In late April, television director Jill Soloway told a reporter for New York magazine that she had female friends “who, as soon as [Donald] Trump got elected, didn’t want to have sex.”
She continued, “I know a lot of women who still aren’t having sex because they’re so angry.”
This was more than five months after the election. I’d say that’s taking politics way too far.
It was 1960s-era left-wing activists who popularized the slogan “The personal is political,” but we seem to have entered an era where the opposite is true: The political is so personal that people aren’t functioning in healthy, civilized or rational ways.
The personal has always been political, of course: Your life experiences impact your politics, no matter what those are.
“If you’re not a liberal at 25, you have no heart, and if you’re not a conservative at 35, you have no brain.” Some version of that quote has been attributed to King Oscar II of Sweden, Benjamin Disraeli and Winston Churchill, among others, while American intellectual Irving Kristol famously quipped, “A neoconservative is a liberal who’s been mugged by reality.”
Both quotes skew to the right, but they speak the same truth as the ’60s leftist slogan.
There’s an important difference, though, between allowing personal experience to shape your political philosophy and letting your politics shape you. In today’s fraught atmosphere, we need to spend more time contemplating that difference.
In fact, the current toxicity may spring from our allowing politics to occupy too much space or too elevated a place in our minds.
At a horrific extreme are the mentally disturbed or just plain evil people so possessed by their politics that they commit violence in its name. Whether it is the crazed Bernie Sanders supporter gunning down Republicans on a ball field, or a white supremacist massacring black parishioners at a Bible study, or an anti-abortionist killing people at a Planned Parenthood clinic, every “ism” has had adherents who cross over into murderous fanaticism.
When they strike, the vast majority of us join together in sorrow and fellow feeling. But that kindred spirit is far too fleeting. It is punctured immediately by partisans rushing to condemn an entire party or religion for the actions of one madman.
Whether those partisans are newspaper editorialists or talk show hosts or strangers at a party, they have allowed political passions to subvert their professional ethics, their intellects and their manners.
In recent years, this has happened repeatedly, from ABC News falsely pinning the Aurora, Colo., movie theater killings on a Tea Party member who happened to share the shooter’s name, to The New York Times editorial board falsely asserting a connection between U.S. Rep. Gabrielle Giffords’ assailant and Sarah Palin’s political action committee, to certain conservatives placing last week’s Republican baseball shootings at Sen. Sanders’ feet.
Doesn’t anybody take a deep breath and count to 10 anymore? Not if it means someone else beats you to the tweet, I guess.
The more faith and hope citizens place in politics, the more severe will be the disappointment when those politics falter, and the more likely people may be to lash out. After all, the dam of politeness can hold back only so much.
It isn’t holding back the severed-head parodies or the slayings of a Trump-like Caesar on stage. Of course, President Donald Trump rarely seems to refrain from the rash, the unkind or the ill-considered himself, but the critics who use the same techniques, or worse, to protest his incivility clearly lack a sense of irony.
In my 20-plus years as a columnist in Pittsburgh, I’ve developed a menu of self-deprecating quips to use when meeting someone new that allows us (I always hope) to set politics aside and connect.
This approach used to work beautifully, but that’s much less true these days. I am still not reconciled to the meanness I routinely encounter — used to it, yes, but “not reconciled” because it is so unnecessary.
I know my left-leaning colleagues experience similar rudeness from ideologues of the right. I would have expected conservatives and libertarians to pin fewer hopes on politics and therefore be less susceptible to its disappointments, but alas.
We get to choose not to rush to judgment. We get to choose to be kind, or not, to other people. We get to choose not to let politics interfere with being civilized.
And we are far gone indeed when political anger gets in the way of something as basic as sex. Whatever happened to “a place for everything and everything in its place”?
Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.