In the midst of a family conflict, its cause now long forgotten, my father said something to me that has lingered:

“Right now, it doesn’t matter if [your relative’s] complaint is true. It matters more that this is how she perceives things, so I need to love her by respecting and addressing her feelings.”

Or words to that effect. It was my introduction to the therapeutic mode of thinking. There was little conflict in our home, but I recognized this as an important addition to the logic-centered and debate-heavy dynamic of our typical family discourse.

His approach restored peace and provided a little healing — more as time has gone by, because some wounds take a long time to heal.

Advertise with us

My father’s words have come back to me often during the national anthem protests at National Football League games. Pain must be acknowledged and concerns addressed, but how far does a therapeutic approach work on the national platform? At what point do facts matter?

Once President Donald Trump entered the fray, it was easy for some to forget what Colin Kaepernick had said a year earlier. He began sitting or kneeling during the national anthem to protest “a country that oppresses black people,” where the oppressors are “getting away with murder.”

That is quite an assertion. It is one with which many people would disagree. Is the disagreement due to guilty consciences stung or false accusations resented?

The facts do matter — right from the start.

Since we are all equal in the eyes of the law, since discriminatory practices are actively prosecuted and remediating policies of inclusion and diversity are the norm, saying that “the country” is “oppress[ing]” people of color is basically not accurate.

Advertise with us

Individuals may mistreat individuals, however, and specific actions or policies at specific institutions may have such a disparate impact on racial and ethnic groups’ well-being that we have to re-evaluate them — as Attorney General Eric Holder did with the police department in Ferguson, Mo.

Whether anyone is literally “getting away with murder” can be assessed only on a case-by-case basis.

There was much talk of “murder,” for instance, for months after the August 2014 death of Michael Brown in Ferguson. “Hands up, don’t shoot!” became the protesters’ chant after Mr. Brown’s companion claimed he had raised his arms in surrender to Officer Darren Wilson.

No camera was there to capture the tragic course of events, but forensic evidence later revealed that Mr. Brown had reached inside the patrol car and grasped Officer Wilson’s gun and was shot not when walking away or surrendering but while charging toward the policeman.

The shooting death of Philando Castile near St. Paul, Minn., in 2016 was quite different. It really shook the nation, in part because his girlfriend livestreamed its immediate aftermath as she sat in the car next to his bloody body.

Advertise with us

It is hard to fathom that a jury of seven men and five women — two blacks and 10 whites — could acquit the officer of manslaughter charges. But I have to acknowledge that I didn’t hear all the evidence, which the racially representative jury did.

The facts of these two cases — Mr. Brown’s and Mr. Castile’s — vary significantly. Both have been repeatedly termed “murder,” but neither fits the legal definition. Does it help in these cases — or in many others, with victims and officers of all races — to say that anyone is “getting away with murder”?

The facts matter, and carefully articulating them matters, because no matter what our cause, when we paint with too broad and inexact a brush, we lose the support of reasonable people who would otherwise want to help.

There are facts that must be adjusted to, yes, but there is also pain that must be acknowledged.

Does anyone in America doubt that there’s no more work to be done on racial inequality? That there is still real suffering we have yet to remedy? Wounds that still haven’t healed?

Advertise with us

This is where we are right now: Facts and feelings don’t jibe, and we’re stuck at odds on the sidelines during what used to be a fleeting but blessed moment of national unity.

A great leader would try to bridge the gap between facts and feeling, rhetoric and reality. He or she would acknowledge America’s painful racial history and invite us to a place where we could work together to find specific, targeted remedies that address the facts of injustice wherever they are.

The New England Patriots’ posture Sunday — left hand on teammate’s back and right hand over the heart — captures where I hope we’ll soon be. It acknowledges the conflict while affirming unity.

All patriots want the country to thrive, and all know we are in this thing together.

Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com