At a rally Wed­nes­day for the Re­pub­li­cans’ tax bill, Pres­i­dent Don­ald Trump stood flanked by two American flags and some Christmas trees trimmed with red, white and blue or­na­ments.

He de­toured from the tax topic to point to a sign on the stage bun­ting and pro­claim, “I told you that we would be say­ing ‘Merry Christ­mas’ again.” The St. Louis crowd roared its ap­proval.

Talk about your mixed mes­sages. Pagan trees with pa­tri­otic flair and Christ­mas greet­ings, at a rally for tax re­form? That’s as tan­gled as the av­er­age strand of hol­i­day lights.

Under the mess is an irony. The sep­a­ra­tion of church and state, Amer­ica’s gift to the world, grew slowly but di­rectly from Je­sus’ an­swer to a trick ques­tion about, yes, taxes: “Render unto Cae­sar what is Cae­sar’s and unto God what is God’s” (Mat­thew 22:21).

Advertise with us

Two mil­len­nia later, the church-state di­vide couldn’t get much mes­sier. We’ve been strug­gling to fig­ure it out since the Pu­ri­tans fled re­li­gious per­se­cu­tion in En­gland, landed here and started per­se­cut­ing ev­ery­body else.

Bat­tles along “the wall of sep­a­ra­tion” flare up reg­u­larly. Ever since “Happy Hol­i­days” re­placed “Merry Christ­mas” on ev­ery­thing from store signs to Star­bucks cups, we’ve en­joyed the sea­sonal “war on Christ­mas,” a fact that makes The Wash­ing­ton Post’s head­line on the St. Louis tax rally, “Trump opens new front in the cul­ture wars,” flat-out wrong.

That front has been open for a while, but it is dan­ger­ously mis­guided. Although I like to say “Merry Christ­mas,” I can’t in­sist some­one else do so — not an in­di­vid­ual, nor a mer­chant pur­su­ing wide­spread ap­peal. (I wish my fel­low Chris­tians would pon­der whether such ef­forts will make Je­sus ap­peal­ing to non-be­liev­ers.)

Christ­mas aside, though, is there a “war on Chris­ti­an­ity”? There does seem to be a sus­tained an­tag­o­nism to­ward tra­di­tional re­li­gions, ex­pressed by an­gry sec­u­lar­ists who don’t know enough his­tory to un­der­stand whom they can thank for our church-state sep­a­ra­tion. (Bap­tists first, Tho­mas Jef­fer­son sec­ond, rec­og­niz­ing a com­mon cause.)

And since a ma­jor­ity of Amer­i­cans em­brace Chris­ti­an­ity, an­tip­a­thy to re­li­gion of­ten looks like a more spe­cific “war on Chris­ti­an­ity.” What­ever you want to call it, it’s blaz­ing on a few dif­fer­ent fronts right now.

Advertise with us

On Tues­day, the Supreme Court will hear ar­gu­ments in Mas­ter­piece Cake­shop Ltd. v. Col­o­rado Civil Rights Com­mis­sion. The case is baker Jack Phil­lips’ ap­peal of a judge­ment against him for de­clin­ing to make a wed­ding cake for a same-sex cou­ple on the grounds that it vi­o­lated his deeply held faith.

Mr. Phil­lips’ prac­tice of his creed as a busi­ness­man has been con­sis­tent for 24 years. He closes on Sun­day, he re­fuses to make prod­ucts with pro­fane, anti-Amer­i­can or Hal­low­een themes, and he has also de­clined to make a cake with an anti-gay mes­sage, call­ing it hate­ful.

The com­mis­sion, though, re­vealed a fla­grant dou­ble stan­dard by al­low­ing three other bak­er­ies, around the same time, to de­cline to make cakes that would have crit­i­cized same-sex mar­riage with ic­ing-ren­dered Bible verses.

Be­cause Mr. Phil­lips and oth­ers like him can prove that they have not dis­crim­i­nated against gay cli­ents (or pro-Hal­low­een cli­ents) in any other way, they can thus demon­strate that the stick­ing point is not a cli­ent’s sex­ual ori­en­ta­tion (or hol­i­day pref­er­ence) but the forced ex­pres­sion of an idea or par­tic­i­pa­tion in a re­li­gious cer­e­mony with which they dis­agree.

On an­other front, Penn­syl­va­nia, Cal­i­for­nia and a few other states have sued the fed­eral gov­ern­ment and the Lit­tle Sis­ters of the Poor to force the nuns to pro­vide em­ploy­ees in­sur­ance plans cov­er­ing con­tra­cep­tives, which vi­o­lates the nuns’ faith.

Advertise with us

The Supreme Court al­ready de­cided this mat­ter, in 2016, in­struct­ing the states to work out com­pro­mises pre­serv­ing all par­ties’ rights. Ap­par­ently, quite a few states’ lead­ers are un­able to peace­fully co­ex­ist with the re­li­gious.

In Wash­ing­ton, D.C., the Metro bus sys­tem has just re­jected a Roman Cath­o­lic ad cam­paign pro­mot­ing “spir­i­tual giv­ing” — “Find the Per­fect Gift” — ar­gu­ing that the de­pic­tion of shep­herds, sheep and stars “pro­motes re­li­gion,” a vi­o­la­tion of the tran­sit sys­tem’s rules.

At the heart of the matter is whether the Metro system can lawfully refuse all “advocacy” ads, whether political or religious. Importantly, the Catholic church is fighting for the right to its own expression, not trying to coerce someone else’s, whether on coffee cups or wedding cakes.

It is lib­erty we should fight for, not the pri­macy of our par­tic­u­lar creed. Je­sus said, “Render unto Cae­sar what is Cae­sar’s,” and left it up to us to fig­ure out what ex­actly that is.

When fol­low­ers of any re­li­gion fight for their faith, or flaunt it, in ways that are co­er­cive or abra­sive or triv­ial, they make our pre­cious lib­erty that much harder to pro­tect.

Ruth Ann Dai­ley: ruth­an­n­dai­ley@hot­mail.com