After wading through the allegations made against Judge Brett Kavanaugh since his nomination to the Supreme Court, the one thing we can say we know for sure is the same thing we knew before it all started: Unsupervised teens drinking too much alcohol do stupid, embarrassing and even dangerous things.
That’s it. That’s all we know for sure.
Thursday’s reconvened hearing may provide no greater clarity. Barring the emergence of credible testimony, we likely won’t know whether Judge Kavanaugh was even present at the two parties — one in high school, one in college — where he is alleged to have assaulted two female peers, allegations he categorically denies.
As we try to sort through it all, most of us are probably feeling conflicted. I certainly am.
Prior to Christine Blasey Ford’s allegation, I was very much inclined to support Judge Kavanaugh, finding his personal life and career admirable.
Now, however, that inclination must be offset by my experiences as a woman, friend and sister. I have witnessed or endured the damage caused by various acts of injustice, in the workplace and in social settings, in public and in private, ranging from unequal pay to groping to rape.
Read More
These varied experiences caused varied amounts of harm. Being groped at 25 by a 65-year-old attorney was something I easily dismissed. I complained about the pervy geezer to his colleague and have given it hardly a thought in 30 years.
While being discriminated against in my career has caused ongoing, semi-contained damage, it is minor compared to the rape of a loved one who still struggles with the trauma 32 years later.
You can take all these ills seriously without having to believe automatically, 100 percent, any accusation a woman makes.
In fact, taking these problems seriously requires that we do make distinctions, both minor and major. The alleged victim is not always honest. Each incident is not all-or-nothing. It is time to say, as the #MeToo movement rolls on, that the details matter.
I don’t find the allegation dating from Judge Kavanaugh’s Yale years nearly as credible or weighty as Ms. Ford’s story, but the detail I can’t get past in both narratives is the impact of alcohol on young brains.
Even a small amount of alcohol lowers our inhibitions, impairs our judgment, slows our cognition and impacts our physiological responses.
In vino veritas? No, not really.
Each of us is a bundle of contradictions, especially in young adulthood. Who we are at 15, 17, 20 is still taking shape. We are still choosing among myriad influences from myriad sources.
In fact, the self may be fairly fluid throughout life. As things happen to us and we respond, as opportunities arise or we create them, as we act and react, we are changing who we are.
But who we are and aspire to be when we are in full possession of our faculties is the truest presentation of our authentic selves.
There’s a reason parents tell their kids “Make good choices,” not “Have good impulses.”
We speak of “the better angels of our natures” and know that wrestling against our worse impulses — whether suppressed, unknown, indulged or completely random — is a lifelong challenge. We meet this challenge less than fully armed when we drink or do drugs.
And alas, all of the teens in these alleged incidents — whoever they were — were alcohol-impaired. The same deficit may affect what they remember, or don’t, to this day.
Something happened to Ms. Ford. The facts may or may not be what she recalls decades later. It may or may not have involved Judge Kavanaugh.
In adulthood, both have led exemplary lives. Neither of them deserves to be destroyed by the current crisis. Ironically, the person at greater risk of unjust victimization, now and going forward, is Judge Kavanaugh.
Without new reliable information to the contrary, he should be confirmed.
Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.