The problem is buried so deep into our system of health insurance that no policymaker has the nerve to touch it: health and work shouldn’t be linked.
There’s scant labor market or health justification for a system built on employer-sponsored coverage, but entrenched interests override good health outcomes, controlling costs and providing coverage to as many people as possible.
The tax-preferred status of health insurance benefits that opts employers and employees out of income or payroll tax duties on those benefits totaled $384 billion in 2024.
Yet policymakers have made clear that rather than rock this boat, they’d prefer to wait for it to tip over on its own.
Congress’s failures
Congress’s lack of stewardship over health insurance dates back to its origins. The first such plan in the U.S. was offered by Baylor University Hospital to Dallas public school teachers in 1929. The architect was a former teacher working in the hospital’s administration who came up with a monthly subscription plan in exchange for future hospital stays.
After adding more professions and hospitals, it became Blue Cross. The American Medical Association, seeing the success of the American Hospital Association’s new experiment, began to offer non-hospital physicians plans, which became Blue Shield.
Dropped into this swirling mix of loosely linked occupations, hospitals, doctors, and monthly payments for negotiated care was the multi-year wage freezes of World War II.
Employer-paid plans were exempt from these freezes, the costs of plans were deemed to be a business expense, and the benefits were not counted as income. After the war, the Internal Revenue Service solidified the twice-over tax preference as part of the Internal Revenue Code.
At no point did policymakers articulate a design to provide health insurance for Americans through their employers. Each successive Congress has instead inherited a system whose circumstantial origins were cemented into something permanent but not planned. The lack of planning is evident when considering the myriad miseries the system creates.
Where to begin.
Myriad miseries
First, health insurance is not only expensive for employers to provide, but employers are not equally financially capable of bearing the costs.
As a result, larger firms get to provide better coverage than smaller firms, which are at a disadvantage to negotiate things such as insulin costs. Employees of small firms on average a pay higher share of the total premium as well as face a higher deductible than employees of large firms.
This disparity in health-insurance offerings mars the labor market. Productivity is maximized when workers and firms are matched based on their human capital.
Throw insurance into the mix, and employers can be boxed out when competing for workers based on their health offerings and workers can warp their job search and tenure based on which employers provide the best health plan. The latter is called job lock: Staying at a job mostly for the health insurance. It’s a bad situation for workers and employers.
Second, health insurance also mars compensation. There’s evidence that workers who can be identified as adding to health costs, such as obese individuals or women of child-bearing age who may become pregnant, are paid less as a result. This is on top of the broader suppression of wage growth and labor demand experienced by all workers as a result of employer health costs.
Third, what’s truly bad about this whole system is that tying health insurance to work creates coverage gaps that the government must fill. Indeed, the evolution of public health insurance has been about Congress trying to fill holes employers leave behind.
In these holes fall some of the most expensive people or situations to insure. Medicaid covers 35% of all disabled individuals in the U.S., 61% of all long-term care recipients, and 41% of all births.
Medicare covers 80% of all deaths. The most expensive year of life is the last one, and end-of-life care is half of Medicare spending.
In essence, employers are “skimming the top,” insuring younger and higher income Americans and avoiding the oldest, poorest, chronically disabled, or dying. And the government sinks a fortune into supporting this system.
Although the Affordable Care Act added some regulations and mandates to employer benefits, most of the bill’s thrust was to cover those left out of the employer market by subsidizing the individual market and expanding Medicaid. It was a compromise policy.
An 80 year failed experiment
What’s incredible about the One Big Beautiful Bill Act is that it dismantles much of the ACA’s wraparound coverage, already weakened by the Supreme Court decision that made Medicaid expansion optional. It’s a rejection of the compromise that propped up the employer-sponsored system, a system rife with problems.
Either employer-sponsored health insurance is worth all the costs, inefficiencies, and problems, and Congress works around it, or it’s an 80-year experiment with enough evidence of failure that it’s time to move on to the next system.
Congress sitting on the shore and waiting for the boat to sink isn’t doing enough.
Kathryn Anne Edwards is a labor economist.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.