Ever since the Supreme Court’s historic Tinker v. Des Moines decision in 1969, public school students have had a constitutional right to free speech.

And since, oh, forever, kids have exercised the right to be “dumb” — to borrow an adjective from Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg.

In the 1960s, the issue was the Vietnam War, and the contested “speech” that wound up at the high court was the wearing of black armbands to school in protest.

In 1980, my fellow seniors gathered on the schoolhouse steps to burn an Iranian flag during the hostage crisis. (I was there for the school newspaper.) They weren’t protesting the U.S. government, and they waited till after the final bell, so no one got miffed.

Advertise with us

Today, the issue is perceived racism in some parts of American society, and the free speech in question is kneeling while the national anthem is being played at sporting events.

The protest began in the football preseason, when Colin Kaepernick, a quarterback with the San Francisco 49ers, chose to sit rather than stand as “The Star-Spangled Banner” was played. Afterward, he explained, “I am not going to stand up to show pride in a flag for a country that oppresses black people and people of color.” He modified the protest to kneeling on Sept. 1.

Last Monday Justice Ginsburg deemed such behavior “dumb and disrespectful,” a comment she apologized for on Friday as “inappropriately harsh.”

Mr. Kaepernick’s protest has spread — all the way to Coraopolis and Neville Island, where most of Cornell High School’s cheerleaders knelt during the anthem at the school’s Sept. 30 football game, disconcerting the guests from the local Veterans of Foreign Wars post who were presenting the colors.

An inflammatory video pastiche of the event was disseminated via social media, triggering vitriol and threats of violence from viewers and commenters around the country, which in turn prompted principal Aaron Thomas to reschedule, and highly limit access to, last Friday’s homecoming game.

Advertise with us

If Justice Ginsburg was right the first time and the symbolic protest is “disrespectful and dumb,” then the video and ugly backlash prove that those qualities are contagious across racial and ideological divides.

At least we are united in stupidity, right?

I don’t think the gesture is “dumb,” though. I find it wrong-headed and counterproductive, yes, but not dumb. The people involved are thinking about something important and are forcing others to as well — if in an off-putting and divisive way.

In an article about a singer who took it a step further and decided to kneel while singing the anthem, Billboard magazine claimed “countless athletes and celebrities” have joined Mr. Kaepernick’s protest. I’m betting they can actually be counted, but their jumping on this bandwagon comes as no surprise: It’s what celebrities do to “keep it real” despite their incredible privilege.

I have more sympathy for teenagers who join in, like the cheerleaders at Cornell High School. That’s what teenagers do. They try on ideas and personas, test boundaries and make grand pronouncements, some of which will probably strike their seasoned elders as ridiculous.

Advertise with us

With a little more thought, though, the cheerleaders might have reached a different decision. They will cheer for their public school and the game of football, but they take no pride in the country in which these blessings exist?

I also feel sympathetic toward the man with whom it all started, Colin Kaepernick.

It is pertinent, I think, that his birth mother is white, the absentee birth father is black and his adoptive parents are white. In a time of racial unrest, what does it feel like to have both “sides” of a conflict present within your very body? In your understanding of who you are?

Like teenagers, perhaps Mr. Kaepernick is still working it all out, but his assertion that the United States “oppresses” people of color is not true and has not been for decades.

America has been on the path of repentance for our original sin — slavery — for more than 150 years now, and the transformation of society just since the 1960s’ triumph of the civil rights movement is astonishing.

Advertise with us

But America has a very specific problem in the disproportionate stopping, arrest, incarceration and punishment of black men. The narrative of racial unrest should not, however, include a broad generalization about white officers killing unarmed black men, because the tragic facts — about both officers and victims — are too varied to support it.

The truth is always more complicated than simplistic gestures could possibly capture. And the simplistic, no matter how sincere, usually takes us further away from a healthy solution, not closer.

Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com