The United States has a serious drug problem. In particular, the use of heroin and opioids is epidemic. Overdose deaths have reached a truly frightening level.
Whether the U.S. has a growing problem with violent crime, however, is much less clear. After almost 20 years of steady decline, there was an uptick in 2015, but the rate remains about half what it was in the peak year of 1996, when the “War on Drugs” was still a full-on effort.
You can easily dig much more deeply into drug use and crime statistics online, but you don’t have to do so to see that there is not necessarily any cause-and-effect link between widespread drug use and violent crime.
In fact, you could assert the opposite: Drug use has climbed, which means drug trafficking has increased, yet violent crime has plummeted. And all that happened while America was imprisoning people at a higher rate than any other nation on earth.
Nonetheless, on Friday Attorney General Jeff Sessions instructed federal prosecutors to seek the most severe penalties possible in even non-violent drug cases.
“Drug trafficking is an inherently dangerous and violent business,” Mr. Sessions said. “If you want to collect a drug debt, you can’t file a lawsuit in court. You collect it with the barrel of a gun.”
Though I do believe some drugs should be legalized, you won’t read any defense of drug use or trafficking here. It is, from start to (often tragic) finish, a morass of pain and despair and predatory cynicism.
But many of us non-lawyers have watched enough legal dramas on TV to know the phrase “Assumes facts not in evidence.” If drug traffickers have engaged in a violent crime, they can be charged, tried and sentenced appropriately; if not, no.
Would we sentence someone who lifted candy from a convenience store as if he’d robbed the clerk at gunpoint, because we think he might someday graduate to armed robbery? Let’s just say no to pre-emptive imprisonment.
This new order is a direct response to one issued by Mr. Sessions’ predecessor, Eric Holder. In 2013, Mr. Holder instructed federal prosecutors to pursue lesser charges than they might have so as to avoid triggering mandatory minimum sentences that would put non-violent offenders in prison for many years.
That is, he was instructing assistant U.S. attorneys to circumvent laws passed by Congress. That’s not a Constitution-respecting way to do things, but the lack of outcry at the time indicates the emerging consensus against draconian sentences for nonviolent offenders.
A growing body of research shows that harsh sentences do not deter criminals or reduce crime. Instead, they do long-term social damage by sowing bitterness and mistrust of the justice system; by putting non-violent offenders into overcrowded and often violent prisons; and by destroying the networks of family and community so important to breaking the cycles of dysfunction and poverty on which crime feeds.
These realizations prompted a welcome bipartisan effort in 2015 to reform mandatory sentencing laws. The “Smarter Sentencing Act” would have caught the law up with Mr. Holder’s instructions, but it languished and died with the Judiciary Committee.
Implying that the Holder directive was hampering the justice system, Mr. Sessions claims his new directive makes sure prosecutors are “unhandcuffed and not micromanaged from Washington.” Telling them they must seek the most serious charges and longest sentences they possibly can — or persuade their superiors and carefully document why they have decided not to — sounds a lot like micromanaging to me.
Mr. Sessions may be right on the law as it currently stands, but most of the available research indicates he’s wrong on the policy. He is a law-and-order guy unable to see that our laws have created disorder.
And his defenders are surprisingly few. Democrats have decried the Sessions directive, of course, but so have congressional Republicans, the powerful Koch brothers and officials in red states where Holder-style efforts have eased prison overcrowding and helped budgets without increasing crime.
Maybe Mr. Sessions’ move will finally galvanize Congress to act. Republican lawmakers may be increasingly eager to create some distance between themselves and Trump administration officials’ understanding of the legal system.
This issue is extremely important and its impact far-reaching. Could we just finally do the right thing the right way?
Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.