Retail businesses are being hit hard by theft. The National Retail Federation (NRF) reported last year that “shrink,” the industry term for store theft, accounted for $112.1 billion in losses in 2022 across the industry, up from $93.9 billion in 2021. This covers everything from the traditional “five-finger discount” to organized criminal groups that target stores.
The upsurge in shoplifting may be an inadvertent consequence of another rising trend: automation. With stores now having fewer people minding them, thieves have felt emboldened.
In response, trade groups are pushing for new federal legislation to help fix the problem. The Combating Organized Retail Crime Act, for example, would create an organized retail theft division within the Department of Homeland Security.
A better solution would be for businesses to realize that workers are a greater anti-theft asset than they think.
Hire more people
Hire more people to monitor the floors. Have more watch the stores. This will reduce the opportunities for would-be thieves and embolden store owners and workers to stop theft when it happens.
It will also make the stores appear to be more a part of the community where friends and neighbors work and less like the large vending machines they have become. Stores have become ghost towns largely devoid of staff. Many stores now use primarily self-checkout and have skeleton crews running the location.
There is still no substitute for a pair of human hands and eyes. Most stores have cameras watching all areas, for example, but cameras still need someone to monitor them, in addition to people on the floor who can be alerted to stop would-be thieves. Otherwise, the cameras are just an elaborate home-movie system.
Self-checkout can drive away paying customers, too. Amazon mostly abandoned its experiment with cashier-less “Just Walk Out” grocery stores in early 2024 when it realized that potential customers weren’t going for it. It frequently took hours for customers to get their receipts because the purchases were monitored by off-site cashiers via cameras.
Interestingly, the big retail chains do not appear to be employing fewer people overall. CVS Pharmacies, for example, had an average of 28 employees per store last year and an average of 32 employees this year. Automation is not reducing total headcount.
But the growth clearly has not translated to more people working in the stores. The automation seems to have coincided with more hires elsewhere within corporations.
CVS announced in October it was shedding 2,900 jobs and notably said that the positions impacted would be “primarily corporate roles.” Jobs in stores and pharmacies would, the corporation said, avoid the ax, presumably because they cannot afford to cut back there any further.
The effects
The lack of store staff has several effects. It means that not only are there fewer workers to spot shoplifting, but they are more likely to be reluctant to try to stop thieves because they have fewer co-workers to back them up should the situation escalate. NRF reported in 2023 that 41% of surveyed retailers said that “no employees are authorized to stop or apprehend shoplifters,” up from 38% in 2022.
One can understand the stores’ position. Prosecuting shoplifters in most cases will be more expensive than whatever the store might recover in court and can cause hard feelings within the surrounding community. But it is clearly a self-defeating stance if it opens the doors, figuratively and literally, to further theft.
And, finally, the broader American culture seems to be more accepting of theft if it is framed as stealing from faceless corporations, not individuals. The fewer people minding a store, the less stealing from the store feels like stealing from people.
The executives running the retail stores are struggling to figure out what to do, journalist Marc Fisher, author of a recent study on the rise of shoplifting for the Atlantic Monthly, told this author. “All of the retail industry executives, retail security experts and criminologists I spoke with cited automation as one of the key causes of the current crisis.”
They recognize that “the shift in recent decades toward automating everything from checkout to store security (cameras, AI monitors, programs such as those I described in the piece) has been accompanied by big cuts in staffing, which in turn came about in part as a cost-saving measure and, perhaps more often, because of the difficulty in hiring and retaining shop workers,” he said in an email.
Workers are an asset
Management needs to remember that workers are an asset, not just for labor productivity but also for intangible human qualities they bring to the shopping experience.
They bring pride in making sure their section is clean and well stocked; the assistance they can give to customers searching for the right item; or the ability to respond to unusual situations like a customer having a health emergency. Thieves are less likely to steal if they can see multiple people watching them rather than just one.
Fixing the shoplifting crisis does not require elaborate federal legislation or tougher criminal sentences or stricter security measures or more elaborate surveillance. It requires more workers. That is something management can easily fix. It will cost more, of course, but it is a worthwhile investment.
Sean Higgins is a research fellow specializing in labor policy for the Competitive Enterprise Institute.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.