How many Americans, I wonder, were surprised by recent news that the country’s abortion rate has fallen to a lower point than it was in 1973?
Count me among them. I was a child when Roe v. Wade was decided, and it never really struck me, in the years since, how common abortion already was when the U.S. Supreme Court made its landmark decision.
You’d think, to judge from competing propaganda, that pre-Roe was a time when few women would ever think to get an abortion and those who did had to obtain them stealthily, in unspeakable conditions.
Neither extreme is true, but the fevered phrases used to promote both the anti-abortion and pro-abortion rights causes can cloud our perception of the past. Does our rhetoric also prevent our seeing a reasonable, more peaceful future?
In 1973, the year of Roe, the abortion rate was already 16.3 per 1,000 women. After peaking in 1981 at 29.3 abortions per 1,000 women, the rate has fallen steadily, reaching a new low of 14.6 in 2014, according to Planned Parenthood-affiliated Guttmacher Institute.
The U.S. Centers for Disease Control had previously reported an even lower rate of 12.5 for 2013, the most recent year it has studied.
The Guttmacher and the CDC use different data-collecting methods, but either method tells me the rhetoric on both sides of this decades-long conflict obscures some important truths — as well as some common ground for hope and cheer.
As for common ground, the early days of the Trump presidency aren’t promising. Pro-abortion rights advocates raise grim scenarios, captured in the Election Night “No abortions!” shrieking of the 14-year-old daughter of ABC News host George Stephanopoulos and Ali Wentworth (as she shared it on “The View”).
At the other end of the spectrum are the flat “Abortion is murder” quotes and placards from Friday’s “March for Life.” Not even the Bible states that, something religiously motivated anti-abortion activists ought to know.
Both real life and the Bible are more nuanced, and so is the thinking of the majority of Americans. Follow the surveys, year in and year out, and you see that those in the center pull away when either extreme seems in the ascendancy: The realities of “partial birth abortion” swelled the anti-abortion ranks in the 1990s, and the possibility of a Supreme Court anti-abortion majority has pro-abortion rights backers nervous now.
So what can we agree on?
First, let’s celebrate the decline in abortions. A majority of us seem to agree at least that abortion is not a good thing. We agree a new life is special and significant — if not sacred — and for a woman to feel compelled to end it is, by many testimonies, a sorrowful and troubling experience. Surely we all desire less sorrow in the world.
While some attribute the continuing decline to growing restrictions, the Guttmacher Institute notes the rapid decline from 2008 to 2011 precedes the recent crop of restrictive state laws. Researchers instead cite the increasing availability and effectiveness of birth control.
It is also possible that decades of anti-abortion activists bearing witness and providing alternatives and support for mothers-to-be have softened hearts and changed minds.
Again, you wouldn’t know it from the rhetoric, but the U.S. abortion laws are among the most lax in the Western world. Many European countries allow abortion only through first trimester except for cases of grave health risk or sexual crime.
Similarly, American polls now indicate a large and growing consensus — as high as 74 percent — to limit abortions to the first trimester.
Pro abortion-rights advocates are quick to point out that 92 percent of all abortions in the U.S. already do occur in the first trimester. But 8 percent, of course, do not, and 1.2 percent occur after 21 weeks.
This means that in 2014, about 74,096 unborn children were aborted at the 14-week mark or later — 11,114 of them after 21 weeks, which is very close to the point of viability outside the womb. This is not the bloodless, chemically-induced shedding of tiny clumps of cells. Do we wish to be a society that casually allows such brutality against helpless human beings? Most of us say no.
America’s trajectory on abortion is a familiar one in human history. Suddenly set “free” of certain moral prohibitions, we plunge into license and libertinism, then soberly assess the tragic devastation and spend many years searching for a way toward the reasonable and good.
We should end the inhumanity of mid- and late-term of abortions, but, anti-abortion advocates, remember: In liberty, love can do what the law cannot.
Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.