Where were you when Dem­o­crats bat­tled in the streets of Chi­cago in 1968? Kamala Har­ris and Tim Walz were play­ing with blocks or col­or­ing books, be­cause both of them were about four.

The truth is that prob­a­bly no Dem­o­crat un­der 65 knows any­thing about that week that he or she didn’t read in a book or watch in an Aaron Sor­kin film. And yet my news feed is full of sto­ries about the ee­rie sim­i­lar­i­ties of that con­ven­tion to this one, about the ghostly mem­o­ries that Dem­o­crats must now con­front.

The party’s or­i­gin story

It’s not like Dem­o­crats ha­ven’t been back to Chi­cago since that blood­bath 56 years ago. They gath­ered there in 1996, when Bill Clin­ton (who will speak Wed­nes­day night) was nom­i­nated for a sec­ond term. They made more poi­gnant his­tory there in 2008, when Barack Obama stood in Grant Park and thanked the coun­try for mak­ing him its first African Amer­i­can pres­i­dent.

But 1968 pro­vokes a spe­cial kind of nos­tal­gia in the party, be­yond the drama of a bro­kered con­ven­tion and vi­o­lence in the streets. It is, in a sense, the or­i­gin story of the mod­ern Demo­cratic Party.

Advertise with us

It was the turn­ing point at which all-pow­er­ful party bosses, all of them white and male, be­gan to lose their grip on the party. It was the mo­ment when younger re­form­ers crashed the gate of Demo­cratic pol­i­tics, lead­ing to an en­tirely new way of pick­ing pres­i­dents.

After 1968, cau­cuses and pri­ma­ries would come to dom­i­nate the se­lec­tion pro­cess (they were a much smaller part of it be­fore then), with ac­tiv­ists and or­di­nary vot­ers sup­plant­ing ru­ral and ur­ban Demo­cratic ma­chines. Rules were de­vised to di­ver­sify del­egates, giv­ing women and ra­cial mi­nor­i­ties seats at the ta­ble. A new gen­er­a­tion of ide­al­is­tic Dem­o­crats streamed into Wash­ing­ton as leg­is­la­tors and aides. The in­flu­ence of so­cial move­ments — Black, an­ti­war, fem­i­nist — eclipsed union chiefs and lo­cal pa­tron­age.

All of which made pos­si­ble the rise of a pea­nut farmer named Jimmy Carter, and then the tri­umph of Clin­tonism and the as­cen­sion of Obama. But all that time, as the boomers were re­mak­ing Demo­cratic Wash­ing­ton, some­thing else was hap­pen­ing, too. The out­sid­ers be­came the in­sid­ers. The re­form­ers be­came wealthy and en­trenched.

The new guard kept power

The party’s new guard even­tu­ally de­vised its own ar­cane sys­tem — known as su­perdel­egates — for re­press­ing re­form move­ments that might threaten the new sta­tus quo. The young ide­al­ists shaped by 1968 pi­o­neered the fields of poll­ing, di­rect mail and lob­by­ing.

They built huge firms on K Street and va­ca­tion homes on the Del­a­ware shore, while the tenor of our pol­i­tics grew dark and di­vi­sive. The vi­brant so­cial and la­bor move­ments of the 1960s be­came em­pires of their own, ex­ist­ing as much to per­pet­u­ate their power as to en­act leg­is­la­tion.

Advertise with us

And when the time came, years ago, for that ’60s gen­er­a­tion to hand off power to younger Dem­o­crats, much as they had de­manded of their el­ders in 1968, they flat out re­fused. The Dem­o­crats who fought for de­moc­ra­ti­za­tion in 1968 fought just as hard to hoard their power a half-cen­tury later, when the party some­how re­mained firmly in the grip of oc­to­ge­nar­i­ans.

I don’t want to speak too broadly here, be­cause some pow­er­ful Dem­o­crats who go back to 1968 are close friends who have taught me a ton about pol­i­tics over the years. I ad­mire a lot of what they’ve achieved. But the truth is that if that long-ago con­ven­tion still has rel­e­vance in Demo­cratic pol­i­tics, it’s be­cause the party’s old­est in­sid­ers, the peo­ple in­spired by that mo­ment, largely failed to honor their prom­ise.

They did not re­form our pol­i­tics any more than they cor­rupted it. They did not dif­fuse power any more than they clung to it — and cling to it still, to the point where a nearly 60-year-old nom­i­nee some­how feels like the cool breeze of youth.

Be­lieve me, this week’s con­ven­tion will bear lit­tle if any re­sem­blance to 1968; pro­tests over the Mid­dle East will seem gen­teel by com­par­i­son, and the speeches in­side the hall will be de­press­ingly cho­reo­graphed.

Ban­ish­ing the ghosts

But the ghosts of that mo­ment will float across the stage in the per­son­ages of Nancy Pelosi and Char­les Schu­mer, the Clin­tons and the Bid­ens, which­ever in­ter­change­able Ken­nedys hap­pen to show up this time. In these hon­or­able yet un­yield­ing el­ders, the leg­acy of the 1960s will be well on dis­play.

Advertise with us

Yet when Har­ris fi­nally takes the stage Thurs­day night, she has an op­por­tu­nity to ban­ish those ghosts once and for all, by mak­ing clear that her idea of re­form isn’t rooted in the for­got­ten trau­mas of 1968, but rather in the idea that ev­ery gen­er­a­tion has the right to re­make the party — and the coun­try — for its own mo­ment.

If she does that, then Dem­o­crats can pack up the hall and leave Chi­cago be­hind, this time for good.

Matt Bai is a Washington Post contributing columnist. His previous article was “Kamala Harris must risk having substantive policies, or lose.”