We have watched plenty of high-profile people recently come to grief for their alleged sins.

I say “watched” as if we were all passive observers, but we are not. Some people clearly incite and feed the shaming frenzy.

Whether they hold the microphones at news conferences or post anonymously on the internet, they are helping to shape a society that is beginning to look more and more like one big, bloodthirsty mob. Collectively, we’re not satisfied until heads roll.

It is odd that the less religious we become as a society, the more rabid our public rituals of outing, shaming and punishing get.

Advertise with us

Carolina Panthers quarterback Cam Newton commented it was “funny” to hear a female reporter using football terminology like “routes.” The outcry was a veritable roar, and faster than you can say “fumble,” Dannon Yogurt had dropped him as a sponsor.

U.S. Rep. Tim Murphy, R-Upper St. Clair, resigned after it was revealed he had an affair and apparently advised his mistress to have an abortion. When the news first broke, he announced he wouldn’t run for re-election next year, but Republican elders summoned him for a sit-down, and he was gone.

Read More

As for indie film producer Harvey Weinstein, many accusers have come forward, in a New York Times investigation, to claim that he had engaged in a decades-long pattern of sexual harassment and payoffs. Now he is “taking a leave of absence” from his film company and “working with therapists.”

These recent incidents involve gender relations, but we’ve seen a similar pattern play out regarding race relations, sexual orientation, gender identification, body image — along any fault-line issue in society.

And it seems a little too much about finding fault.

Advertise with us

The past week’s three big transgressions vary widely in severity, impact and consequences, but you would think each was potentially the end of civilization.

How much of the uproar is a function of the round-the-clock news and social media? It’s hard to say, but in Cam Newton’s case, I’d suggest “a lot.”

He professed himself “stunned” by the backlash. I was, too; it was over the top. But he felt it: In his video apology, he said his comment was “extremely unacceptable” and “extremely degrading and disrespectful.”

No, it was not “extreme.” It wasn’t “degrading,” either — c’mon, women, we’re stronger than that — but it was “disrespectful.” Either it said a lot about Mr. Newton or it was a bad, one-off moment that powered the news cycle for a couple of days.

Other than feeding the media maw, what motivates these ever harsher public morality plays? True concern about harm being done? Glee in watching the mighty fall? Virtue signaling? The joy of wielding power over others? A desire to change the culture?

Advertise with us

I’m not sure how much instructive or preventive value there is in these shaming rituals; in fact, they may be getting harsher in part because they aren’t working. There’s a limit to what you can teach through clobbering people.

Power-wielding has long been the purview of mainstream media; now bloggers, tweeters and trolls can shape national narratives, too. How fun.

Glee in watching the mighty fall is especially obvious when those falling are politicians, although it tends to stay on one side or other of the partisan divide. The people thrilled by the demise of Fox News honchos for sexual harassment are enjoying it all again with the revelation of Mr. Murphy’s affair and abortion hypocrisy.

What’s new and surprising is that Harvey Weinstein, a big Democratic donor, is finally under scrutiny for horrid behavior that was apparently “an open secret” for years.

How different from 2014, when the emails of producer Scott Rudin, also a big Democratic donor, were released in the Sony hack, revealing some truly tasteless racist jokes about President Barack Obama’s supposed taste in movies and actors. Mr. Rudin apologized, he won a few more Tonys, and A-list celebrities still flock to his parties.

Advertise with us

How steep a price you pay may depend on whether people like you — or need your money or want your job — but it does seem our appetite for the public shaming ritual has reached a new intensity.

I attribute it to displaced guilt. If I attack what’s ugly inside you, it helps me ignore my own ugliness. As the numbers who take care of that basic human need at church, synagogue or mosque shrink, the more frequent and exaggerated the public scapegoating will be.

And the more incessant and undifferentiated these public displays of self-righteousness become, the more they will fall on deaf ears. That will help no one, not least those who have been ritually sacrificed.

Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com