Without immigration, the American population would have only grown a tiny amount in 2024. The U.S. Census Bureau estimates that the nation’s population grew by nearly 1%, but 84% of that increase was from immigration. It estimates that 2.8 million of the 3.3 million increase were immigrants.

It is quite likely that if the U.S. were to stop all immigration today, our population would be falling.

Even more immigrants

Further, these figures probably understate the effect of immigration on U.S. population growth. First, more recent immigrants tend to have a higher birth rate than other U.S. residents. A study by the Center for Immigration Studies found that in 2019, the fertility rate for Americans born here was 1.69, compared to 2.02 for immigrants. In other words, immigrants are propping up the natural population growth.

Second, the Census Bureau’s immigration numbers have been widely criticized as being too low. Our immigration system is so broken that no one knows the actual number, but last year, when the bureau estimated that net international immigration into the U.S. was 1.2 million, the Congressional Budget Office estimated it was 4 million. This year’s estimate this of 2.8 million sounds more reasonable.

Advertise with us

Every state added population from international immigration. With 411,000, Florida had the most new residents from other countries, with New York a close second with 389,000. Texas had a 311,000 increase from international immigration. International immigration comprised 88% of Florida’s total growth but only 56% of Texas’ growth.

Without international immigration, 20 states would have lost population. California would have been the biggest loser at 129,000. New York, Pennsylvania, Illinois, and Massachusetts rounded out the top five in this category. The 20 states that would have lost population without immigration would have lost a total of 385,000.

Internal movement

What about domestic or interstate migrations? There was significantly less moving between states by Americans last year.

In 2023, about 1.75 million people moved from one state to another. This year that dropped to 1.15 million, a decline of about one-third.

Interstate migration has been dropping for several decades, most likely due to an aging population. However, this is an unusually large drop for one year. The ability to work remotely and, therefore, less need to relocate for a job is probably a factor.

Advertise with us

Some states gained people. Texas led other states by gaining 85,000 residents. North Carolina was a close second at 82,000. South Carolina, Florida, and Tennessee were third through fifth, respectively.

However, many numbers were down from the previous year. Texas’s was less than half of last year’s and Florida’s almost two-thirds less.

California continued to lead the way in losing residents, shedding 240,000. New York lost 120,000. Illinois, New Jersey, and Massachusetts also had significant losses. Louisiana and Mississippi were the only southern states that lost residents to other states.

Painful disruptions

The new data strongly suggests that assuming the new Trump administration comes close to making good on it immigration reforms and deportation promises, there will likely be a significant decline in the U.S. population. The decline will reach almost every region and significantly affect the country.

There will certainly be some benefits from a declining population, but there will also be some significant and painful disruptions. There will almost certainly be labor shortages in many industries and a significant decline in economic growth.

Advertise with us

Polling has consistently shown that Trump’s more restrictive immigration policy has widespread support across almost every demographic. It will be interesting to see whether the support continues as the reality of population decline begins to be felt.

Bill King, a businessman and lawyer, is a former opinion columnist and editorial board member at the Houston Chronicle. His previous article was “How many are dying in America?”