The year hasn’t yet reached its midpoint, but a strong contender for the ultimate social Rorschach test of 2018 has just emerged.

These great sortings happen every so often: Team Gale or Team Peeta? (2014). Blue-and-black-striped dress or white-and-gold-striped dress? (2015).

Some might think that the current divide is whether you hear “Yanny” or “Laurel” in that inescapable audio clip, but that one doesn’t do much for me — and not just because I have only ever heard “Yanny.”

The better social Rorschach tests are the ones where there are many angles to discuss, and 11 days after the wedding of Prince Harry and Meghan Markle — an eternity in modern social media time — people are still talking about Bishop Michael Curry’s sermon.

Advertise with us

The Twitter-verse has recovered from the horror of the bride’s wispy hairdo and moved on to other celebrity mortifications. But that sermon!

The “sorting” began at the wedding itself. As the Most Rev. Curry, the first African-American presiding bishop of the Episcopal Church, passionately proclaimed the transforming power of love, the camera caught more than a few aristocrats watching him with eyes popping and mouths agape.

Or, as comedian Kenan Thompson put it in a “Saturday Night Live” impersonation that night, “I preached, and I testified, and I yelled while 500 stuffy English people looked at me like I was a fart in an elevator.”

By my lights, Bishop Curry didn’t come close to “yelling,” but it was pretty funny to witness the discomfort his fervor caused in some. You could almost see the thought balloons: “Egads, what is this?” “Oh dear, he actually believes what he’s saying.”

More people, though, seem to have been intrigued by his message and manner. We’re still sifting through it, online and in person.

Advertise with us

I had skipped the live broadcast, but a friend could hardly contain her enthusiasm two days later, so I went home, found BBC America’s repeat and watched the service.

“The Today Show” got it right by dubbing it “The Sermon Heard ‘Round the World.” That’s literally true, since it reached about 2 billion viewers worldwide. But as a reference to the shots that started the American Revolution, is it metaphorically true?

Vox.com writer Tara Isabella Burton and the like-minded hope so. In a thought-provoking essay, Ms. Burton praised the sermon as “the rhetoric of liberation theology — a 20th-century theological tradition inspired by Marxist thought — to characterize love as a necessary, chaotic and political force.”

It’s like “Yanny” versus “Laurel.” This was a political sermon? Only two sentences in its 15 minutes mention any political arrangement or action — “governments and nations ... we will lay down our swords and shields … to study war no more.”

Love isn’t a government diktat. Love cannot be coerced, but with enough love changing enough individuals’ hearts, governments can certainly be transformed. That’s not Marxist socialism, it’s representative democracy at work.

Advertise with us

Bishop Curry wisely refrained from urging any specific action. He simply noted all the blessings that could flow “where love is the way.” He may incline toward liberation theology himself, but on the first occasion in human history when a preacher has been able to address 2 billion people at once, he chose to emphasize the most accessible part of the Christian gospel: love.

And that has proven a Rorschach test for conservative Christians, too. It is not hard to find essays and blog posts complaining that Bishop Curry did not preach “the whole truth.” He left out the full meaning of Jesus’ death.

As with the Marxist take, I’m wondering if we heard the same words. Quoting the Antebellum slave song, he said, “ ‘If you cannot preach like Peter, and you cannot pray like Paul, you just tell the love of Jesus, how he died to save us all!’ ... Oh, that’s the balm in Gilead! … He died to save us all.

“He gave up his life … for the good of others, for the well-being of the world ... for us. … [R]edemptive love changes lives, and it can change this world.”

Theologians will worry over the difference between redeeming grace and mere moral example — and they should. But as the great preacher Stuart Briscoe would say, the Christian’s greatest calling is to make Jesus “winsome.”

Advertise with us

Bishop Curry did that in spades. The delight of the “Today Show” crew — big grins, high-fives — when he sat with them two days later was unprecedented.

Was the sermon embarrassing or enchanting? Was it the Gospel or not? Marxist or not? Each listener decides for herself, but we can’t deny that love was powerfully proclaimed. We seem hungry for that, and might be enticed to investigate further.

Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com