Due to some unusual family circumstances, Election Day found me outside Minneapolis, staying in a friend’s summer home that had been shut down for winter and therefore had no television or Wi-Fi.
In this weird no-tech bubble, I went to sleep at midnight with little more than a grown child’s bewildered text (“How is this happening?”) alerting me to the possibility that Donald Trump might win the White House.
A different bubble prevailed Wednesday, in the seven hours I spent driving from Minneapolis to a Chicago airport, constantly scanning the Midwest’s talk radio frontier. I must have sampled at least 30 stations, and like the ubiquitous, nationally syndicated hosts, the locals were mostly conservatives.
Their moods ranged from cautiously optimistic to ecstatic, from “Surely Mr. Trump will have to tone it down and work with Congress” to “The political landscape has been changed forever!”
Perhaps Mr. Trump’s backtracking Friday on repealing Obamacare burst any happy Republican’s triumphalist bubble. But bubbles, it seems, are the order of the day.
Or maybe you prefer “silo.” Whatever term captures the phenomenon by which any group of Americans is oblivious to the concerns of people not like themselves. In this election, the coastal elites, the media and the Democrats (to be absurdly redundant) utterly missed the discontent of a very motivated voting bloc.
Our bubbles may be due to technology or choice, or to both endlessly feeding each other, but the most ironic I’ve encountered, post-election, is the media bubble.
You know that “You had one job” meme? A road sign that reads “BMUP” or “SHCOOL,” the kid’s backpack with an image of Barbie above the word “Spiderman,” the handicap ramp with three steps at one end …
Yes, well, the national media’s “one job” is to cover the entire nation, fairly and thoroughly. In this election cycle they blew it, epically.
It’s tough to admit you completely missed a historic story and then insist you did your job well, but The New York Times attempted this pretzel posture. An unusual letter released this weekend from the publisher to subscribers acknowledged the election’s “unexpected climax” but wondered if the paper had been misled by Mr. Trump’s “sheer unconventionality.”
It stated, “We believe we reported on both candidates fairly during the presidential campaign” and promised “the same fairness, the same level of scrutiny, the same independence to our coverage of the new president and his team.”
Perhaps this was meant as correction for Times staffers as well, since two Times media critics opined, even while the ballots were still being counted, that their failure was not scrutinizing the two candidates even-handedly: They had gone too easy on Mr. Trump.
But the numbers tell a story different from both the publisher’s account and his staff’s. Joe Concha of The Hill did a simple story count. Remember the mid-October surprises of sexual harassment allegations against Trump and the WikiLeaks release of Clinton campaign chairman John Podesta’s emails? In the following day’s Times there were “11 negative stories on Trump, including one in the sports section,” Mr. Concha wrote, “but zero on Clinton/WikiLeaks,” despite the emails’ shocking contents.
ABC, CBS and NBC did a combined 23 minutes that night (Oct. 14) on the Trump story, with 1 minute 7 seconds devoted to the Clinton story. Mr. Concha also delves into big news outlets’ very lopsided polling questions.
An assessment that seems more logical, all things considered, came from Will Rahn of CBS News:
“With a few exceptions, [the Washington media] were all tacitly or explicitly #WithHer, which has led to a certain anguish in the face of Donald Trump’s victory. More than that and more importantly, we also missed the story, after having spent months mocking the people who had a better sense of what was going on.”
Acknowledging the “mocking” is admirable. People do get tired of being mocked, dismissed, condescended to and bullied. They get tired of having their principled objections to, say, Obamacare or an ever-expanding federal government labeled as racism, meanness or greed.
At some point they will rise up and poke the offenders in the eye. Hence the election.
But now the temptation to live inside a bubble of self-delusion falls on the GOP. If they want to succeed, they must remember that the voters who chose Donald Trump over the establishment Democrat also chose him above a big field of establishment Republicans.
If GOP leaders now think they can retreat into their Beltway bubble and return to business as usual, theirs will be the next bubble the voters pop.
Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.