Media coverage of this election is about anything but the issues, because that’s the way Hillary Clinton needs it to go. She needs as much of the talk as possible to be about women in general so it can be about one woman in particular. Her.
If the election focused on matters of substance, especially domestic issues, either of the men running — faux Republican Donald Trump or true libertarian Gary Johnson — would likely win.
That’s because in poll after poll throughout most of President Barack Obama’s second term in office, a consistent majority of Americans — usually 60 to 70 percent — have said they believe the country is headed in the wrong direction. Change is what we want.
Since Ms. Clinton would provide essentially a third Obama term, but without the competence or glamour, the only change she can deliver is gender. That’s why the spotlight must stay on her female-ness vs. Mr. Trump’s cartoonish love-dis-marry-taunt-hire-woo relationship with the female sex. (He is nothing if not mercurial.)
If the conversation stays here, Hillary wins, representing all women as both victim and victor.
Given this narrow path to the White House, Ms. Clinton also needs to keep the contest between her and Mr. Trump only, because Gary Johnson has no tortured history with women. (Some might say he has a tortured relationship with basic facts — where Aleppo is, who his favorite foreign leader is — but why didn’t that matter when candidate Obama said he had been to 57 of the American states?)
The old guard, left-leaning mainstream media are obliging Ms. Clinton, but so are Apple news feeds, Google algorithms and the Twitter-verse. Is this due to media bias, media laziness or everyone’s shallowness?
That last option is certainly possible, because these days we all fit Andy Warhol’s description of himself: “deeply superficial.” If we weren’t, we would be asking ourselves which of the candidates really has the worst record when it comes to “women.”
I use quote marks because media coverage of women’s issues since the 1970s has assumed that we — 51 percent of the nation’s population — all think alike. That we experience the world in the same way, embrace the same priorities and values, have the same goals and choose our president to meet the same needs.
Besides the tendency to see people in large, homogeneous groups, another leftist hallmark of news coverage of “women’s issues” is the assumption that all women are looking to government to meet needs and solve problems. Not all women think like that; those who do, vote for Democrats.
How any of us — male or female — thinks about the economy, immigration, religious liberty, foreign affairs, etc., will depend in large part on our life experiences.
And if we were an international beauty pageant winner who gained a lot of weight and got slammed by Donald Trump — or was it praised and supported by him? — then enlisted by the Democratic Party to air only one side of the story, we would have a very different take on this election and on women’s issues than, say, Juanita Broaddrick or Kathleen Willey or Paula Jones or Lani Guinier or Kimba Wood. Or Monica Lewinsky.
Who are these women, you ask if you are under 40? They are the best-known of the women chewed up and spat out by the 1990s Clinton White House. If they were victims of Bill Clinton’s sexual appetites, they were gutted by Hillary Clinton as “bimbos,” trailer-park trash and worse. If they were not Bill’s sexual targets but choices for federal appointments who were too weak to succeed, they were hung out to dry, shunned by the Clintons and banished from the capital — no matter how old their friendships with the former first family.
There are those who profess to value and look out for “the people” but have little use for flesh-and-blood humans, beyond their own selfish needs.
In this regard, Donald Trump is not unlike Hillary Clinton. He’s just less hypocritical about it. His callousness and rapacity are more open because he has less self-control. Having started at a higher rung on America’s socio-economic ladder, he has never needed the discipline Ms. Clinton has acquired through a lifetime of male disrespect and the consequences of her own astonishing dearth of talent.
A candidate’s character is not a minor issue, but given the two major candidates’ pot-kettle equivalency on how they treat women, we can either insist they move on to other matters, or we can point out that when it comes to character, the third-party candidate wins.
Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.