Here’s a bargain of the most horrifying kind: For less than $100,000, it may now be possible to use artificial intelligence to develop a virus that could kill millions of people. That’s the conclusion of Jason Matheny, president of the Rand Corp., a think tank that studies security matters and other issues.
“It wouldn’t cost more to create a pathogen that’s capable of killing hundreds of millions of people versus a pathogen that’s only capable of killing hundreds of thousands of people,” Matheny said. It could cost billions of dollars to produce a new vaccine or antiviral in response.
Targeted bioweapons
Some years ago, a research team created a cousin of the smallpox virus, horse pox, in six months for $100,000, and with AI it could be easier and cheaper to refine the virus.
A retired Chinese general has raised the possibility of biological warfare that targets particular races or ethnicities (probably imperfectly). This may be why the U.S. Defense Department has said that the most important long-term threat of biowarfare comes from China.
Scientists for years have explored how AI may dominate warfare, with autonomous drones or robots programmed to find and eliminate targets instantaneously. Warfare may come to involve robots fighting robots.
One great uncertainty is the extent and timing of job losses that could amplify social unrest and lead to an explosion of deaths of despair and to the rise of right-wing populism.
Read More
AI has a more hopeful side as well, of course. It holds the promise of improving education, reducing auto accidents, curing cancers and developing miraculous new pharmaceuticals.
One of the best-known benefits is in protein folding, which can lead to revolutionary advances in medical care. Scientists used to spend years or decades figuring out the shapes of individual proteins, and then a Google initiative called AlphaFold was introduced that could predict the shapes within minutes.
Scientists have since used updated versions of AlphaFold to work on pharmaceuticals including a vaccine against malaria, one of the greatest killers of humans throughout history.
So it’s unclear whether AI will save us or kill us first.
Technology can oppress
One reason for my wariness of AI is that while I see the promise of it, the past 20 years have been a reminder of technology’s capacity to oppress.
Smartphones were dazzling, but there’s evidence tying them to deteriorating mental health in young people. A randomized controlled trial published just this month found that children who gave up their smartphones enjoyed improved well-being.
Dictators have benefited from new technologies. Liu Xiaobo, the Chinese dissident who received a Nobel Peace Prize, thought that “the internet is God’s gift to the Chinese people.” It did not work out that way: Liu died in Chinese custody, and China has used AI to ramp up surveillance and tighten the screws on citizens.
AI may also make it easier to manipulate people. A study released this year found that when Chat GPT-4 had access to basic information about people it engaged with, it was about 80% more likely to persuade someone than a human was with the same data. Congress was right to worry about manipulation of public opinion by the TikTok algorithm.
All this underscores why it is essential that the United States maintain its lead in artificial intelligence. As much as we may be leery of putting our foot on the gas, this is not a competition in which it is OK to be the runner-up to China.
The limits Joe Biden placed on China’s access to the most advanced computer chips will help preserve our lead. The Biden administration has recruited first-rate people from the private sector to think through these matters and issued an important executive order last year on AI safety, but we will also need to develop new systems in the coming years for improved governance.
I’ve written about AI-generated deepfake nude images and videos, and the irresponsibility of both the deepfake companies and major search engines that drive traffic to deepfake sites.
And tech companies have periodically used immunities to avoid accountability for promoting the sexual exploitation of children. None of that inspires confidence in these companies’ abilities to self-govern responsibly.
Silicon Valley decides
“We’ve never had a circumstance in which the most dangerous, and most impactful, technology resides entirely in the private sector,” said Susan Rice, who was President Barack Obama’s national security adviser. “It can’t be that technology companies in Silicon Valley decide the fate of our national security and maybe the fate of the world without constraint.”
I think that’s right. Managing AI without stifling it will be one of our great challenges as we adopt perhaps the most revolutionary technology since Prometheus brought us fire.
Nicholas Kristof is a columnist for The New York Times, where this article first appeared. His previous article was “The genocide the world doesn't care about.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.