There is so much to appreciate in the Supreme Court’s decision in favor of the Colorado baker — the margin, the men, the moderation — that it will be easy to overlook what should remain troubling.
The most obvious positive here is the margin of the court’s vote. How many times in recent years have we heard or made complaints about our “narrowly divided” court and its many 5-4 decisions? As goes the court, so goes the nation — or is it vice versa?
In the case of Jack Phillips of Masterpiece Cakeshop, however, the decision was 7-2.
In 2012 Mr. Phillips declined to create a cake for a same-sex wedding celebration, citing his deep and long-standing religious beliefs. The gay couple filed a complaint with the Colorado Civil Rights Commission, which found Mr. Phillips in violation of state civil-rights law, a judgment later upheld by a Colorado appeals court.
In the Supreme Court decision Monday, all but two justices (Ruth Bader Ginsberg and Sonia Sotomayor) agreed that Colorado courts had shown impermissible hostility toward Mr. Phillips’ faith and violated his First Amendment rights. That’s a heartening level of agreement on such a contentious issue.
After the margin, consider the men — three in particular. First is Justice Anthony Kennedy, who wrote this decision, as well as the landmark 2015 decision in Obergefell v. Hodges legalizing same-sex marriage. By taking a prominent role in both these cases, he is trying to make a statement, I believe, about the possibility of sorting out our sometimes conflicting rights with respect and good will.
Justice Kennedy’s tone in the Obergefell decision was emotional, even crusading; here it is circumspect and dispassionate. The comparison indicates which side his heart is on, but he insists that “these disputes must be resolved with tolerance, without undue disrespect to sincere religious beliefs, and without subjecting gay persons to indignities when they seek goods and services in an open market.”
It was probably this man’s moderation that made the 7-2 margin possible. I applaud his balance, though I think religious folk should ponder the phrase “undue disrespect.”
The second man deserving of appreciation is Justice Neil Gorsuch, whose concurring opinion elevates SCOTUS prose to an unusual, even delightful level of clarity and style.
He treats more piercingly the Colorado Commission’s double standard in declining to fault bakers who refused to make cakes with anti-gay messages. The Ginsburg dissent and even Justice Elena Kagan’s concurrence attempt to let the commission off the hook by arguing that only Mr. Phillips’ discrimination was against a protected group.
Justice Gorsuch refutes this, summarizing: “In both cases, it was the kind of cake, not the kind of customer, that mattered to the bakers.”
He decries the arbitrary application of “a sort of Goldilocks rule: describing the cake by its ingredients is too general; understanding it as celebrating a same-sex wedding is too specific; but regarding it as a generic wedding cake is just right.” The italics are his, and they’re marvelous.
He has a gift for the aphorism: “Popular religious views are easy enough to defend. It is in protecting unpopular religious beliefs that we prove this country’s commitment to serving as a refuge for religious freedom.” Amen to that.
The third man I applaud is the baker himself, Jack Phillips. Although I would not have chosen the same course, despite aspiring, like him, to follow the teachings of Jesus, I must commend his courage and perseverance in fighting for his — and others’ — freedom of conscience.
But how much has been won?
While the decision is narrower than religious conservatives might like, it strikes me as less narrow than their opposites are claiming. The court cites not only the “clear and impermissible hostility” of Civil Rights Commission members, but also the lack of neutrality toward religion made evident by their disparate treatment of the other bakers. The problem wasn’t just their rudeness, it was also their reasoning.
The decision’s final paragraphs note that the exact details of the Masterpiece case mattered greatly, thereby implying that other similar cases may bring different results. Justice Kennedy foresees “possibilities that seem all but endless.”
What all this portends is more long years of legal conflicts that, unfortunately, divide far more of us than just the couples and artisans involved. They damage the beliefs we claim to cherish.
It is not too late — it is never too late — to craft laws that clarify the place where sacred and secular, private and public collide. It is not too late to agree, no matter what our personal persuasions, to proceed with mutual respect. A strong Supreme Court majority, diverse but unified, has pointed the way.
Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.