At The New York Times, executive editor Dean Baquet says, “We don’t get religion.”

And, if you want evidence of the accuracy of Mr. Baquet’s institutional self-assessment, you need look no further than the Times’ recent article on Jackie Evancho, the young star and Pittsburgh-area resident who will be singing at Donald Trump’s inauguration.

It was during a Dec. 8 interview on NPR when Mr. Baquet made his statement on the entire East Coast media establishment’s failure to comprehend the importance of religion in many Americans’ lives.

“I think that the New York-based and Washington-based … media powerhouses don’t quite get religion,” he said on NPR’s “Fresh Air.”

Advertise with us

“We don’t get religion. We don’t get the role of religion in people’s lives. And I think we can do much, much better.”

The Times’ Evancho story would have been an interesting place to start. The article appeared last week under two different headlines: First, on Jan. 11, “Caught in Media Frenzy, Family Sticks Together,” and the next day, “Juliet and Jackie Evancho, Bonding as Targets in a Trump Media Frenzy.”

While distancing itself from the “frenzy” in its customary analytical tone, the newspaper unfortunately affirms it, by failing to explain, much less question, the assumptions on which the frenzy rests. Those assumptions are fairly anti-religious in nature.

And please note: These religious issues may have nothing to do with the Evancho family, whose religious views are unknown to me and unexplored by the Times.

Nonetheless, here’s what is energizing the “frenzy”:

Advertise with us

“On social media,” reporter Katie Rogers wrote, “where people have a direct line to the sisters’ Twitter and Instagram accounts, a torrent of comments have faulted Jackie for performing for Mr. Trump while having a transgender sister.

“Her critics are homing in on the gay rights record of Mr. Trump’s vice president-elect, Mike Pence, who as governor of Indiana signed into law a religious freedom act that was widely denounced for allowing discrimination against gay people.”

“Widely denounced?” By whom? And does the Indiana law in fact “allow discrimination”?

The Times article does report that sales of Ms. Evancho’s latest album did “rise sharply” after her inauguration appearance was announced. This would seem to indicate a “frenzy” of support for her decision.

Perhaps some of these album buyers are people who would appreciate the safeguarding of their constitutional right to, for instance, not participate in a religious ceremony with which they disagree and to exercise this right without losing everything they own.

Advertise with us

But my example, like the Times article, unnecessarily limits the bigger issues at stake.

Online, the Evancho article links to an op-ed by Gov. Pence, from the March 31, 2015, Wall Street Journal, in which he explains the genesis and necessity of Indiana’s Religious Freedom Restoration Act.

Briefly, the law mirrors the federal RFRA statue — it contains no reference to sexual orientation — and awareness of Indiana’s need for its own version arose from the consequences of the Affordable Care Act, which would have forced employers to provide birth control options that violated their religious beliefs.

According to an essay written by Daniel O. Conkle, an Indiana University law professor (and same-sex marriage supporter), and quoted by Gov. Pence, Indiana’s law “would provide valuable guidance to Indiana courts, directing them to balance religious freedom against competing interests. … It is anything but a ‘license to discriminate,’ and it should not be mischaracterized or dismissed on that basis.”

But The New York Times did just that: It mischaracterized the law and therefore Gov. Pence, an evangelical Christian, as promoters of discrimination.

Advertise with us

Some gay rights advocates — though not all, by any stretch — organized a reasonably large protest and got some high-profile corporations to denounce the law. Polls taken in its immediate aftermath and for a year thereafter showed a slight majority of voters opposing religious freedom laws.

But a January 2017 Marist Poll shows that 65 percent of us — and a majority in every political party — want protection for religious freedom “even when it conflicts with government laws.” That is exactly what the Indiana law was designed to do — “to balance religious freedom against competing interests.”

No part of this matter is simple. There are religious gay rights advocates. There are irreligious people who haven’t figured out a solution on transgender bathroom policies for school districts. Our worlds overlap and collide.

“I think there are things that we can be more creative about to understand the country,” Mr. Baquet said after confessing the Times’ failure to “get religion.”

Nothing terribly creative is needed — just a willingness to report honestly on the messy realities of life and faith.

Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com