In August 1992, six U.S. marshals set out to arrest Idaho survivalist Randy Weaver over a missed court date on a firearms charge, partly caused by a clerical error. What followed was an 11-day standoff and three deaths, including a federal officer.
The siege became known as “Ruby Ridge” and triggered calls for reform, particularly from the right. Today, ICE raids that too often end in violence are generating similar calls for reform, particularly from the left.
Congressional efforts to find bipartisan agreement on safeguards can draw inspiration from the reforms Ruby Ridge spurred. Those changes allow federal agents to keep enforcing the law while better protecting constitutional rights.
The FBI needed to change
Senate hearings in 1995 revealed breakdowns in command structure, communication, and rules of engagement.
The Justice Department’s internal review found that the FBI’s rules of engagement — which effectively authorized shooting armed adult males on sight — violated both department policy and constitutional standards. Officials were deemed “remarkably uncritical” in approving those rules. The operations commander had exercised “inadequate control.”
These findings led to concrete changes. The FBI revised its deadly force policy to permit lethal force only when imminent danger of death or serious bodily harm exists, and no reasonable alternative is available — a standard closer to civilian policing.
The bureau reformed its Hostage Rescue Team deployment, requiring clearer authorization and better local coordination, and established rigorous protocols for critical incident management. The U.S. Marshals Service and the Justice Department followed with improved training, clearer multi-agency guidelines, and stronger oversight for sensitive operations.
These reforms recognized that even legitimate law enforcement must operate within constitutional bounds.
Unconstitutional actions
Fast-forward to 2025, and similar constitutional concerns have emerged around immigration enforcement.
For example, ICE routinely uses administrative warrants signed by immigration officials rather than judges. Unlike criminal warrants requiring judicial review under the Fourth Amendment’s probable cause standard, these administrative warrants are issued by ICE staff and need not be approved by a neutral magistrate. Agency rules do not even require that staff issuing them be attorneys.
Letting federal agents enter homes based on paperwork they issued themselves eliminates a critical check the Founders built into the Constitution. The Fourth Amendment does not distinguish between citizens and non-citizens, and the Supreme Court has consistently held its protections apply to everyone on U.S. soil.
Similarly, recent reports of heavily armed tactical teams deployed for civil immigration violations echo the criticisms leveled at the FBI three decades ago. But while post-Ruby Ridge reforms subjected federal law enforcement to enhanced scrutiny and rigorous training, ICE officers as a whole have considerably less oversight and training.
ICE has internal use-of-force policies modeled on those of local police departments, but the majority of ICE agents have not been using body-worn cameras. Independent accountability is scant. A review by a nonprofit news organization found that in six of 12 shootings by federal immigration agents causing death or injury since September 2025, local police conducted no investigation.
Ruby Ridge taught us — painfully — that “just following orders” and “enforcing the law” are insufficient justifications when constitutional safeguards are ignored. Those protections matter most when enforcement feels most urgent and when those targeted are least popular, whether a self-proclaimed white separatist like Weaver or those suspected of being here illegally.
Learning the lessons
Drawing on policymakers’ response to Ruby Ridge, Congress must now translate lessons from ICE’s overreach into concrete reform.
Judicial review of warrants isn’t a technicality. It’s the difference between a government of laws and a government of men.
Proportionate use of force isn’t an obstacle to effective enforcement. It’s what keeps enforcement legitimate.
Proper oversight and clear rules of engagement protect both the public and the officers themselves.
Some activists after Ruby Ridge believed that there should be no gun laws and some activists now believe there should be no limits on immigration. Most Americans understand the need to enforce laws of every type, but want it done professionally and constitutionally.
Ruby Ridge was a tragic stain on federal law enforcement, but it proved we could learn from our mistakes and insist on a better, more accountable approach. Now we must do it again.
Marc A. Levin (mlevin@counciloncj.org) is chief policy counsel and Khalil Cumberbatch (khalil@counciloncj.org) is director of engagement and partnerships at the Centering Justice Initiative.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.