When North Carolina passed a law in March requiring citizens to use the bathroom that matches their gender at birth, the state’s conservative activism may have struck the nation’s jobs-preoccupied centrists as guilty of pre-emptively picking a fight.
Which is not actually a very conservative move. In the modern era, conservatives, by definition, usually play defense.
While pre-emptively taking a stand on this gender issue can be read as a reaction to the Supreme Court’s sweeping same-sex marriage decision, the North Carolina law still seemed rash.
But Friday’s sweeping “directive” instructing schools to allow students to use bathrooms based on their gender identity demonstrates that conservatives were correct in anticipating the heavy hand of federal overreach.
As The New York Times noted, the federal directive “does not have the force of law, but it contains an implicit threat: … lawsuits or a loss of federal aid.”
As per usual, then, the Obama administration has chosen muscle over persuasion. This is bullying just as surely as the we’ll-choose-your-bathroom-for-you position is.
So with the hyper-political types on each side having staked out an extreme, maybe more reasonable people can now find a way through this strange new world. For most of us, it is fraught and perplexing.
A new CNN survey (of merely 1,001 adults) finds that Americans oppose laws like North Carolina’s by 57 to 38 percent. And besides the small sample, the survey did not ask specifically about children or schools.
Reasonable adults can handle unisex bathrooms. Beyond the one-at-a-time type you find everywhere, there’s the large-scale version I first encountered at a New York City restaurant seven years ago: no gender-specific signs, just private stalls on three sides of the room, with a row of sinks on the fourth, to be shared by all.
I did not hesitate, but I would not have sent my 13-year-old daughter in there unaccompanied.
More to the point — and everyone is avoiding these specifics — who would want to send a female-to-male transitioning teen into a high school men’s room, with the exposure of public urinals?
All teenagers are fumbling their way through puberty, identity issues and sexual awakening. No matter whether they are straight, gay, transgender or uncertain, they are not helped by either disrespect or humiliation.
What can we require of our children, and at what age?
Those are tough questions to answer, but neither North Carolina nor the Obama administration is getting it right.
The truly conservative position — caution and compassion — makes sense here. So does allowing each district to work out a policy with parents’ input and without federal bullying.
And since transgender people of all ages total only about 700,000 in a nation of 319 million, we ought to be able to summon the kindness and good manners as conflicts arise and as we do due diligence.
Ideologues at either extreme are wrong. The traditionalists who insist gender identification and physical anatomy are synonymous cannot have met or listened to any transgender teens like, say, Dakota Yorke, runner-up prom queen in Portage, Ind.
And trans advocates ignoring the mixed and still-emerging scientific research into the causes of transgender — studies of identical twins, of brain function, of depression and suicide rates, etc. — should hesitate to thrust vulnerable people into volatile social situations. They should also respect the rights of non-trans teens.
Where people stand on the “bathroom issue” does not fit any of the neat, pre-ordained religious and political boxes you’d expect from government maneuvers to date.
The young adult children of a family I know well — who are non-religious, athletically gifted and conscientiously inclusive — nonetheless asserted recently that they would never have felt comfortable with transgender classmates in their locker rooms. They view the red states’ anticipatory legislation as reasonable and a federal mandate as tyranny.
My first encounter with gender-fluid peers was in 1982 when a male classmate brought a date to our professors’ dinner party, but the pretty female “date,” we later learned, was our classmate’s younger brother. The professor, a staunch liberal, was deeply offended.
These matters both lie deeper than and go far beyond politics. What people say in private conversation and what they tell pollsters may be quite different. And when it comes to school policy, those who should have the greatest say are those most affected by the decisions — kids of all kinds and their parents.
Time to adapt and tolerance for all will be needed — as well as building contractors.
Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.