The 2024 elec­tion is shap­ing up to be a “Bet­ter the devil you know than the devil you don’t know” kind of con­test. That say­ing is rooted in what is called “am­bi­gu­ity aver­sion bias.” Even if a sit­u­a­tion is bad, in­di­vid­u­als would rather stay with what they know rather than face un­cer­tainty.

So it goes with our pres­i­den­tial nom­i­nees. Vot­ers not lik­ing Don­ald Trump the man may not be enough for Kamala Har­ris to beat the for­mer pres­i­dent.

Known over un­known

Be­hav­ioral econ­o­mists de­scribe am­bi­gu­ity aver­sion, or un­cer­tainty aver­sion, as the ten­dency to fa­vor the known over the un­known, in­clud­ing known risks over un­known or in­cal­cu­la­ble risks. In a pro­fes­sional sit­u­a­tion, many peo­ple would pre­fer to have con­tact with or do busi­ness with a per­son they al­ready know, even though they don’t like them, than with a per­son they hardly know.

This prin­ci­ple also seems to ap­ply to po­lit­i­cal can­di­dates and voter be­hav­ior. A re­cent New York Times/​Siena poll il­lus­trated this fal­lacy in ac­tion. The poll shows Trump with a 52% un­fa­vor­a­bil­ity rat­ing. The poll also has Trump ahead of Har­ris na­tion­ally by 2 points, 46% to 44%.

Advertise with us

Some­thing has to ac­count for the ap­prox­i­mate 6% of vot­ers who view Trump un­fa­vor­ably while at the same time saying they would be vot­ing for him.

There are cer­tainly vot­ers who will cast their bal­lots for the for­mer pres­i­dent be­cause they pre­fer him as a can­di­date, pre­fer­ring his lead­er­ship or his pol­i­cies. But a ma­jor­ity of the elec­tor­ate find him dis­taste­ful, whether it was his ac­tions sur­round­ing the 2020 elec­tion, the events around Jan. 6, 2021, his fel­ony in­dict­ments, the fact that he is an ad­ju­di­cated sex­ual abuser, or even just his ob­nox­ious so­cial me­dia posts.

Yet de­spite all of that, a ma­jor­ity of vot­ers may just pull the le­ver for a Trump/​Vance ticket since they are un­sure about Har­ris/​Walz.

Who wants to know more?

The same poll asked the fol­low­ing: Do you feel like you still need to learn more about Kamala Har­ris, or do you pretty much al­ready know what you need to know? Just more than a quar­ter (28%) of re­spon­dents said they needed to know more about her. Of that group, 66% said they would like to learn her pol­i­cies and/​or plans.

Only 12% said they needed to learn more about Trump.

Advertise with us

Har­ris has only done one recorded in­ter­view. While Amer­i­cans did get to see her on the de­bate stage on Sept. 10, she did not give many de­tails on her ad­min­is­tra­tion’s plans. It took five weeks for the Har­ris cam­paign to add an “is­sues” sec­tion on her cam­paign web­site and even then, it was re­mark­ably vague.

To date, Har­ris has not taken ques­tions from the press pool and. as of this writ­ing, has no other in­ter­views sched­uled, all of which im­pedes vot­ers get­ting to know her bet­ter.

It re­mains to be seen whether there will be any fur­ther de­bates be­tween Har­ris and Trump. Trump in­di­cated on Sept. 12, that there would be no more, which again would deny vot­ers ad­di­tional op­por­tu­ni­ties to learn more about Har­ris.

While it is also too soon for post-de­bate poll­ing on the can­di­dates, most ob­serv­ers and pun­dits re­marked at how crazy Trump seemed dur­ing the ABC News de­bate, es­pe­cially when he falsely claimed that Hai­tian mi­grants in Spring­field, Ohio, were steal­ing peo­ple’s dogs and cats and eat­ing them. Then again, peo­ple might be used to this type of be­hav­ior af­ter watch­ing and lis­ten­ing to him for the last 10 years.

The dom­i­nant me­dia nar­ra­tive is miss­ing the am­bi­gu­ity aver­sion by as­sum­ing that Amer­i­cans will be so turned off by Trump’s an­tics they can­not pos­si­bly vote for him. How­ever, rightly or wrongly, many Amer­i­cans think back nos­tal­gi­cally on the pre-pan­demic econ­omy or re­mark on how there were no wars go­ing on while Trump was pres­i­dent.

Advertise with us

Har­ris’ am­bi­gu­ity hurts her

While they might not like Trump’s char­ac­ter or be­hav­iors, they felt more pros­per­ous and safer in con­trast to the un­cer­tainty of a Har­ris ad­min­is­tra­tion. Har­ris needs to move be­yond her stra­te­gic am­bi­gu­ity, as it is likely hurt­ing her. Vot­ers want to know more about her pol­i­cies and agenda, and broad, sweep­ing state­ments may not cut it any­more.

Un­less vot­ers get to know Har­ris bet­ter and like what they see and hear, they might just de­fault to the devil they know in No­vem­ber.

Lynn Schmidt is a columnist and editorial board member with the St. Louis Post-Dispatch. Her previous article was “The Democrats, and American democracy, need a new ticket.”