In July 2023 — be­fore the pri­ma­ries, be­fore last month’s de­bate — a New York Times/​Siena Col­lege poll found that Demo­cratic pri­mary vot­ers, 50% to 45%, pre­ferred that the party nom­i­nate some­one other than Biden in 2024. But the Demo­cratic Party’s elites were in lock­step around Biden.

The fact that he was barely cam­paign­ing or giv­ing un­scripted in­ter­views was ra­tio­nal­ized rather than crit­i­cized. No ma­jor Dem­o­crats de­cided to chal­lenge him for the nom­i­na­tion. Some of this re­flected con­fi­dence in the pres­i­dent. Some of it re­flected the con­se­quences of chal­leng­ing him.

How par­ties work

The White House and the Demo­cratic Party ap­pa­ra­tus it con­trols are pow­er­ful. Con­gres­sio­nal Dem­o­crats will not get their bills pri­or­i­tized or their amend­ments at­tached if they are too crit­i­cal of the party lead­er­ship. Non­profit lead­ers will stop get­ting their calls re­turned. Loyal party do­nors will aban­don you if you’re branded a her­e­tic.

“I would be cru­ci­fied by them if I spoke out of line,” an anon­y­mous Demo­cratic state party chair told NBC News early this month. “I know when you get out of line, they all of a sud­den have a shift of pri­or­i­ties, and your races, your state is no lon­ger on the map.” That was far truer a year ago, when Biden’s po­si­tion in the party was un­chal­lenged.

Advertise with us

This is sim­ply how par­ties work. But it meant that Demo­cratic vot­ers were given nei­ther a real choice of can­di­dates nor a demon­stra­tion of Biden’s fit­ness for the cam­paign. What they were given in­stead was sig­nal af­ter sig­nal that ev­ery power bro­ker in the party was be­hind Biden and con­fi­dent in his abil­ity to win re­elec­tion. Who were they to ar­gue? Biden won the pri­mary con­test in a land­slide.

In Feb­ru­ary, af­ter Biden skipped the Su­per Bowl in­ter­view and flubbed the news con­fer­ence in­tended to de­fend his mem­ory, I ar­gued that he should step aside and Dem­o­crats should choose a new ticket at the con­ven­tion. His age had be­come an in­su­per­a­ble prob­lem — vis­i­ble in ev­ery poll and ap­pear­ance, om­ni­pres­ent when you spoke to or­di­nary vot­ers — and the way his team was in­su­lat­ing him from un­scripted in­ter­views re­flected a rec­og­ni­tion of his di­min­ish­ment.

Biden was trail­ing Don­ald Trump even then. He was not show­ing him­self ca­pa­ble of the kind of cam­paign needed to close the gap. And the risk of frailty or ill­ness caus­ing a ca­tastro­phe across the long months of the cam­paign seemed un­bear­ably high.

Everyday vs. elite

The re­sponse I got from ev­ery­day Dem­o­crats was over­whelm­ing — and al­most en­tirely pos­i­tive. The back­lash I got was from Demo­cratic elites, and it was of­ten fierce.I’ve never pub­lished any­thing else for which the gap be­tween reg­u­lar and elite read­ers was so vast.

After the de­bate, the Demo­cratic elites, an in­for­mal, dis­or­ga­nized co­a­li­tion, frac­tured. With each out­ing, more top Dem­o­crats came to be­lieve he’d lose in No­vem­ber — and that he might not have the ca­pac­ity to ef­fec­tively serve a sec­ond four-year term even if he won.

Advertise with us

They ex­er­cised their in­flu­ence in the ways they can. Calling on Biden to step aside, giv­ing anon­y­mous quotes to re­port­ers, writ­ing opin­ion es­says, with­hold­ing do­na­tions, or­ga­niz­ing pe­ti­tions, cir­cu­lat­ing polls.

This was the po­si­tion of Biden’s crit­ics: Would he win the Demo­cratic pri­mary con­test to­day, given all that Dem­o­crats now know? Few be­lieve he would. Polls clearly show that most Amer­i­cans want Dem­o­crats to field a can­di­date other than Biden and that most Amer­i­cans be­lieve he is un­fit for a sec­ond term. The Demo­cratic Party is court­ing di­sas­ter if it does not lis­ten.

This was the po­si­tion of his back­ers: Biden won the pri­ma­ries. There is no mech­a­nism for vot­ers to weigh in yet again. For him to be pushed out by Demo­cratic power bro­kers would be il­le­git­i­mate. Polls are bro­ken and the only valid pub­lic in­put is the pri­mary con­test he ran in, func­tion­ally un­op­posed, which be­gan months be­fore the de­bate and the pro­ces­sion of in­ter­views that have so dam­aged faith in his ca­pa­bil­i­ties.

The truth is that all this talk of elites is one fac­tion of Demo­cratic elites try­ing to dis­credit an­other. It is an elite ac­tion aimed at other elites. And that re­flects the re­al­ity of where the party is right now: It can­not fea­si­bly hold a new pri­mary con­test. There is no per­fect pro­cess to get (or hide) be­hind.

A dif­fuse net­work

There is only this dif­fuse net­work of peo­ple, with vary­ing lev­els of power and in­flu­ence and in­for­ma­tion, work­ing and ar­gu­ing un­der cha­otic, un­cer­tain con­di­tions, try­ing to do the best they can. That’s true on both sides of the Biden di­vide.

Advertise with us

The Demo­cratic Party of 2023 had elites, too. They were less vis­i­ble be­cause they were uni­fied. All the elected of­fi­cials were en­dors­ing Biden. All the do­nors were back­ing him. All the staff mem­bers were cer­tain he would be the nom­i­nee.

Now they are frac­tured, and we are see­ing what we should have seen ear­lier: a gen­u­ine de­bate over the best path for­ward for the Demo­cratic Party.

Ezra Klein is a columnist for The New York Times, where this article originally appeared. His previous article was “AI will change the world in ways we can't predict, and faster than we know.”