Among the ongoing revelations of prominent men’s sexual misconduct, one of the most thought-provoking comments came from actor Jason Alexander.
Apropos of accusations against comedian Louis C.K., the “Seinfeld” star tweeted: “Gentlemen, comedy is often inappropriate. It is sometimes daring and audacious and shocking. But our behavior, in the real world, toward women — that doesn’t get a pass on inappropriate.”
How difficult is it, though, to keep a strict line between speech and behavior when words tend to produce deeds and when you’ve immersed yourself in words that routinely violate conventional, boring morality?
Before going with a girlfriend to C.K.’s show at the University of Pittsburgh’s Petersen Events Center barely a year ago, I had seen only two episodes of his FX series “Louie.” I remembered them as occasionally crude, but somehow still gentle and wry.
The first 10 minutes of his stand-up made me the most embarrassed I have been for another human being in a very long time. If C.K. ever resumes his career, I’d advise him that virtually no human reaches puberty without realizing her own parents have had sex. Stating this fact repeatedly and at great length in Anglo-Saxon terms is neither original nor funny.
But I’m not calling out this one comedian only. And I’m not calling out only comedy, or only men, for that matter.
The famous adage that sprang to mind in response to Mr. Alexander’s tweet about C.K. was this: “A man is what he thinks about all day long.”
That’s how Ralph Waldo Emerson put it almost two centuries ago, but his aphorism was a close adaption of an ancient Bible verse (appropriate for a time when society is suddenly getting very Old Testament-y on certain sins). “As a man thinks in his heart, so is he” — Proverbs 23:7.
Obviously, not every raunchy comedian has been accused of sexual misconduct, and similar stories are emerging across a broad range of professions. But I do find it fascinating that so many sad incidents apparently occur in what we call “the entertainment industry.”
Mr. Alexander’s tweet asserted that comedy is “sometimes daring and audacious and shocking.” Those are lofty words. Might they verge on overblown and self-justifying?
Obscene language hasn’t really served any purpose in comedy since the days of Lenny Bruce and George Carlin. Nowadays, it’s just lazy. (You can say those words. Great. That doesn’t mean you’re funny.)
Claims of being “daring” and “audacious” rest on the assumption that there are boundaries yet to be breached and that breaching them will serve some constructive purpose (other than lining the artist’s pocket).
The works of Kara Walker, to turn to a different art form, are shocking and controversial. Her most famous silhouette installations conjure narratives from America’s past of slavery and racial oppression, the images graphically rendered, sometimes sexually explicit and exaggerated — almost cartoonish.
The shock serves a purpose: As a viewer, you know her images convey historical truth, you shudder at the pain and depravity and your heart cries out against it.
Viewers can pursue the same arguments about gory violence or explicit sex in movies and television. If a would-be artist’s shock and audacity aim not to illuminate but merely to titillate? Then it’s just entertainment, and we’re listening or watching to wallow in transgressive images.
If comedy — or film, or popular music — is “often inappropriate,” how do its creators and consumers hold onto a sense of what is appropriate? Aren’t they — we — actively changing our own sensibilities?
In the wake of Louis C.K.’s admission of wrongdoing, the New York opening of “I Love You, Daddy” — the movie he wrote, directed and stars in — was canceled. Reviewers who have already seen it report it contained multiple jokes about child rape.
Some things are just never going to be funny. Or will they, eventually?
I am not asking to go back to the the days when television portrayed married couples sleeping in twin beds, when Rhett Butler’s “damn” caused national convulsions. Even if that were possible, and it’s not, I prefer reality — messy, righteous, loving, painful, bawdy, disappointing, tragic.
Reality, warts and all. It just worries me that we’ve become so enamored of warts.
We are abusing our freedom of expression to construct a society where it is as hard as it could possibly be to keep our minds and hearts healthy. I believe we are making it infinitely harder for ourselves and our children to lead good lives.
We are free. We can say and show almost anything. How about we don’t and call it a day? It would be a much better day than the days these famous fellows, and their victims, are experiencing right now.
Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.