The idea that every adult American should receive some minimal level of cash without having to demonstrate need is having a moment. So much so that Stanford University has started the Basic Income Lab to track the growing number of experiments in this area.
It now counts around three dozen basic income pilots in effect across the country. Artificial intelligence pioneer Sam Altman announced the results last month of a UBI study he commissioned, exclaiming that the findings show such programs can potentially end poverty.
So, are we on the cusp of a socio-economic revolution? Have we found a solution to the persistent social problems that traditional thinking has failed to address? No.
It’s cash welfare
Every UBI study, including Altman’s, is testing cash welfare. They might call it a universal benefit, but the study participants are all lower-income, well below middle class.
Rather than revolutionaries, Altman and others like him are mostly hitching their wagon to a movement that is more than a hundred years deep in the fight. For advocates and researchers hoping to end child poverty, there’s nothing new about the importance of cash.
Go back to early 1909, when a group of social reformers descended upon the White House to explain to President Theodore Roosevelt that America was mistreating its children. At the time, it was not uncommon for children of poor parents to be sent to state-run orphanages or even abandoned and put to work.
Read More
The reformers told Roosevelt that poor families deserve financial support, and cash welfare in the U.S. began. These early programs started as a loose confederation of voluntary state initiatives called Mothers’ Pensions.
But with the Social Security Act, they morphed into Aid to Dependent Children and, later, Aid to Families with Dependent Children, or AFDC. The AFDC was eliminated in 1996, with the government deciding to go back to voluntary and temporary benefits that states could mete out, along with a supplemental federal tax credit for working mothers.
A valuable lesson
The AFDC is probably one of the most reviled public programs in U.S. history. It taught a valuable lesson, which is that cash handouts by the government breed resentment.
The enduring myth of the “welfare queen” started during the presidential election of 1976 when Ronald Reagan suggested that too many of those receiving government assistance weren’t deserving. Even its advocates acknowledged that a basic flaw of AFDC was the resentment of families who didn’t qualify for the program.
So, following AFDC’s demise researchers embraced the idea that a better solution would be to give cash to most families with children rather than trying to design a program to target poor families with children — a task that would likely miss some in need and continue to breed resentment. After all, economic insecurity is not limited to the poor.
This type of program was given a high level of intellectual endorsement when it was included as a key recommendation in a 2019 National Academies of Sciences report about how to end child poverty. The nonprofit’s idea was to leverage the existing Child Tax Credit, which already had an established phase-out for higher income families.
The American Rescue Plan did exactly that during the pandemic, creating a near-universal cash benefit for families with children during the second half of 2021. It was an incredible success in reducing child poverty, which the Census Bureau says was slashed by 46% between 2020 and 2021.
Those brief months also gave researchers the evidence needed to address a concern that has dogged every program that distributes resources to the poor, which is that recipients will waste the money, spending it on things like drugs and alcohol instead of on their children.
The opposite happened, as families were found to have spent the money on food, housing and necessities for their children — a result replicated in study after study that looked at the program’s effects.
Marketing welfare
Basic income advocates would recoil at the notion that they are testing welfare even though their research produces the conclusion that it’s fine to give poor people money because they will spend it wisely.
As child poverty advocates for generations can attest, research rarely speaks for itself, and results often matter less than perception. Which is why we should be applauding efforts like Altman’s even though the word “welfare” is conspicuous by its absence. That’s OK. Good marketing dictates that “substance” be paired with “style” to be effective at selling an idea or product — even welfare.
Kathryn Anne Edwards is a labor economist and independent policy consultant.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.