Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Wolf comes across as a reasonable fellow and managed to do so even during the long months of intransigence on the state budget.
Whether it’s the mild voice or the imperturbable face, I can’t say, but there’s definitely a difference between seeming reasonable and being reasonable.
Recent days have brought two significant decisions from the governor, one of which most people will welcome. The other reveals Mr. Wolf as a hardliner, moving away from America’s reasonable mainstream.
His executive orders to prohibit discrimination of any kind by the state or its contractors, but particularly discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation, were announced Thursday, with the governor noting that he was taking this step because the Legislature hadn’t moved quickly enough.
On the other hand, he announced he would veto a pro-life bill fast-tracked by House Republicans that would prohibit abortions after the 20th week of pregnancy (instead of the current 24).
So Mr. Wolf moves unilaterally to stymie the Legislature when it moves too fast for his liking and moves to circumvent it when it moves too slowly.
He’s the Goldilocks of governors: Not too fast, not too slow — he wants them to move just right.
Though some may decry the governor’s methods, I can’t imagine that many people will argue with the substance of the anti-discrimination bill — yet. The devil — or God, or the truth — is in the details, as all those old saws go.
In explaining his executive orders, the governor cited North Carolina’s rash legislation, which instituted a statewide ban on discrimination without including sexual orientation or gender identity and prohibited municipalities from passing their own potentially contradictory ordinances. He also could have cited an ill-considered bill in Mississippi that began as protection for ministers who decline to perform same-sex marriages but ended up far too sweeping in scope to either make sense or withstand legal challenge.
So, while most Pennsylvanians would probably agree that the LGBT population needs protection from discrimination, they might also wonder if a little more due diligence is in fact necessary to produce a better bill than other states have managed.
As for the slower-than-Wolf-approved pace, the state Senate’s Government Committee chairman, Mike Folmer, said he wants to make sure the bill doesn’t violate religious liberty.
Because Mr. Wolf’s executive order covers “contractors and grantees,” faith-based organizations might now be excluded from state contracts and grants if they hew to traditional theology on, say, same-sex marriage.
Respect for all persons includes respect for our constitutional freedom of religion.
It also includes respect for unborn life — and on this issue the governor is clearly out of the reasonable mainstream.
To support his promised veto of a bill that would prohibit abortions after the 20th week of pregnancy, Mr. Wolf cited a U.S. District Court decision — from 1975. Public opinion and medical technology have changed dramatically in four decades, and so have our laws.
According to the Planned Parenthood-affiliated Guttmacher Institute, 20 states now prohibit abortions after a certain number of weeks, with 12 of those states drawing the line at 20 weeks. These restrictions are in keeping with changing social values.
The Gallup poll has been measuring opinion on many aspects of abortion rights for 40 years, asking more detailed questions as the years have gone by. A sudden mid-1990s surge in pro-life ranks was followed by years of steady growth, so that by 2009 the electorate was pretty evenly divided between those self-identifying as “pro choice” and “pro life.”
Beyond this now-consistent split, however, a majority of us report dissatisfaction with current laws and desire greater restrictions on abortion. We oppose “partial-birth abortions” performed past the first trimester by a margin of 2-1.
In short, Pennsylvania legislators’ latest pro-life bill is right in step with public opinion. Mr. Wolf’s promised veto is not.
Whether the executive orders and the pro-life bill are moving too fast or too slow, you have to wonder why they happen to be moving at all right now. Well, the state primary looms, and both sides are trying to keep their bases mobilized, their voters’ blood stirring.
They may also be acting from sincere motivations of conscience and the desire to represent their constituents’ will.
Whichever it is — partisan political need, conscience, the citizens’ will, or some combination of the three — Mr. Wolf’s actions aren’t as reasonable and judicious as his mild-guy manner would lead you to believe.
Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.