Vice Pres­i­dent Kamala Har­ris re­cently pro­posed price con­trols on gro­cer­ies to stop food com­pa­nies from “goug­ing” Amer­i­can con­sum­ers. It’s a ter­ri­ble idea, as many have al­ready pointed out, be­cause price con­trols lead to short­ages and other bad out­comes. It’s also doubt­ful Har­ris could push such a pol­icy through Con­gress.

But are food com­pa­nies in fact goug­ing peo­ple? There’s been talk about price goug­ing ever since in­fla­tion spiked in 2021, so in early 2022, I looked at the fi­nan­cial re­sults of com­pa­nies in the S&P 500 In­dex to see if they were ex­ploit­ing con­sum­ers or merely pass­ing on their own higher costs. It looked to me at the time that they were rais­ing prices to beef up prof­its.

Mak­ing more, mak­ing less

For ex­am­ple, the S&P 500’s op­er­at­ing mar­gin — that is, the per­cent­age of rev­e­nue com­pa­nies keep af­ter de­duct­ing op­er­at­ing ex­penses such as ma­teri­als, wages, rent and util­i­ties — was mean­ing­fully higher in 2021 than be­fore the COVID pan­demic, and Wall Street an­a­lysts ex­pected it to re­main that high.

The same was true for the S&P 500 Equal Weight In­dex, which sug­gested that most com­pa­nies were ex­ploit­ing a post-pan­demic surge in con­sumer de­mand by hik­ing prices faster than their own costs were ris­ing.

Advertise with us

After hear­ing Har­ris’s plan, I de­cided to take an­other look. Oper­at­ing mar­gins have de­clined since 2022. The S&P 500’s mar­gin is back down to where it was be­fore the pan­demic, and that of the equal weight in­dex is even lower, all of which sug­gests that most com­pa­nies have not raised prices enough to fully ab­sorb their own higher costs.

Finan­cial re­sults for the con­sumer sta­ples sec­tor, which is where food and bev­er­age com­pa­nies re­side, tell a sim­i­lar story. The sec­tor’s op­er­at­ing mar­gin climbed to 10% in 2021 from 8% in 2019, but it is now down to 7%. Here, too, it ap­pears that com­pa­nies have ab­sorbed more in­fla­tion than they’ve passed on to con­sum­ers.

I sus­pect what hap­pened was that com­pa­nies raised prices in 2021 in an­tic­i­pa­tion of higher op­er­at­ing costs, but that those higher ex­penses didn’t show up un­til 2022 or later. The mis­match caused mar­gins to in­flate on higher rev­e­nue in 2021 and de­flate when higher op­er­at­ing ex­penses hit fi­nan­cial state­ments in sub­se­quent years, leav­ing com­pa­nies on the whole no bet­ter off than be­fore the pan­demic and per­haps slightly worse off.

Mod­est mar­gins

There’s a re­lated ques­tion about whether mega-com­pa­nies have used their size to raise prices more than smaller ones. I see no in­di­ca­tion of that in the num­bers.

The big three in the sta­ples sec­tor — Wal­mart Inc., Procter & Gam­ble Co. and Costco Whole­sale Corp. — have main­tained their pre-pan­demic mar­gins, as have more than half of com­pa­nies in the sec­tor. It’s not clear, in other words, that the big­gest com­pa­nies have wielded more pric­ing power since the pan­demic.

Advertise with us

The an­swer is roughly the same when iso­lat­ing the food prod­ucts in­dus­try within the sta­ples sec­tor. There’s more par­ity among food com­pa­nies than in the broader sec­tor.

The in­dus­try’s stand­out is Oreo-maker Mon­delez In­ter­na­tional Inc., whose mar­ket value is twice that of Kraft Heinz Co., the sec­ond most-valu­able com­pany. Even so, among food com­pa­nies that have man­aged to ex­pand mar­gins since the pan­demic, Mon­delez’s mar­gin growth is the weak­est.

For the food prod­ucts in­dus­try over­all, mar­gins are only modestly higher than be­fore the pan­demic, so like the broader S&P 500, it ap­pears com­pa­nies mostly at­tempted to pass on their own higher costs to con­sum­ers.

To be clear, busi­nesses have a right — but not a duty — to charge as much as the mar­ket will bear for their goods and ser­vices. Indeed, free mar­kets de­pend on that right. The fact that mar­gins have sta­bi­lized since the pan­demic is a sign that mar­kets are work­ing as they should to match sup­ply with de­mand even dur­ing a very cha­otic time.

It’s true, as the Har­ris cam­paign in­ti­mates, that the S&P 500’s op­er­at­ing mar­gin rose by 50% from the early 1990s through the late 2010s. That’s a dis­cus­sion for an­other day, but I’ll note that mar­gin ex­pan­sion does not nec­es­sar­ily lead to higher prices as that pe­riod co­in­cided with some of the low­est in­fla­tion on record.

Advertise with us

A cri­sis re­sponse

At the same time, lim­ited gov­ern­ment in­ter­ven­tion is ap­pro­pri­ate if com­pa­nies ex­ploit a cri­sis that dis­rupts the nor­mal op­er­a­tion of mar­kets and the econ­omy, as the pan­demic did for a time.

But the U.S. is no lon­ger in cri­sis, and Har­ris did not of­fer enough de­tails about how she would han­dle price goug­ing now or in such an emer­gency. She would do bet­ter to aban­don the idea be­cause, at least for now, price con­trols seem to be a solu­tion in search of a prob­lem.

Nir Kaissar is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist. His previous article was “The money didn't trickle down to the working class.”