In the play “Hamlet,” Claudius has murdered his brother, Prince Hamlet’s father, to take the throne of Denmark. In a moment of dramatic irony, he boasts that a divine protective force keeps monarchs like him safe from harm. “There’s such a divinity that protects a king.”
For too long Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor, King Charles’ disgraced younger brother, has been protected by the British establishment from the consequences of his actions or possible misdeeds.
Until his arrest by police on his 66th birthday on suspicion of “misconduct in public office.” One of the foundational principles of the rule of law is the legal maxim, “Be ye never so high, the law is above you.”
Andrew on notice
A charge or a court action does not automatically follow an arrest. Another foundational principle of the rule of law is the assumption of innocence unless proven guilty. But what does it do, especially in combination with the release of the Epstein files?
It puts Andrew on notice that he can no longer tell untruths about a relationship with Jeffrey Epstein that continued long after the financier was convicted and imprisoned for procuring a minor.
Release of the Epstein files has shredded his own airbrushed account of that friendship. It raises doubts about his credibility in a notorious BBC television interview where he denied having sex with Virginia Giuffre, a minor procured by Epstein and his accomplice Ghislaine Maxwell. The consequences of legal perjury for Andrew would be dire.
Andrew’s cup of misery is overflowing. Allegations related to the Epstein files are that he forwarded confidential reports to the financier while he was a trade envoy for the UK. Former Prime Minister Gordon Brown has demanded that police investigate him as an accessory or witness to Epstein’s use of London’s Stansted and Luton airports to traffic women and girls.
Andrew’s vices have been hiding in plain sight for many years, too, and have been ignored.
Andrew’s hidden vices
In my time working at the Sunday Times newspaper we revealed in 2007 that an unknown Kazakh oligarch had bought the then prince’s former home of Sunninghill Park for £3 million ($4 million) above the asking price and an estimated £7 million more than the property’s market value.
Made an official trade envoy by Prime Minister Tony Blair to indulge his mother, the late Queen Elizabeth II, Andrew had become patron of the British-Kazakh Society jointly with the country’s dictator, Nursultan Nazarbayev. The sale has been subsequently linked to a Kazakh money laundering scheme, but at the time Andrew refused to make any inquiries into the cause of his good fortune.
Deference to his mother, an icon of respectability, lay at the heart of it. Who at the time was policing the border between Andrew’s official duties and his financial affairs? Now it is alleged that his access to foreign leaders and financiers may have helped Epstein, too.
Some mothers are blind to the faults of their children. Andrew was the late Queen’s favorite. When Giuffre sued him in a New York court, accusing him of sexual assault, the Queen provided £7 million toward his £12 million out-of-court settlement, topped up with £3 million from her husband’s estate. Andrew strenuously denied all the charges at the time and still does.
Prime Minister Keir Starmer, his own tenure of office in jeopardy after a series of scandalous appointments, is vulnerable to the accusation that he tolerates a “boy’s club” at No. 10. He won’t be providing any protection. Mountbatten-Windsor’s brother the King declares that “the law must take its course.”
Can the monarchy survive the scandal? The cynics will reply that the damage caused by Andrew to the Royal Family is catastrophic, but not serious. After all, the monarchy has been surviving scandals for decades, even centuries.
The memory of Queen Victoria’s “wicked uncles,” a notably bad lot, was soon erased by her virtuous marriage to Prince Albert, a pillar of Germanic rectitude and intellectual high seriousness. Edward VII’s fondness for actresses and horses never did the institution much harm, and his grandson Edward VIII’s abdication in 1936 to marry an American divorcee preserved bourgeois propriety and yet gifted the world a glamorous royal love story.
Andrew’s vices exposed
The collapse of Charles’ fairytale marriage to Princess Diana only enhanced the marketability of an institution the royal family calls “The Firm.”
Andrew’s vices and those of his ex-wife, Sarah Ferguson, may do the same. They provide a perfect foil to the goody-two-shoes couple of his nephew William and wife Catherine, the Prince and Princess of Wales — or at least to their well-polished public image.
The great Victorian authority on the British constitution, Walter Bagehot, warned that exposure of the workings of the monarchy would let “daylight in on magic.” He didn’t foresee that the public’s hunger for a sacrificial Epstein villain might become an essential part of the performance.
Still, the cynics may have underestimated how this scandal trumps them all. We may hear more about Andrew’s unwise choice of company — allegedly including a Chinese spy — and the extent of his involvement in Epstein’s network at home and abroad.
Unless he clears his name, the late Queen’s intervention in settling Andrew’s court case will increasingly look to the public like the payment of hush money. And you don’t have to be a moralist to worry that it took allegations about profiteering, not the cries of alleged victims, to bring Andrew to the attention of police.
Martin Ivens is the editor of the Times Literary Supplement and was previously the editor of the Sunday Times of London.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.