“Let’s take our country back!”

The first time I remember hearing that expression was in 2004. I’m certain of the year because it was repeated — either by me or a local university professor — during a weekly panel discussion that was being televised during a presidential campaign.

The only year that fits those details is 2004, and in 2004 this off-putting expression was coming from John Kerry supporters: They were going to take their country back!

“From whom?” I quipped. “Aliens?”

Advertise with us

“Exactly!” the professor gloated.

The gleam in his eye told me he thought he’d won the volley, but to my way of thinking, I had. He had revealed exactly what he thought of what turned out to be, weeks later, a decisive majority of American voters.

In the 2016 election cycle, the roles were reversed. In a brief post-election rumination for the Nov. 21 edition of The New Yorker, comedian Larry Wilmore expresses his chagrin at hearing supporters of Donald Trump (the “mango Mussolini”) chant “Take our country back” and “Make America great again.”

Though he is mere months older than I am, Mr. Wilmore apparently doesn’t remember the Democrats’ chants in the 2004 election cycle, so he ascribes 2016 attitudes to racism rather than to partisanship.

“I wondered who they thought had stolen their country,” he writes. “Well, the chief suspect lives at 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue. It appears that Obama’s biggest mistake was P.W.B., Presidenting While Black.”

Advertise with us

So does that mean George W. Bush’s mistake, inciting Democrats’ chants, was Presidenting While Texan?

No, every eight- or 12-year period delivers a course correction to Washington, D.C. It has ever been thus. But the more extreme the “base” of both parties becomes, the wider the pendulum’s swing and the more polarizing the accompanying rhetoric. Mr. Wilmore’s words don’t seem aimed at closing the chasm.

•

The same day I saw his essay I also opened a fundraising letter from the Benjamin Harrison Presidential Site — the 23rd president’s home and museum in Indianapolis.

In Harrison’s day, the stately brick house was a quiet country retreat, but today it is near the city’s bustling convention center and sees 27,000 visitors per year.

Advertise with us

On the back of the letter was nothing but three small photos of various tour groups — and a quote from Harrison that seems carefully chosen for these fractious times.

“The flag cannot stand for the benevolent policies of an administration. It stands for more permanent things — for things that changing administrations have no power to change.”

These words, and another of Harrison’s thoughts on the necessity of hope to the “good citizen,” reveal him to be quite an optimist. Today, each faction fears that the opposing side’s administration does, in fact, have the power to change things we had thought were permanent, and this fear escalates the rancor of our political discourse.

From his single term in the 1890s, Harrison couldn’t have foreseen the vast expansion of the federal government and the way in which an unresponsive, metastasizing bureaucracy can whittle away at our liberty.

But he is right that the flag stands for permanent things, transcendent things — ideals we should honor and strive to preserve. Doing so would require humility, something that has been in short supply in D.C. for a very long time.

Advertise with us

•

We cannot preserve the good if we won’t call true evil what it is when we see it. Our nation’s changing administrations have often stood in stark contrast but rarely more so than this weekend, at the death of Fidel Castro.

The outgoing administration’s statement focused on continued outreach to Cuba (that is, on President Barack Obama’s legacy) and was therefore determinedly conciliatory in tone — to the point of farce: “History will record and judge the enormous impact of this singular figure [Castro] on the people and world around him.”

Imagine an American president saying that about another of the past century’s despots — Stalin, Hitler, Mao, Pol Pot, Amin, Saddam Hussein, Assad. … That Castro killed fewer people and ravaged a smaller country doesn’t make his victims’ suffering any less tragic and real.

How many more decades will be required for history to judge Castro? None. A mass murderer is dead.

Advertise with us

Donald Trump’s statement balanced hope for the people of Cuba with unvarnished truth about what they have suffered — and who caused it.

I did not vote for either of these presidents, but thank God for some necessary and timely truth-telling. More of that, and only that, please.

Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com