Say what you will about Joy Behar and Lauren Duca — that they say mean and ignorant things, for starters — but at least they respect religious faith enough to feel the need to mock it.
Far more harmful is the near silence about religion that prevails in some quarters. In certain influential places, religion is barely worth mentioning, no matter how dramatic its role in a newsworthy event.
Twitter and talk shows exist for mouthing off. When the Rev. Billy Graham, a Christian evangelist with a global reach, died Wednesday, Ms. Duca, a Teen Vogue blogger, startled many by tweeting, “Have fun in hell, bitch!”
A few days earlier, Joy Behar of “The View” shocked millions when she mocked the beliefs of Vice President Mike Pence. “It’s one thing to talk to Jesus. It’s another thing when Jesus talks to you,” she said. “That’s called mental illness, if I’m not correct.”
“If I’m not correct?” Surely she meant, “If I’m not mistaken,” and she was. She walked back her comments as a “joke” a couple of days later, claiming to be a Christian herself (which would actually make the situation much worse).
Most people don’t lash out without reason. They do so because they perceive a threat, or an opportunity, or both. In attacking sincere religious faith, the aggressors are implicitly acknowledging religion’s power.
While such aggression can be countered, it is much harder to push back against something that isn’t there. Here’s a recent instance of the important but unsaid. It makes me wonder how many I’ve missed.
I did not recognize Rick Stevens’ name when I found out he’d died, but I knew his hit songs with Tower of Power. I’d heard “You’re Still a Young Man” at many TOP concerts, but never with Mr. Stevens on lead. That’s because, as I learned from his obituaries, addiction torpedoed his career in 1972; he was convicted in 1976 for killing three people in a “drug deal gone wrong” and spent 36 years in prison.
It was while perusing the TOP website last month looking for concert tickets that I read of Mr. Stevens’ death last September. Band founder Emilio Castillo posted, “Rick Stevens went to heaven today to be with the Lord whom he loved with all his heart.”
Mr. Castillo recalled having told his just-paroled friend a few years earlier how skeptical he was of the “prison salvation” experience, but he was proved wrong: “[Rick] went above and beyond the call of duty and carried his message of faith and redemption to many.”
This tribute made me wonder what newspapers had written about him. What I found was eye-opening.
The Associated Press obituary, which was reprinted widely, quoted extensively from Mr. Castillo’s online farewell, including its explicit Christian message of a transformed life and hope of heaven.
Unfortunately, though, when you google “Rick Stevens obituary,” the top hit is The New York Times. This article, the one most online news consumers likely saw, carefully recounts Mr. Stevens’ singing career, drug problems, crimes and imprisonment, but mentions his religious conversion only fleetingly.
The Times thus fails to tell accurately the story of an artist’s life, avoiding the redemption that was so pivotal to it — a narrative arc that is such a significant part of the American psyche and culture.
The best obituary, balanced and rich with detail, appeared in the San Jose Mercury News, which covers TOP’s hometown of Oakland, Calif. — a strong argument for the importance of local newspapers.
Not long after the 2016 election, Times executive editor Dean Baquet publicly mused that “media powerhouses don’t quite get religion. … We don’t get the role of religion in people’s lives. And I think we can do much, much better.”
They still need to. Consider:
When Ms. Duca wrote “Donald Trump Is Gaslighting America” for Teen Vogue in December 2016, both the Times and The Washington Post covered it prominently. Both have been silent about her tasteless tweet on Billy Graham and the ensuing uproar.
The Post reported the remarks about Mr. Pence from former White House staffer Omarosa Manigault that sparked “The View” conversation, but it has not reported on Ms. Behar’s comments and the continuing controversy (25,000-plus protest phone calls to the network).
Each time readers notice quiet but significant omissions like these, it erodes our trust. It propels us to outlets that do “get” us. It reinforces our divisions.
Mr. Pence said Ms. Behar’s comments are “evidence of how out of touch some in the mainstream media are with the faith and values of the American people.”
Sometimes this is displayed noisily. Sometimes it is displayed in a selective and exclusionary silence.
Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.