“We were so close.”

After one of the most harrowing weeks in recent American life, these are the words that haunt me.

Though they could have been uttered after any race-related tragedy of the past decade or so, I heard them Friday night from Pittsburgh newsman Ellis Cannon.

He’d heard them a year or two ago from the lips of his elderly mother, though he can’t quite remember when.

Advertise with us

Was it after Ferguson, or Charleston, or Baltimore? The tragedies merge into one endless open wound. Last week it was Baton Rouge, St. Paul and Dallas.

We use place names because they are more neutral than victims’ or perpetrators’ names, and because in some places — Charleston and Dallas — the list of victims is so long.

Whichever it was back then, Mr. Cannon alerted his mother one morning to what she’d be seeing on the news all day long. Her simple, sad summation of a nation’s turmoil: “We were so close.”

We were so close to unity and equality. Long-hoped-for healing from centuries of slavery and racial oppression seemed to be within reach. When did our course reverse, and why? The reasons are complex and tangled.

We were so close, and we will have to keep our hearts and minds open if we want to draw close again. No single slogan or narrative can encompass the facts of these individual tragedies. No single solution will prevent them.

Advertise with us

Our nation’s primary cultural narrative is the black-and-white racism that is slavery’s tragic legacy. We turn to it, even though our modern reality and the facts of these tragedies are diverse.

The Dallas shooter said he wanted to kill white officers, but one of the five he murdered was Mexican-American. The officer who shot and killed Philando Castile in a St. Paul, Minn., suburb — Jeronimo Yanez — is Latino. Three of the six Baltimore officers originally charged in the death of Freddie Gray are black.

Are or were they racists?

With so many recent incidents captured on video, what has shocked Americans is how quickly and incomprehensibly an encounter over a minor traffic offense can escalate to fatal shooting. Again, is racism alone driving these events? Or is some other factor at work, too?

The possibility that racism provokes more encounters between police and black men certainly has to be addressed, but I think a powerful, unexamined force plaguing all of us is fear.

Advertise with us

Not just blacks’ fear of police, or officers’ fear of violent citizens of any ethnicity, but also a fear that is contagious, multifaceted and pervasive.

And in a culture that disdains fear as weakness, fear’s disguise is anger.

Americans have been on edge pretty much since 9/​11, but the threat of terrorism is a low-level undercurrent compared to the daily struggles so many have faced for so much of the new millennium.

The nation’s economy has suffered two serious downturns, and as the saying “last hired, first fired” tells us, the people hurt worst in bad times are those who were newest to prosperity.

Men have suffered more than women, and young black men have taken the worst hit. Anyone who has endured lengthy joblessness can attest that there are few fears worse than the possibility that you will never be employed, never be able to support yourself, never have the self-respect that comes from making a contribution to society, never be valued.

Advertise with us

Fearful times are dangerous times, because fear hardens our divisions.

We were so close, but what many people seem on the verge of right now is the loss of hope.

“We’re hurting,” said Dallas police Chief David Brown late Thursday night. “We are heartbroken. There are no words to describe the atrocity that occurred to our city. All I know is that this must stop — this divisiveness between our police and our citizens.”

How do we stop it? How do we heal all that divides us?

We can’t count on political leadership — especially not this year — but the answer is leadership of all kinds, everywhere, at every level of society.

Advertise with us

We were so close. We could be still, if business owners, faith leaders, movement organizers, artists, millionaires, coupon shoppers — all of us — make intentional choices to add jobs, launch programs, give till it pinches, express love in myriad practical acts.

The Dallas police chief, with a riveting directness and spiritual depth, asked: “Can we, in a moment of crisis … forgive? Can we disagree without demonizing? I believe we can.”

We can, and we must.

Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com.