgeon, for instance. You could train me for years, and I might get stronger or acquire some medical knowledge, but I’d likely never overcome my squeamishness and physical cowardice. If I were humanity’s last hope, the species would perish.

Setting standards in the moral realm, though, is different. Most adults have some role to fill, and results are harder to quantify. As parents and teachers, we struggle to know where to draw the line and how to respond to changing circumstances (such as smartphones and other technologies) that complicate our goal of guiding youngsters. A further challenge is that, in society at large, we bring diverse beliefs and priorities to the task.

In the Christian church, despite our myriad denominations, we do share the Bible as our primary authority. And, as with the rules of my childhood, the Roman Catholic church has imposed a standard for priests that is more rigid than — and significantly different from — what the Bible instructs.

Advertise with us

As a non-Catholic, I was surprised to learn that priestly celibacy was not required until the 12th century. It is difficult for me to understand how this came about. The apostle Peter, whom Catholics consider the first pope, was married. Paul and other New Testament writers said church leaders (priests, bishops, elders) should be “the husband of one wife,” have obedient children and be sober, gentle, humble, hospitable and so on.

Paul was happy in his celibacy and wished others shared it so that they, too, could single-mindedly serve God, but he was realistic: “Better to marry than to burn with passion.” And while using masculine nouns and pronouns in his writing, Paul ministered side-by-side with female missionaries and thanked them by name.

By setting a stricter, different standard for priests, the church has excluded many wonderful people who desired a spouse and family. Perhaps it also unwittingly opened the door to men who are single not because they are spiritually gifted but because they are immature or warped.

Please know that the Catholic Church is not the only Christian entity that attracts pedophiles. Predators go wherever they sniff out prey, and religious institutions of all kinds are full of trusting people, people whose hopes, needs and wounds make them tragically vulnerable.

I say none of this to throw stones, but because I see cautionary parallels with my own religious experience.

Advertise with us

I cherish my upbringing, but I’m walking my own journey, and I can bear witness that anything humans have shattered or torn, God can heal. The church is his, and so are we.

Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.