Ever since the Puritans fled oppression in England and landed here, only to begin persecuting anyone who dared disagree with them, quarrels about religious liberty have pocked the American landscape.
Roger Williams fled Puritan Massachusetts and founded the future colony of Rhode Island, envisioning a place where “the most Paganish, Jewish, Turkish [Muslim], or anti-Christian consciences and worship be granted to all men.”
That was around 1640. We still haven’t figured it out, have we?
From the Clinton era’s Religious Freedom Restoration and Defense of Marriage acts, to the Obama era’s Hobby Lobby decision, to President Trump’s Supreme Court nominee and proposed repeal of the Johnson Amendment, our political battles and “culture wars” are often about conflicting demands for liberty of conscience.
Having been deeply marked in childhood by one of these cultural skirmishes, I’ve spent a great deal of time pondering exactly when and how everyone could agree to live and let live.
Beneath all the posturing and hot air, most claims of imperiled liberties could be clarified by posing, early and often, one straightforward question: What’s it to you?
In each of the now endless barrage of these conflicts, we should just ask ourselves what each side is demanding of the other. To be allowed to do or not do something? To be forced to act? Why? What’s it to you?
When I attended a Missouri elementary school way back during the Nixon-Ford years, daily alternating music and gym classes were replaced on Fridays with square dancing. As the daughter of a fundamental Baptist minister, I was not allowed to square dance. (I know — how ironic.)
I had it relatively easy, depending on the gym teacher: I either spent the hour reading in the library — joy! — or copying, from books onto 3 by 5 cards, the rules for every playground game known to humankind.
My older sister, however, was forced, as a first-grader, to jump rope alone in the hallway — for a full hour! — while sixth-graders taunted her on their way to lunch. When my parents found out why she came home crying every Friday, my father drove straight to the school and gave the gym teacher a piece of his mind. And attended every PTA Pancake Saturday until we all graduated, just to make the teacher-turned-principal have to shake his hand.
The school was right not to change its practices for a tiny minority and not to compel us to participate in an activity outside our religious tradition, but it was very wrong to punish us kids for our family’s dissent.
I believe many current religious conflicts are similarly clear. Should Little Sisters of the Poor or the devout owners of Hobby Lobby stores be forced, in violation of their religious beliefs, to arrange or subsidize certain kinds of birth control for their employees?
No. The government has no compelling interest in forcing this action upon anyone.
Should those employees, however, be prohibited from acquiring, on their own, those same birth control options, just because some religious people think it’s wrong? No, of course not. Let each party act according to her conscience, free of government’s heavy hand.
In 2006, Neal Gorsuch was approved by the U.S. Senate for the 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals without a single Democrat objecting — including then-senators Barack Obama and Joe Biden, Chuck Schumer, Harry Reid and Dianne Feinstein.
Suddenly, though, Judge Gorsuch is anathema. It was his Hobby Lobby decision the Supreme Court upheld. His other writings seem to indicate a consistent concern for liberty in the face of attempts to compel actions from those whose consciences the actions would violate.
By contrast, with the proposed repeal of the Johnson Amendment, religious nonprofits would regain the freedom to act in ways that have not been allowed since 1954 — when Sen. Lyndon B. Johnson found a way to punish a non-religious nonprofit for daring to support his political rival.
The left is in an uproar: “How repealing the Johnson Amendment could ruin politics” read one headline. As a matter of law, why shouldn’t religious 501(c)(3)s have the same political rights as, oh, trade unions, which are 501(c)(5)s?
It’s clear what’s at stake for the left in this conflict — a current political advantage.
But people and institutions of faith should be careful what they wish for.
While one’s religion often shapes one’s politics, I do not want politics shaping my religion. I don’t want a transcendent faith vulgarized by unnecessary political entanglements.
What’s it to me? Everything. We should be free, but we should remember that sometimes liberty is an open door to disaster.
Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.