A Target shopper videoed himself finding torn-off prices and price increases by as much as 75%, while Walmart shoppers also found prices removed and a markup of 60%.
Removing posted price tags lets retailers introduce “dynamic pricing,” a form of AI-driven automated pricing combining digital surveillance of consumers and their spending habits with relentless corporate profit-seeking.
Continuous adjustment
With dynamic pricing, stores can change electronic prices instantaneously, allowing them to deploy strategies like “surge pricing,” when prices increase during a window of increased consumer demand.
Product prices continuously adjust — sometimes within minutes — in response to real-time supply and demand. Proponents claim that it allows precision based on various factors, such as current market demand, seasonal fluctuations, and supply changes.
Amazon has already started deploying a type of dynamic pricing in which price levels change based on user-specific data. Its algorithms analyze browsing history, spending habits, credit scores, location, physical and mental health indicators, and more data to tailor prices to each individual.
Using your personal data, a seller like Amazon can predict your “pain point,” the most money that you are willing to spend on a particular good or service. You won’t even realize that you are being charged higher prices than another person.
Lina Khan, former chair of the FTC, reports that consumer watchdogs have found different people being charged higher prices for products, ranging from test prep services, an Uber ride, hotel rooms, to Internet connection services. The decisive factors used to raise prices included characteristics like one’s race, home city and the wealth of one’s neighborhood.
Potential for abuse
This capacity has alarming potential for manipulation and abuse, particularly when there are no more price tags showing public prices and no one can actually see what anything costs.
Using automated pricing based on consumers’ psychographic profiles opens a Pandora’s box of charging different prices based on race, religion, nationality, or gender. Doing so would be illegal, but how would a consumer know what algorithmic criteria are being used for the prices they are paying?
In 2024, U.S. Senator Sherrod Brown called on Walmart and Amazon to better explain their use of these automated, AI-driven pricing systems. He was concerned, he said, “by how corporations may use customers’ web browsing data to engage in discriminatory pricing [that] may lead to higher prices for individuals or families based on variables including a customer’s location or other sensitive personal data.”
Generally, it is legal for a store to charge different prices to different customers for the same item. But as consumers shop for their school supplies, groceries and other essential goods, this kind of pricing behavior is starting to make some angry.
There is a deep sense that businesses should not be able to weaponize a consumer’s own data against her or him. Something about this practice seems unethical and unfair, and potentially discriminatory.
Consumers on their own
So far, federal and state governments have been mostly AWOL. Consumers have been left on their own to figure all of this out.
As chair of the FTC during the Biden administration, Lina Khan launched a study to investigate surveillance pricing, gathering information from eight companies about their collection and use of private data to charge Americans different prices for the same product.
The Trump White House has not released the report. Meanwhile, legislators in Georgia, Colorado, Illinois, and California have introduced bills to ban surveillance pricing.
Meanwhile, consumers see prices creeping up and wonder where relief might come from.
Steven Hill was policy director for the Center for Humane Technology, co-founder of FairVote and political reform director at New America. You can reach him on X @StevenHill1776.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.