When a friend surprised me with a beagle puppy for my birthday 14 years ago, I fell in love instantly. Toby-Wan Kenobi, as my kids dubbed him, spent much of his first year in my lap.

Last Tuesday, in pain and almost unable to walk, Toby was difficult to carry when my son Alex and I took him to their old cross-country training destination atop Spring Hill, where we held him for photos and one last look at the Pittsburgh skyline.

And we both had our arms around him Wednesday, weeping as the veterinarian put him to sleep.

We love our animals, don’t we? They bring us so much pleasure. How we treat them says a lot about us.

Advertise with us

I’m willing to assume, then, that the people who want to outlaw circuses in Pittsburgh are acting from a lovely place in their souls. The problem is that the effort, as revealed in the ordinance proposed last week, is far more emotion than logic.

In its very first “whereas,” the ordinance asserts that performing animals learn their acts through “extreme coercion techniques.” Spokesmen for both the Ringling and the Shrine Circuses said this is not true: They use only “positive reinforcement” (Ringling). The animals are “like family to us” (Shrine).

The circuses’ assertions are likelier to be true: It would not make sense to mistreat their animals since an angry animal’s nearest potential victims are its human handlers. I bet they love their animals like we do.

Pittsburgh’s legislation doesn’t attempt to prove its claim of harm, though, topping it instead with another “whereas” that asserts authorities cannot properly monitor the animals’ treatment or “follow up on previous infractions.”

What infractions? Isn’t this inflicting punishment without bothering to prove a crime?

Advertise with us

And the punishment would hurt more than just a couple of businesses. Since the Shrine Circus raises money to cover free medical care provided by Shriners’ hospitals, a ban by “progressive” Pittsburgh would hurt children in need. Progress, indeed.

The ordinance rests on a lot of anthropomorphizing, but the projection of human thoughts and feelings onto the animals is very one-sided. Let’s consider the other side.

If wild animals suffer stress from too much travel, boring repetition and lack of free-range exercise (what we humans call “having a job”), why wouldn’t the stress be offset (as it is for humans) by the satisfaction of earning one’s meals and helping needy children?

Maybe some wild animals allegedly enduring “psychological problems” would find their spirits lifted by knowing that they’re helping sick kids.

Maybe some have a hammy side that finds its truest expression when making people laugh. Maybe some of them love being the comedians and acrobats of the animal kingdom, and they can’t believe that’s all they have to do to ensure physical safety and plentiful food.

Advertise with us

The anti-circus movement assumes that “the wild” is a wonderful place. Doesn’t this Rousseau-ian view of benevolent nature get debunked with every episode of “Animal Planet”?

Maybe some of the slower herd members who got caught by humans are relieved to be playing instead of being prey.

Maybe some wild animals just aren’t that wild about the wild.

Are any non-humans able to comprehend or participate in moral good? If not — if dancing bears wouldn’t feel better knowing their act is for a good cause — what justifies our assumption that dogs enjoy being trained as police officers and put at risk for much, much worse than twirling injuries?

How can we justify training some as seeing-eye dogs or letting some humans carry around other small species as “emotional support”? Isn’t all of this “using” them for human interests?

Advertise with us

It is. So where do we draw the line? Will zoos be banned next?

Toby “the Wonder Beagle” existed for no other reason than to delight my family.

Beagles are hounds, and therefore natural hunters. Since I do not hunt, was I mistreating Toby by not allowing him to fulfill his biological nature? When he found a bird carcass in the yard, was I abusing him by wrestling it from his jaws?

Was he angry or sorrowful about this? Who knows?

What I do know is that the first time we left him at a kennel during vacation, all three kids got on the floor to play with him and hug him goodbye.

Advertise with us

The staffer remarked, “In my next life I want to come back as these kids’ pet!”

We are not going to agree about what “uses” animals can fulfill, nor know what they “think.” Ensuring kind treatment and letting people choose for themselves — now that would be progress.

Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com