President Donald Trump is reshaping the way America’s history is presented in places that people around the world visit.

“Over the past decade, Americans have witnessed a concerted and widespread effort to rewrite our Nation’s history, replacing objective facts with a distorted narrative driven by ideology rather than truth,” said his executive order targeting museums, called “Restoring Truth and Sanity to American History.” That “fosters a sense of national shame.”

Obligation to the past

Contending with the uglier parts of U.S. history is necessary for an honest and inclusive telling of the American story. Americans can feel pride in the nation’s accomplishments while acknowledging that some of the shameful actions in the past reverberate today.

“The past has no duty to our feelings,” said Chandra Manning, a history professor at Georgetown University. “We, however, do have an obligation to the past, and that is to strive to understand it in all its complexity, as experienced by all who lived through it, not just a select few.”

Advertise with us

That is not to say that the uncomfortable weight of difficult truths isn’t a valid emotion. Postwar Germans were so crushed by the burden of their people’s past, from the horrors of the Nazi regime to the protection of war criminals in the decades after the war, that they have a word for processing it: vergangenheitsbewältigung, which means the “work of coping with the past.” It has informed huge swaths of German literature and film and has shaped the physical way European cities create memorials and museums.

America’s version can be found across the cultural landscape. From films to books to classrooms and museums, Americans are learning about slavery in the South, the way racism has affected everything from baseball to health care, and how sexism shaped the military.

Trump, however, defines vergangenheitsbewältigung differently. Among the first executive orders he issued was “Ending Radical Indoctrination in K-12 Schooling.” His version of American history tracks with how it was taught decades ago, before academics began bringing more diverse voices and viewpoints into their scholarship.

Maurice Jackson, a history professor at Georgetown University, said Black Americans have fought hard to tell their full story. “Black history is America’s history,” he said. Leaving the specifics of the Black experience out because it makes some people ashamed gives an incomplete picture of our nation, he said.

After Trump issued his executive orders, federal workers scrambled to interpret and obey them, which in some cases led to historical milestones being removed, or covered up and then replaced.

Advertise with us

It’s been done before

Federal workers removed a commemoration of the Tuskegee Airmen from the Pentagon website, then restored it. They taped butcher paper over the National Cryptologic Museum’s display honoring women and people of color, then uncovered the display.

Mentions of Harriet Tubman in a National Park Service display about the Underground Railroad were removed, then put back. The story of legendary baseball player Jackie Robinson’s military career was deleted from the Department of Defense website, then restored several days later.

Women known as WASPs risked their lives in military service — training and test pilots during World War II for a nation that didn’t allow them to open a bank account — are no longer a prominent part of the Pentagon’s digital story.

“Programs that memorialize painful truths help ensure past wrongs are never revived to harm again,” Rep. Steven Horsford (D-Nevada), said on X, noting that presidents are elected to “run our government — not rewrite our history.”

Authoritarian leaders have long made the whitewashing of history a tool in their regimes. Joseph Stalin expunged rivals from historic photographs. Adolf Hitler purged museums of modernist art and works created by Jewish artists, which he labeled “degenerate.” Museums in Mao Zedong’s China glorified his ideology.

Advertise with us

While this may be unfamiliar to Americans, Georgetown University history professor Adam Rothman says that in the scope of human history, “these are precedented times.”

It’s not yet clear what the real-world effect of Trump’s Smithsonian order will be or exactly how it will be carried out. Who will determine what exhibits cause shame and need to be removed? What will the criteria be? Will exhibits that discuss slavery, for instance, be eliminated or altered?

“Our nation is an ongoing experiment,” says Manning, who has written books about the Civil War. “And what helps us do that now in 2024 compared to 1776 is that we do have a shared past.”

She explained: “Every single human culture depends upon, grows out of, and is shaped by its past. It is the past that has shaped all of us, it is our past that contains the bonds that can really hold us together.”

Inspiring pride

It’s what makes the study of — and threat to — American history unique among nations. Katherine Benton-Cohen, also a Georgetown history professor, said that is what she sees happen with her students. “The American striving to realize the democratic faith and all the difficulties it entailed and challenges overcome should inspire pride, not shame. If you feel shame, as the kids would say, that’s a ‘you’ problem.”

Advertise with us

She flies the American flag at her house. “I’m not afraid of the American past, I’m alive with the possibilities — of finding common cause, of fighting for equality, of appreciating our shared humanity, of upholding our freedoms.”

Petula Dvorak is a columnist for The Washington Post’s local team. Her previous article was “The Post Office, now under Donald Trump's scrutiny, helped free America from England.”