“I would support you to be spokesperson for the Pentagon,” Connecticut Sen. Richard Blumenthal acidly told Pete Hegseth during his hearing before the Senate Armed Services Committee.
The insult was a poke in Hegseth’s eye for his career at Fox News. Blumenthal, who once fibbed that as a Marine he had served in Vietnam (he never left the States), thought Hegseth lacked the record of “leadership” to head an organization as large and complex as the Department of Defense.
On paper, former Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin had such “leadership” experience, as did Jim Mattis, Bob Gates, Leon Panetta, Donald Rumsfeld. Hegseth led a platoon in Iraq before smiling his way through Saturday morning news shows.
Hegseth wasn’t the traditional nominee, and that’s the point. Welcome to the executive presidency.
Remaking the executive branch
Blumenthal and others like him fail to understand that Donald Trump is remaking the executive branch of the federal government, and it starts with choosing communicators.
Any effective network of strategic communication must be organized as a hierarchy. The executive’s ability to achieve his goals is fundamentally dependent on high-fidelity, rapid information transferal, where the message is relayed broadly, quickly, and without significant distortion.
When Trump took office eight years ago, the left resisted him through the mainstream media, Hollywood, and corporate America, but the spearhead of “The Resistance” was his own government. The bureaucrats of the vast “administrative state” did not see him as a legitimate occupant of his office.
Thus, they didn’t merely distort the communication that came from the top. They tried to subordinate his agenda by refusing to transfer the information. More than that, they actively disseminated information that ran counter to the president’s stated aims.
In his 1938 classic “The Functions of the Executive,” author Chester Barnard explains that an executive’s first task is to create a “definite system of communication.” Barnard wasn’t talking about the technical means of communication, but the communicators themselves. Controlling an enterprise, hinges on the executive’s choice of who will repeat and amplify his message.
Consider the inauguration. Trump spent the entire first day of his second term on camera, narrating his executive actions. Trump knew his daylong, unscripted availability would contrast sharply with his predecessor’s behavior. Joe Biden’s increasing withdrawal from the public and his inability to deliver spontaneous remarks hid his declining mental health, and the fact that he really wasn’t in charge.
All forms of communication either demand or simulate presence, and Biden hadn’t really been present for some time.
Executives with followers
By the time Trump took the oath of office, he was activating many of the key nodes in his system of communication.
Kash Patel, a charismatic attorney of ambiguous political origins, has a Truth Social following of 1.5 million people. Until recently, he sold children’s books, scarves, and other goods through his online merchandising site. Since leaving Congress in 2021, Tulsi Gabbard has been a successful talk show host, news commentator, and author. Her followers on X approach 3.5 million.
Before the election, nobody anticipated Hegseth, Patel, or Gabbard would be selected to lead government bureaucracies. They lacked experience and pedigree, among other intangibles required under the Bush-Obama-Biden paradigm for leadership.
The quality that binds them and others in Trump’s administration is their ability to think and speak on their feet, and to connect with large audiences. Via television and the Internet, they are able to go beyond rehearsed speech to win “followers,” in the parlance of social media.
In the attention economy, smart phones and computers continue to claim more and more of our time. And Trump’s nominees are some of that economy’s brightest entrepreneurs.
This matters because the old “leadership by committee” paradigm is dissolving before our eyes. The era of believing the group is the source of creativity — that leadership by committee is preferable to a strong, winning executive — is ending.
That idea unraveled under Biden, who depended entirely on a group of self-interested aides and advisors who concealed his infirmities and nudged along his decision-making according to their plans. But the leadership-by-committee approach didn’t begin with him.
Memorably, George W. Bush claimed that he was “the decider,” but the running joke during his presidency was that everybody but Bush was in charge — people like Rumsfeld at Defense, Colin Powell at State, Paul O’Neill at Treasury, and, of course, Vice President Dick Cheney.
All were older, supposedly wiser, and more experienced in government and business. The results, however, were disastrous. Rather than win the war on terror, Bush’s advisers and executives used war as a pretext to expand the size and scope of government.
In the process of fighting Islamic extremism, he naïvely built a network of information-gathering and surveillance that would eventually be unleashed upon “domestic extremists,” the Obama-era epithet for Americans who resist the left-wing, top-down model of administrative government.
Trump knows
Although the governance-by-committee approach presented it as a more “inclusive” and ethical form of leadership, administrative managerialism pushed the American people first to the margin of politics, then out of government completely.
Trump repudiates that paradigm. There will be no administrative committee that jointly deliberates a course of action and then finds a “compromise” that always amounts to a half-measure with little buy-in.
Trump knows exactly what he wants to do and to whom he is obligated. His election marks the end of an era that put the group over the individual, administration over execution.
John Waters, a lawyer, served as a deputy assistant secretary of Homeland Security from 2020-21. Adam Ellwanger, a professor at University of Houston-Downtown, was a 2023 Lincoln Fellow at the Claremont Institute for Statesmanship and Political Philosophy. Follow him at @1HereticalTruth on X.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.