At a rally Wednesday for the Republicans’ tax bill, President Donald Trump stood flanked by two American flags and some Christmas trees trimmed with red, white and blue ornaments.
He detoured from the tax topic to point to a sign on the stage bunting and proclaim, “I told you that we would be saying ‘Merry Christmas’ again.” The St. Louis crowd roared its approval.
Talk about your mixed messages. Pagan trees with patriotic flair and Christmas greetings, at a rally for tax reform? That’s as tangled as the average strand of holiday lights.
Under the mess is an irony. The separation of church and state, America’s gift to the world, grew slowly but directly from Jesus’ answer to a trick question about, yes, taxes: “Render unto Caesar what is Caesar’s and unto God what is God’s” (Matthew 22:21).
Two millennia later, the church-state divide couldn’t get much messier. We’ve been struggling to figure it out since the Puritans fled religious persecution in England, landed here and started persecuting everybody else.
Battles along “the wall of separation” flare up regularly. Ever since “Happy Holidays” replaced “Merry Christmas” on everything from store signs to Starbucks cups, we’ve enjoyed the seasonal “war on Christmas,” a fact that makes The Washington Post’s headline on the St. Louis tax rally, “Trump opens new front in the culture wars,” flat-out wrong.
That front has been open for a while, but it is dangerously misguided. Although I like to say “Merry Christmas,” I can’t insist someone else do so — not an individual, nor a merchant pursuing widespread appeal. (I wish my fellow Christians would ponder whether such efforts will make Jesus appealing to non-believers.)
Christmas aside, though, is there a “war on Christianity”? There does seem to be a sustained antagonism toward traditional religions, expressed by angry secularists who don’t know enough history to understand whom they can thank for our church-state separation. (Baptists first, Thomas Jefferson second, recognizing a common cause.)
And since a majority of Americans embrace Christianity, antipathy to religion often looks like a more specific “war on Christianity.” Whatever you want to call it, it’s blazing on a few different fronts right now.
On Tuesday, the Supreme Court will hear arguments in Masterpiece Cakeshop Ltd. v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission. The case is baker Jack Phillips’ appeal of a judgement against him for declining to make a wedding cake for a same-sex couple on the grounds that it violated his deeply held faith.
Mr. Phillips’ practice of his creed as a businessman has been consistent for 24 years. He closes on Sunday, he refuses to make products with profane, anti-American or Halloween themes, and he has also declined to make a cake with an anti-gay message, calling it hateful.
The commission, though, revealed a flagrant double standard by allowing three other bakeries, around the same time, to decline to make cakes that would have criticized same-sex marriage with icing-rendered Bible verses.
Because Mr. Phillips and others like him can prove that they have not discriminated against gay clients (or pro-Halloween clients) in any other way, they can thus demonstrate that the sticking point is not a client’s sexual orientation (or holiday preference) but the forced expression of an idea or participation in a religious ceremony with which they disagree.
On another front, Pennsylvania, California and a few other states have sued the federal government and the Little Sisters of the Poor to force the nuns to provide employees insurance plans covering contraceptives, which violates the nuns’ faith.
The Supreme Court already decided this matter, in 2016, instructing the states to work out compromises preserving all parties’ rights. Apparently, quite a few states’ leaders are unable to peacefully coexist with the religious.
In Washington, D.C., the Metro bus system has just rejected a Roman Catholic ad campaign promoting “spiritual giving” — “Find the Perfect Gift” — arguing that the depiction of shepherds, sheep and stars “promotes religion,” a violation of the transit system’s rules.
At the heart of the matter is whether the Metro system can lawfully refuse all “advocacy” ads, whether political or religious. Importantly, the Catholic church is fighting for the right to its own expression, not trying to coerce someone else’s, whether on coffee cups or wedding cakes.
It is liberty we should fight for, not the primacy of our particular creed. Jesus said, “Render unto Caesar what is Caesar’s,” and left it up to us to figure out what exactly that is.
When followers of any religion fight for their faith, or flaunt it, in ways that are coercive or abrasive or trivial, they make our precious liberty that much harder to protect.
Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.