Three months after the election and three weeks past the inauguration, an old internet meme plays endlessly in my mind: “You’re doing it wrong.”

The toxic presidential campaign that wearied so many of us has never really stopped. Both sides are so caught up in the ongoing battle that it seems they’ve forgotten — again — about winning those of us on the sidelines.

And we matter. Voters unpersuaded by either major-party candidate were a pivotal segment in November. In the states that were decided by a small margin — Pennsylvania, Florida, Michigan, New Hampshire, Wisconsin, Minnesota, Nevada, Virginia — that margin was in most cases smaller than the percentage of voters who, like me, opted for a third-party candidate.

Moreover, approximately 2.4 million of the nation’s 139 million voters simply left the presidential choice blank.

Advertise with us

Add to these ranks the voters who were not “for” the candidate they voted for so much as they were against the other one. I know many, many evangelical Christians who held their noses and voted for Donald Trump. As one female relative explained, “I chose crude over corrupt.”

These are the people who aren’t buying what the two parties are selling. Watching both sides go at it now, we’re torn between dismay and cynicism. If either wanted to win us over, they’re doing it wrong.

Three weeks ago on “Saturday Night Live,” comedian Aziz Ansari observed, “Yesterday, Trump was inaugurated, today an entire gender protested against him.”

Except we didn’t. Left-wing women did, with their racial and sexual orientation divisions in full flare-up and with language and props so gross that radio talk-show hosts spent Monday and Tuesday fielding calls from people who had to quickly steer their children and grandchildren away from the Washington, D.C., parade route.

Plenty of us deplore how Presidents Donald Trump and Bill Clinton have spoken of and treated women, but that doesn’t mean we want our daughters to channel Lena Dunham or Amy Schumer. How is crude and debasing behavior the solution to crude and debasing behavior?

Advertise with us

Hard on the heels of the “Some Women’s March” came the protests against Mr. Trump’s immigration policy, Cabinet picks and Supreme Court nominee.

Lots of us look at these protests and suspect that, like the women’s march, they are not spontaneous groundswells.

How do 200-plus students from various Pittsburgh high schools make it to Downtown at 7:30 a.m. to march to Sen. Pat Toomey’s office to protest Betsy DeVos’ nomination as education secretary? Probably not without some key adult help. And what do they know of taxes and education policy?

Adult taxpayers know federal education spending has more than doubled since 1970 — not counting the massive spike of the 2010 “stimulus” — without any appreciable improvement in student performance.

We know school quality varies wildly, with the worst schools located in the poorest districts where educational opportunity is especially crucial. The public school system may work for young protesters from Pittsburgh Allderdice and CAPA, but maybe families from Wilkinsburg and Duquesne feel differently about an education secretary who will advocate for school choice.

Advertise with us

It took almost two months of slow growth on social media before CNBC commentator Rick Santelli’s viral rant against the mortgage bailout resulted in a nationwide Tea Party uprising in 2009. Forgive us if lots of us think today’s protests are not grass-roots movements but manufactured “astroturf” — well-orchestrated campaigns from the established activist left.

And what about the other side? While Mr. Trump is, in each contested arena, simply carrying out his campaign promises, it is hard to imagine a more disastrous rollout than he managed with his seven-nation immigration suspension. Turning back airplanes with passengers already holding entry visas — how did that make America any safer?

Rashness and stupidity won’t win over those of us who couldn’t bring ourselves to vote for him three months ago.

We get it. The Democrats have to play to their base now in hopes of thwarting their chief adversary’s agenda and reversing, in 2018, their typically low off-year voter turnout. We uncommitted aren’t going to find the nonstop bile endearing.

Mr. Trump, however, has to satisfy his supporters while somehow winning over the uncommitted and wary middle. If he doesn’t build public support, self-preserving Republican pols will increasingly have to keep their distance. He’ll be unable to govern.

Advertise with us

So far both sides are “doing it wrong,” but Mr. Trump has the more appealing task ahead. The Democrats cannot change course, but if he were to stop tweeting, tone it down, and adopt a more statesmanlike pace — just basically stop being Donald Trump — a relieved public would likely approve.

Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com