It’s a bad day for the faithful when a president’s executive order on religious freedom is so weak that the American Civil Liberties Union shrugs and says, “Why bother?”

People to whom religious freedom truly matters — most likely, people who believe in something other than their own goodness — should not accept President Donald Trump’s order as the final word from this administration. The way the winds are blowing, they should demand greater protection while they can still get it.

That said, the last thing I want to hear from a pulpit is which candidate I should vote for.

Religion and politics have a chicken-egg relationship, though, and the current debate over the Johnson Amendment is unclear, unfair and rife with hypocrisy.

Advertise with us

In 1954, Texas Democrat Sen. Lyndon Johnson drafted and passed a law amending the tax code because he was angry at nonprofit organizations — not churches — that had campaigned against him. The law, signed by Republican President Dwight Eisenhower, prohibits all 501(c)(3) nonprofits from participating, directly or indirectly, in a campaign for or against a political candidate.

There’s a certain logic behind the law: Should organizations that are tax-exempt be able to use that taxpayer subsidy to promote a preferred candidate? They can promote specific policies and actions; in fact, it would seem that most exist to do so.

But some question why the line is drawn at candidates and campaigns; why political speech is constrained. In any event, as the law exists today, it is inconsistently applied.

When I looked up “Johnson Amendment” a few days ago, the top two links were to nonprofits on either side of this issue (thanks for your attempt at evenhanded algorithms, Google!): the Alliance Defending Freedom, which opposes the amendment, and Corporate Accountability International, which wants to preserve it.

The ADF has a “Pulpit Freedom Movement,” which provides handy quotes from history — including Frederick Douglass, minister being among his many professions, publicly criticizing Abraham Lincoln as “passive, cowardly and treacherous” in the fight against slavery.

Advertise with us

On the other hand, Corporate Accountability International’s essay explaining its support of the amendment includes these words: “As we all work together to challenge the Trump administration’s agenda and actions, I hope you’ll … take action. Stand alongside us in opposing the repeal of the Johnson Amendment.” How ironic.

If a pastor or nonprofit CEO had had the opportunity to say, “As we all work together to challenge Hillary Clinton’s agenda,” would that be cause for the IRS to remove his or her organization’s nonprofit status?

Obviously, the law needs to be reconsidered. The anemic executive order Mr. Trump signed Thursday should be but another point in an ongoing discussion.

Logic and fairness demand clarity that the Johnson Amendment and case law lack, but as a matter of practice, I would prefer that America’s ministers, priests, rabbis and imams never test it.

Religion and politics are inextricably linked, of course. Even people who eschew organized religion have a worldview, a more or less coherent set of beliefs about morality, human nature — and God, if there is one.

Advertise with us

These views shape the government we create and, in turn, the government we create might determine whether we can continue to practice the views we embrace.

But our worldview — or our religion — comes first. It supports and transcends our politics. I do care about how Christ’s teachings could impact the world beyond the church doors, but I don’t care to hear the gospel abased by mere electioneering.

Why would nonreligious nonprofits worry about this issue? Because if the Supreme Court ultimately decides that nonprofit “speech” about campaigns and candidates cannot be treated differently from other speech, or that religious nonprofits cannot uniquely be punished for crossing the line, it will either cost everyone the whole tax-exempt nonprofit construct they’ve enjoyed, or it will set loose religious institutions to participate as never before.

For almost 400 years, America has led the world in striving to establish and maintain the right to liberty of conscience and to freedom of religion (two different things). The struggle started between colonial Puritan factions but was very much alive and spreading in the Founders’ days.

John Adams memorably wrote to Thomas Jefferson arguing for “checks and balances” and saying that he trusted “liberal Christians” no more than he would Calvin, Voltaire or Hume; this cardinal or that archbishop; Quakers, Methodists, Moravians, and so on.

Advertise with us

“The Deists would persecute Christians, and Atheists would persecute Deists, with as unrelenting cruelty as any Christians would persecute them or one another. Know thyself, human nature!”

Human nature hasn’t changed. Post-Johnson, today’s checks are applied without balance, so the centuries-old battle must continue.

Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com