Truth is the daughter of time.” This is one of the very few bits of wisdom I have picked up from four decades (and counting) spent reading as many mysteries and thrillers as work and family obligations permit.
It’s identified on a preface page of Josephine Tey’s great mystery novel “The Daughter of Time” as an “old proverb.” But it is not only that.
It is part of a sentence from “On Truth,” an essay by Francis Bacon (the 16th-century philosopher, not the 20th-century painter). The sentence reads in full: “Truth is the daughter of time, not of authority.”
The truth will out, in other words, but maybe the longer version needs another addition for us moderns: “Truth is the daughter of time, not of authority, nor of crowds.”
You may have to be an optimist to believe it’s still true, though, because modern life seems increasingly swayed by mob psychology — “the madness of crowds” — whether at a zoo or a political rally.
In this bizarre political year, we’ve seen actual, physical crowds erupt too often for comfort. We see it inside and outside Donald Trump’s events: His supporters seem in the grip of reason-free passions, but his protesters are even scarier.
We see crowd psychology at work at Bernie Sanders’ rallies, too, but only inside, where the believers are. Outside the rally, no one’s gonna bother to show up to protest a philosophy — Europe’s “socialism lite” — that is proved a failure every day by, well, Europe.
Where we don’t see masses running amok is at a Hillary Clinton event. This is because her supporters have had to do so much rationalizing and explaining away that their brains are actually quite engaged, if not their consciences. Cynicism requires reasoning, however warped.
Mobs like simpler projects. The distance from incident to uprising is ideally just one step. Technology has made it vastly easier. Today’s torches and pitchforks are Facebook pages and Twitter accounts.
Search the internet with a term like “Twitter outrage” and you’ll find mob action aplenty. In December 2014, Slate magazine did a year-in-review “rage-a-day calendar” cataloging outrage over everything from Sarah Palin’s Obamacare version of “Green Eggs and Ham” to the German magazine that published a photo of Kate Middleton’s bare tush.
Most modern outrage centers around incidents that the people I know would agree don’t matter one bit. Digital mobs get scarier, though, when they form in response to an alleged crime or violent incident. When the goal is to push the justice system in whatever direction the mob fancies, there’s the potential for real harm to real people.
Real harm to humans seemed possible in the immediate aftermath of the gorilla shooting at the Cincinnati Zoo last month. A “Justice for Harambe” page appeared on Facebook. People called for the arrest of the parents of the little boy who somehow got into Harambe’s enclosure, for prosecution of zoo officials for deciding to kill the gorilla, and for the closing of zoos everywhere.
But truth is the daughter of time. Good, old dead-tree journalists took the time to ask zoo officials in other cities what they would have done if a 450-pound gorilla was flipping around a 3-year-old boy like a rag doll. Here in Pittsburgh they said, with regret, that they, too, would have killed the gorilla.
The police will now investigate the family’s actions prior to the incident to see if a charge such as child neglect is warranted.
Which takes time. The Twitter-verse and internet trolls will have moved on to the next outrage.
Anyone and everyone who has resisted a rush to judgment, however, deserves commendation. At this point in history, insisting on due deliberation — insisting on taking time — is tantamount to taking a heroic stand for truth.
By the way, the second wisest thing I’ve ever learned from a mystery novel is also from Josephine Tey, this time “The Franchise Affair.”
Two people are discussing a rather murky alleged crime. One insists that it must be true because an account of it was published in a tabloid. The other thinks, but does not say, “This was the democracy we deified.”
It’s a wry reminder to be careful about what we enthrone as the repository of our fondest hopes for mankind. Mobs are another reminder of the frailty and fallibility of all human endeavors — as if, in 2016, we needed reminding.
Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.