Back from college on fall break last month, my daughter Emma trudged through the door, hugged me and said, “2016 stinks — I want my money back.”

I laughed for a long time and, just as I’ve done ever since my kids could talk, I shared this newest pithy gem with those who might appreciate it — or who would pretend to, indulging my parental pleasure.

But no indulging seemed necessary. The comment apparently resonated. One relative took it a bit further: “Isn’t Emma still in school? I’m assuming she hasn’t contributed much money in 2016. … Wait till she really starts paying in.”

He wasn’t really talking about money, though. Like almost everyone I know, he’s had an unusually difficult year. A year you could be bitter about.

Advertise with us

The list of woes in my immediate circle is long and severe: cancer, unemployment, death of loved ones young and old, failure of relationships, serious surgery, financial setbacks and more cancer.

Framing our personal troubles are the national ones. The entire year has pulsed with a pervasive unease.

Controversial, even inexplicable shootings by police, ambush-style murders of officers by rage-fueled citizens, the unprecedented toxicity of the presidential campaign, the utter untrustworthiness of “news” organizations supposedly providing reliable accounts of all these events. … No matter where we turn, there’s little comfort to be had.

So how do we pull ourselves together and give thanks at the end of a year like 2016? We usually look for the silver lining, of course. We imagine how a particular situation could have been worse and express gratitude that it wasn’t.

Doing dishes a few nights ago with the television yammering behind me, I almost dropped a mug when one young woman’s version of the silver lining — nothing but a quick sound bite — lofted over the ugly din.

Advertise with us

The voice belonged to Diamond Reynolds, who was sitting in the car next to her fiance, Philando Castile, when Officer Jeronimo Yanez shot him to death last July, near Minneapolis. During the fatal traffic stop, her 4-year-old daughter was in the back seat.

In the heartbreaking cell phone video of the shooting’s immediate aftermath that Ms. Reynolds had the presence of mind to live-stream, you can hear her pleading: “Please, Jesus, don’t tell me that he’s gone … .”

But the sound bite I heard three or four days ago was from a news conference-style setting: “It was God that made sure those bullets did not ricochet,” Ms. Reynolds said, “because it could have been all three of us.”

I am astonished by these words. I’m pretty sure I would still be paralyzed by rage. Such a statement of faith, such determination to believe in God’s goodness despite a terrible tragedy is almost beyond comprehension.

Talking with a friend some months ago about a mutual loss, she said something I hear often: “Everything happens for a reason.”

Advertise with us

No, it doesn’t — I knew her well enough to disagree, bluntly. Random stuff happens, accidents, tragedies that a benevolent God doesn’t desire but allows.

That an event has an identifiable cause doesn’t imbue the event with “reason.” We do that. We grope for a purpose that the painful event might serve, an inspiring or ennobling cause it can further in our lives or others’.

Or as my film-enthusiast son Aaron puts it, “We don’t always get to choose our plot points, but we do get to write our own narrative.” Choosing a narrative that’s true and wise is what shapes our destiny, isn’t it?

When I searched online to verify Ms. Reynolds’ words, I also found remarks from Philando Castile’s mother, Valerie, asking for civic peace and vigilance without “outrageous” protests in response to the charges filed against Officer Yanez.

“I’m glad we have come to this chapter,” she said. “It’s a beginning to a different chapter.”

Advertise with us

She clearly expects her son’s death to bring about something good, eventually. She is weaving horrible loss into an optimistic story — a necessary step if triumph over life’s evils is what we seek.

In my faith tradition — and I suspect it’s quite similar to that of these two women — the touchstone Bible verse for this habit of mind is Romans 8:28: “And we know that all things work together for good to them that love God …”

My dad, “The Reverend,” used to illustrate this by saying you wouldn’t find the offer of a cupful of flour or yeast or hot water too appealing, but when those are put together just right, they make very satisfying bread.

The challenge of Thanksgiving week, in a dispiriting year, is to write a grateful narrative, one that will sustain and nourish us more deeply than the table’s bounty.`

Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com