The idea that ev­ery adult Amer­i­can should re­ceive some min­i­mal level of cash with­out hav­ing to demon­strate need is hav­ing a mo­ment. So much so that Stan­ford Univer­sity has started the Ba­sic In­come Lab to track the grow­ing num­ber of ex­per­i­ments in this area.

It now counts around three dozen ba­sic in­come pi­lots in ef­fect across the coun­try. Ar­ti­fi­cial in­tel­li­gence pi­o­neer Sam Alt­man an­nounced the re­sults last month of a UBI study he com­mis­sioned, ex­claim­ing that the find­ings show such pro­grams can po­ten­tially end pov­erty.

So, are we on the cusp of a so­cio-eco­nomic rev­o­lu­tion? Have we found a solu­tion to the per­sis­tent so­cial prob­lems that tra­di­tional think­ing has failed to ad­dress? No.

It’s cash wel­fare

Every UBI study, in­clud­ing Alt­man’s, is test­ing cash wel­fare. They might call it a uni­ver­sal ben­e­fit, but the study par­tic­i­pants are all lower-in­come, well be­low mid­dle class.

Advertise with us

Rather than rev­o­lu­tion­aries, Alt­man and oth­ers like him are mostly hitch­ing their wagon to a move­ment that is more than a hun­dred years deep in the fight. For ad­vo­cates and re­search­ers hop­ing to end child pov­erty, there’s noth­ing new about the im­por­tance of cash.

Go back to early 1909, when a group of so­cial re­form­ers de­scended upon the White House to ex­plain to Pres­i­dent The­odore Roosevelt that Amer­ica was mis­treat­ing its chil­dren. At the time, it was not un­com­mon for chil­dren of poor par­ents to be sent to state-run or­phan­ages or even aban­doned and put to work.

The re­form­ers told Roosevelt that poor fam­i­lies de­serve fi­nan­cial sup­port, and cash wel­fare in the U.S. be­gan. These early pro­grams started as a loose con­fed­er­a­tion of vol­un­tary state ini­tia­tives called Moth­ers’ Pen­sions.

But with the So­cial Se­cu­rity Act, they mor­phed into Aid to Depen­dent Chil­dren and, later, Aid to Fam­i­lies with Depen­dent Chil­dren, or AFDC. The AFDC was elim­i­nated in 1996, with the gov­ern­ment de­cid­ing to go back to vol­un­tary and tem­po­rary ben­e­fits that states could mete out, along with a sup­ple­men­tal fed­eral tax credit for work­ing moth­ers.

A valu­able les­son

The AFDC is prob­a­bly one of the most re­viled pub­lic pro­grams in U.S. his­tory. It taught a valu­able les­son, which is that cash hand­outs by the gov­ern­ment breed re­sent­ment.

Advertise with us

The en­dur­ing myth of the “wel­fare queen” started dur­ing the pres­i­den­tial elec­tion of 1976 when Ron­ald Rea­gan sug­gested that too many of those re­ceiv­ing gov­ern­ment as­sis­tance weren’t de­serv­ing. Even its ad­vo­cates ac­knowl­edged that a ba­sic flaw of AFDC was the re­sent­ment of fam­i­lies who didn’t qual­ify for the pro­gram.

So, fol­low­ing AFDC’s de­mise re­search­ers em­braced the idea that a bet­ter solu­tion would be to give cash to most fam­i­lies with chil­dren rather than try­ing to de­sign a pro­gram to tar­get poor fam­i­lies with chil­dren — a task that would likely miss some in need and con­tinue to breed re­sent­ment. After all, eco­nomic in­se­cu­rity is not lim­ited to the poor.

This type of pro­gram was given a high level of in­tel­lec­tual en­dorse­ment when it was in­cluded as a key rec­om­men­da­tion in a 2019 Na­tional Acad­e­mies of Sciences re­port about how to end child pov­erty. The non­profit’s idea was to le­ver­age the ex­ist­ing Child Tax Credit, which al­ready had an es­tab­lished phase-out for higher in­come fam­i­lies.

The Amer­i­can Res­cue Plan did ex­actly that dur­ing the pan­demic, cre­at­ing a near-uni­ver­sal cash ben­e­fit for fam­i­lies with chil­dren dur­ing the sec­ond half of 2021. It was an in­cred­i­ble suc­cess in re­duc­ing child pov­erty, which the Cen­sus Bureau says was slashed by 46% be­tween 2020 and 2021.

Those brief months also gave re­search­ers the ev­i­dence needed to ad­dress a con­cern that has dog­ged ev­ery pro­gram that dis­trib­utes re­sources to the poor, which is that re­cip­i­ents will waste the money, spend­ing it on things like drugs and al­co­hol in­stead of on their chil­dren.

Advertise with us

The op­po­site hap­pened, as fam­i­lies were found to have spent the money on food, hous­ing and ne­ces­si­ties for their chil­dren — a re­sult rep­li­cated in study af­ter study that looked at the pro­gram’s ef­fects.

Mar­ket­ing wel­fare

Ba­sic in­come ad­vo­cates would re­coil at the no­tion that they are test­ing wel­fare even though their re­search pro­duces the con­clu­sion that it’s fine to give poor peo­ple money be­cause they will spend it wisely.

As child pov­erty ad­vo­cates for gen­er­a­tions can at­test, re­search rarely speaks for it­self, and re­sults of­ten mat­ter less than per­cep­tion. Which is why we should be ap­plaud­ing ef­forts like Alt­man’s even though the word “wel­fare” is con­spic­u­ous by its ab­sence. That’s OK. Good mar­ket­ing dic­tates that “sub­stance” be paired with “style” to be ef­fec­tive at sell­ing an idea or prod­uct — even wel­fare.

Kathryn Anne Edwards is a labor economist and independent policy consultant.