In July 2023 — before the primaries, before last month’s debate — a New York Times/Siena College poll found that Democratic primary voters, 50% to 45%, preferred that the party nominate someone other than Biden in 2024. But the Democratic Party’s elites were in lockstep around Biden.
The fact that he was barely campaigning or giving unscripted interviews was rationalized rather than criticized. No major Democrats decided to challenge him for the nomination. Some of this reflected confidence in the president. Some of it reflected the consequences of challenging him.
How parties work
The White House and the Democratic Party apparatus it controls are powerful. Congressional Democrats will not get their bills prioritized or their amendments attached if they are too critical of the party leadership. Nonprofit leaders will stop getting their calls returned. Loyal party donors will abandon you if you’re branded a heretic.
“I would be crucified by them if I spoke out of line,” an anonymous Democratic state party chair told NBC News early this month. “I know when you get out of line, they all of a sudden have a shift of priorities, and your races, your state is no longer on the map.” That was far truer a year ago, when Biden’s position in the party was unchallenged.
This is simply how parties work. But it meant that Democratic voters were given neither a real choice of candidates nor a demonstration of Biden’s fitness for the campaign. What they were given instead was signal after signal that every power broker in the party was behind Biden and confident in his ability to win reelection. Who were they to argue? Biden won the primary contest in a landslide.
In February, after Biden skipped the Super Bowl interview and flubbed the news conference intended to defend his memory, I argued that he should step aside and Democrats should choose a new ticket at the convention. His age had become an insuperable problem — visible in every poll and appearance, omnipresent when you spoke to ordinary voters — and the way his team was insulating him from unscripted interviews reflected a recognition of his diminishment.
Read More
Biden was trailing Donald Trump even then. He was not showing himself capable of the kind of campaign needed to close the gap. And the risk of frailty or illness causing a catastrophe across the long months of the campaign seemed unbearably high.
Everyday vs. elite
The response I got from everyday Democrats was overwhelming — and almost entirely positive. The backlash I got was from Democratic elites, and it was often fierce.I’ve never published anything else for which the gap between regular and elite readers was so vast.
After the debate, the Democratic elites, an informal, disorganized coalition, fractured. With each outing, more top Democrats came to believe he’d lose in November — and that he might not have the capacity to effectively serve a second four-year term even if he won.
They exercised their influence in the ways they can. Calling on Biden to step aside, giving anonymous quotes to reporters, writing opinion essays, withholding donations, organizing petitions, circulating polls.
This was the position of Biden’s critics: Would he win the Democratic primary contest today, given all that Democrats now know? Few believe he would. Polls clearly show that most Americans want Democrats to field a candidate other than Biden and that most Americans believe he is unfit for a second term. The Democratic Party is courting disaster if it does not listen.
This was the position of his backers: Biden won the primaries. There is no mechanism for voters to weigh in yet again. For him to be pushed out by Democratic power brokers would be illegitimate. Polls are broken and the only valid public input is the primary contest he ran in, functionally unopposed, which began months before the debate and the procession of interviews that have so damaged faith in his capabilities.
The truth is that all this talk of elites is one faction of Democratic elites trying to discredit another. It is an elite action aimed at other elites. And that reflects the reality of where the party is right now: It cannot feasibly hold a new primary contest. There is no perfect process to get (or hide) behind.
A diffuse network
There is only this diffuse network of people, with varying levels of power and influence and information, working and arguing under chaotic, uncertain conditions, trying to do the best they can. That’s true on both sides of the Biden divide.
The Democratic Party of 2023 had elites, too. They were less visible because they were unified. All the elected officials were endorsing Biden. All the donors were backing him. All the staff members were certain he would be the nominee.
Now they are fractured, and we are seeing what we should have seen earlier: a genuine debate over the best path forward for the Democratic Party.
Ezra Klein is a columnist for The New York Times, where this article originally appeared. His previous article was “AI will change the world in ways we can't predict, and faster than we know.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.