The ad was hard to ignore. It was a hot pink page with orange lettering, and the verb in every sentence was the f-bomb.
That’s as explicit as this newspaper will allow me to be. It’s a standard I respect, but it’s evidently not shared by New York magazine, where I encountered the ad, or by any other publication or website that carried it.
Most of its 10 sentences also used the vulgarity as an adjective, gerund or past participle. In a droll bit of faux delicacy, the “u” was replaced by an asterisk.
This insincere scruple — “We’ll leave out the vowels for the prudes” — is really the only aspect of the ad I find amusing. It is from Planned Parenthood of New York City, and at the bottom, next to the organization’s name and emblem, is a sentence that I simply cannot reproduce here, even with asterisks.
Suffice it to say PPNYC asserts that New Yorkers’ freedom to have sex with whomever they’d like — “someone from every borough” — is under assault. It isn’t, of course, unless New Yorkers think their sexual freedom rests upon taxpayers’ willingness to pay for their birth control.
What interests me is the connection between our shared culture and public policy, because as the ad betrays, they are indeed connected.
Let me confess, not for the first time, that I have no stone to throw here. In neither the realm of behavior nor of language am I, uh, “beyond reproach.” As concerns vocabulary, I maintain that the occasional vulgarity can be very funny or powerful, or both, but pulling it off requires restraint, good timing and consideration of one’s audience.
This ad, by contrast, is stupid — and weirdly angry. Among the things the ad says are deserving of the f-bomb: “your loud … upstairs neighbor,” “anyone who can afford their rent,” “broker fees,” man-spreaders, subletters, “whoever has a washer-dryer in their … apartment,” “New Yorkers who technically live in Jersey,” and so on.
The mash-up of envy, resentment and sex is immature, just like the swearing. I didn’t go through my “teen rebellion” until my late 30s and, since the phase featured plenty of curse words and other, more destructive behavior, my patient family was relieved when I got over it.
Sure, you can talk or act like that, but why would you?
You can have sex with “someone from every borough,” but if you’re doing it simply to prove that you can, what have you accomplished?
Each individual figures out such things for herself, of course — and it’s healthier to gain this wisdom by reflection rather than experience — but loved ones must respond to this process with compassion and humility.
That is not the right response, however, to an organization such as Planned Parenthood that promotes unhealthy, destructive behavior for its own financial gain.
One can agree with sexual self-determination and planned parenthood without condoning mindless, soulless copulation and the cult of the disposable fetus. PPNYC’s ad, though, in style and substance, precludes this common ground.
Given the immaturity of the ad’s approach, perhaps it was meant as a youth recruitment tool. Tell the kids they should be having lots of random sex, offer free contraceptives, warn them that their sexual freedom is under political assault, ask them to donate and make them lifelong ideological partners.
Like so many products in our popular culture these days — like so many vulgarity-drenched movies, shows and even sidewalk conversations — the ad is an act of aggression. Our only choices are to ignore it and let it spread and normalize it, or to address it — and thereby spread it.
Even if we debate in order to object more thoughtfully, we can’t un-see anything.
Riddle me this: Why is our liberty so often used to limit our common ground?
I would never want to return to the days of early television, say, when married couples slept in separate beds and language was sanitized to the point of unreality.
But we have moved an unfathomable distance in a few short decades. How much of the change has been for the good?
Long before the celebrity Donald Trump boasted — in a private conversation — of groping women, of violating their physical boundaries, we were already shaping an ever more uncivilized society, where very few boundaries are respected. Where violating previous social norms is seen, ridiculously, as a sign of moral or intellectual courage.
Congratulations, Americans — we can do or say just about anything, any time, anywhere, with or without an asterisk!
But why would we? To what end? What does it accomplish?
Planned Parenthood of New York City has hit a new low. Where do we go from here?
Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.