In February, the AP refused to revise its style guide to refer to the Gulf of Mexico by President Donald Trump’s preferred “Gulf of America.” The administration, with its typical small-mindedness, stripped the AP of its usual insider’s seat in the White House press pool.
AP sued. Although I have some sympathy with Judge Cornelia Pillard’s dissenting opinion in the AP case, I fear she’s imprecise when she asserts that “participation in the Press Pool or the broader White House press corps has never been conditioned on the viewpoint expressed outside the Pool by any participating news organization - until now.”
The unfortunate truth is that presidents have acted badly toward reporters who criticize them for as long as we’ve had presidents and reporters.
Presidential peevishness
Indeed, long before there existed a White House press corps, presidential peevishness led to the punishment of newspapers. We could go back to Abraham Lincoln and John Adams, who might reasonably rank first and second on the list of the nation’s best presidents, but both of whose administrations jailed journalists whose reporting they didn’t like.
A better point of departure might be 1904, when Jesse Carmichael of the Boston Herald filed a story about the Thanksgiving Day antics of Theodore Roosevelt’s children, claiming they had chased a turkey across the lawn. “Why should the Roosevelt children be allowed to torment and frighten an innocent bird?” the article concluded. The president’s secretary — the office of press secretary did not yet exist — denied that the incident had taken place.
But the denial did not satisfy Roosevelt, who ordered both Carmichael and his paper barred from receiving any news releases, not only from the White House, but from all executive departments. The Herald was not even permitted access to official weather forecasts. (The newspaper stood its ground, insisting that Roosevelt had been “misinformed” about the contents of the story.)
Roosevelt’s hostility toward the press was legendary. When, just before the 1908 election, Joseph Pulitzer’s New York World reported that the Roosevelt family had profited from the Panama Canal deal, the president informed Congress ominously that the attorney general “has under consideration” charges against the newspaper — a message condemned even by editors friendly to the administration.
Shortly before leaving office, he filed a lawsuit for criminal libel against theWorld and a second newspaper. The US Supreme Court would ultimately throw out the case, not because it offended freedom of the press, but on the ground that the federal judiciary lacked jurisdiction.
FDR, Nixon and Biden
Speaking of Roosevelts, when Franklin D. Roosevelt was in the White House, reporters were forbidden to photograph the chief executive in his wheelchair. The historian Harold Holzer, in his engrossing 2020 book on the history of the relationship between the press and presidents, tells us that what FDR’s White House styled as a “request” was firmly enforced: “Persistent offenders risked losing their press credentials.”
How effective was the ban? According to Holzer, a later study found that of 35,000 surviving photographs of FDR, only two showed him in his wheelchair.
It is often reported, that President Richard Nixon barred the Washington Post from covering his daughter Tricia’s 1971 wedding. What did happen, according to biographer John A. Farrell, is that he was so incensed by what he considered the Post’s “snide” coverage of the event that he ordered Ron Ziegler, his press secretary, to keep the newspaper from attending future White House social events.
Then, says Farrell, the president went further: “They’re never to be in the White House again. Never! Is that clear?” It does not appear that the ban was ever enforced. Perhaps Ziegler knew enough to let his boss calm down.
And for those who can stretch their memories back to that ancient year 2023, it was Joe Biden’s administration that rewrote the credentialing rules to rid itself of Cameroonian journalist Simon Ateba, whose offense was evidently shouting over others to get his questions heard. The White House called him disruptive.
Ateba claimed that he had to interrupt because he was never called on, and that he was never called on because the administration disliked his views. Either way, the new rules, which limited credentials to those employed by news organizations, excluded hundreds of others as well.
A tragedy, but the press survived
None of this history is meant to excuse the Trump administration’s decision to kick the AP out of the Oval Office over a line in the organization’s style guide. The decision was petty, disquieting and wrong.
It’s been a tragedy of our history that presidents good and bad have frequently taken out their anger on the press. That the news media have survived White House pettishness might be described as a glory of our democracy.
Stephen L. Carter, a Bloomberg Opinion columnist, is a professor of law at Yale University and author of “Invisible: The Story of the Black Woman Lawyer Who Took Down America’s Most Powerful Mobster.” His previous article was “On free speech, what President Biden can do, a President Trump will be able to do.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.